TOWN OF ESSEX — The Essex selectboard voted to approve a final report for the Upper Main Street Planning Project from the contractor, Stantec, at the selectboard’s Monday night meeting.
The project intends to consolidate Essex’s separate, aging facilities, such as the library, fire station and town office — the latter of which is located outside of the actual municipality, and has been since pre-separation — into one municipal complex surrounding a new town office.
Although the selectboard voted four-to-one to accept the final report, about half a dozen residents came Monday night to express concern about the necessity and scale of the project, and the strain they expect it to take on taxpayers who are already hard-pressed financially.
Several residents present said they had not been aware of the project until having read about it in the Reporter’s most recent story on the matter, which outlines some of what was to come in the final report.
The selectboard assured their acceptance of the final report is non-binding for actualizing the project as it’s drafted. Approving any series of bonds to finance the work will be up to the voters. Stantec’s final deliverable was submitted after six months of planning, utilizing public feedback.
Additionally, some points were made about the longer term cost savings of a project like this.
Will Dodge of Essex Energy Committee said while he recognizes the concerns brought up, he doesn’t want the selectboard to lose sight of the opportunity this represents to consolidate all those separate buildings that are currently separately heated with vehicles going back and forth between them, and separate electricity bills, into a single utility-efficient location — particularly if the project utilizes geothermal energy for the complex, as has been proposed.
“Not to smack the dead spider again, but a lot of the buildings, like the public works building, the fire buildings, library, everything, are really undersized and need a lot of work and expense now,” selectboard member Kendall Chamberlin said. “So you're not going to escape costs going forward.”
Per the project scope of the development to come, the report includes a preferred master plan for the entire 32-acre site, concept designs for the fire station, municipal building, library and community center, suggested zoning changes, phasing recommendations, cost estimates and funding options. Municipal building concepts are intended to be considered a preliminary “test fit” for the master plan, and will be further refined in more detailed architectural designs.
Next steps for moving forward the future site development are:
Continue to engage with the public on the master plan, phasing and timing of the site development;
Infrastructure planning;
Request the Vermont Department of Transportation place the roundabout in the project plan on its infrastructure list;
Amending the zoning regulations related to both the Essex Town Center Next Master Plan and the specific recommendations of the Upper Main Street Project Report;
Exploring site development funding options for the site infrastructure and municipal buildings;
Develop detailed architectural designs and programming for the municipal buildings;
The final report for the planning project, now selectboard-approved, will serve to direct staff to further develop a sequencing timeline for the development of the Upper Main Street site.
There is no cost associated with the acceptance of the project report, other than the payment already made to Stantec for its work to this point, though next steps will include expenditures.
The final report itself can be read in full as item B. in Monday night’s meeting packet.
Potential funding sources have been identified, but have yet to be decided upon. Project phasing and the specific development timeline are also yet to be determined.
Before the vote, Dawn Hill-Fleury reiterated an emailed-in question from a resident she said had yet to be answered, about why there are two roundabouts included in the mock-ups for the site.
“That question actually has come up numerous times, so I feel like I have somewhat of an answer ready for you,” Chris Gendron of Stantec said at the meeting. “First off, the piece about the roundabout is something that the public kind of was drawn to, so we showed it.”
“What hasn't happened yet, and this is part of the next phase that needs to happen, is a full on traffic study to see if that's even warranted,” he added.
When Stantec initially met with the Vermont Department of Transportation, VTrans said they couldn’t have full entrance access without a roundabout — left in, left out, right in and right out. They wouldn’t allow just a traditional entrance or a four-way stop, as it would back up traffic.
“So with the approval of this, what’s the next step?” Hill-Fleury asked. “Where do we go from here?”
The development team will continue to engage with the public about the project and its next steps. The selectboard also voted three-to-two Monday to accept a Northern Borders Regional Commission grant to partially finance the Upper Main Street project, particularly the planning and design of water and sewer infrastructure. The grant requires a 50% match.
Going forward, there will be discussions about additional funding options and opportunities.
Internal dissent on the selectboard on the direction of the Main Street project stemmed largely from member Ethan Lawrence’s concerns about the project’s costliness and taxpayer burden.
“I think there needs to be a line drawn somewhere where the town gets to say, are we interested in putting resources into this project? Yes or No,” Lawrence said. “We're going to be looking at getting permitting, applying for and potentially accepting grants to put us in a situation to accumulate debt without first asking the town as a whole if there's interest in this project.”
“I have no issues with the report,” he added. “I think it's very informative for all of us to understand the concept… But the magnitude of what this truly is, and potential benefits and potential costs [is substantial].”
Chamberlin shared some of these concerns and agreed to the importance of ensuring broad, enthusiastic public approval prior to embarking on this journey.
“There's been a number of large projects like this that have not passed,” Chamberlin said. “I’d just like to not go down that road, and find out that we took the wrong road… Public involvement should be a big part of everything.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here