Social-emotional programs at EWSD strive to support students

Posted

ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — In recent years, Americans and Vermonters have watched as mental health supports for students have taken on greater importance in the classroom. 

SEL, or social-emotional learning, is a system that aims to include social and emotional skills in the learning process. Though the term has been around since the 1960s, it has become more mainstream in recent years. 

With Dylan McNamara at the helm of social and emotional learning and wellness at Essex Westford School District, schools have taken a greater role in providing that support for students.

When national research showed the district that SEL supports can lead to improvements in graduation rate, success in postgraduate activities, less substance use and less mental health challenges, McNamara said the district felt the emphasis on SEL was necessary. 

History of social and emotional learning in EWSD

The idea of SEL implementation emerged at EWSD in 2018, following a conversation among district leadership about how to support and empower students most effectively. McNamara told the Reporter district leadership reflected on the district’s vision statement, which states the district is “growing hearts and minds.”

What, McNamara said the district asked themselves, did this vision statement actually mean for students? 

Upon deciding this was an area to focus on, the district began investing funds starting in the 2019-2020 school year toward SEL coaches. These coaches were brought in not only to interact with students, but to provide training to staff to help them support students.

Noticing an impact, McNamara said the district has only increased the number of full-time SEL coaches over the past few years. 

Following the COVID-19 pandemic, the Vermont Agency of Education recommended schools provide SEL resources to students. A 2021 Vermont youth risk behavior survey from the Vermont Department of Health and the AOE found that 26% of Vermont middle schoolers and 29% of high schoolers reported experiencing some poor mental health over a 30-day period.

But EWSD was already ahead of the game, working to support students through the repercussions of isolation, anxiety and other pandemic-era stressors. 

Bringing a task force together, EWSD put together five competencies for students, creating essential standards that differ by grade level for K-12 students. The district breaks it down into self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, relationship skills and responsible decision-making. 

“That’s the work we’ve been doing for the past five or six years,” McNamara said. “Our coaches have been employed to support staff, to potentially help a math teacher understand how they can integrate strategies into their lessons to help kids…To help a literacy teacher identify texts they may use and to also look at how we can structure and organize our school day in a way to support kids.”

The five competencies all seem like important skills. But why is there a need to teach them in EWSD schools?

Staff and student need for programming

McNamara said when SEL implementation was considered back in 2018, the district looked at the fact that some students were struggling to access their own education because of a lack of foundational skills like “emotional regulation, emotional control and behavior regulation.” 

“It was through our discussions and reflection that we felt like, we can have the best lesson, but if they’re not ready to learn, it’s not going to do a lot of good,” he said. 

Providing SEL coaches was one way to alleviate that burden from being placed solely on academic staff. But implementing a new type of curriculum also means adding work to teachers’ already heavy workloads. 

“I think teachers are happy with the resource. I do think there’s a little bit with teachers that there’s a lot on their plate. I think, in theory, they definitely want to support it and I think they believe in it,” he said. “I think, when you’re asking staff to do additional lessons, unless we’ve found ways to give them more time, it’s been hard.” 

That is why, McNamara said, the district tries to build time into teachers’ schedules for SEL training, as opposed to making it an extra class block within a teacher’s day. 

And just as the district felt this implementation could have benefits for staff, McNamara said the national research agreed.

One EWSD-cited source, a 2011 study conducted through the Society for Research in Child Development showed an 11 percentage point increase in students’ emotional and social skills and academic performance after analyzing 213 SEL programs. 

Another 2015 study EWSD took into account found associations between the level of social-emotional skills in Kindergarteners and the outcomes of education, substance use, employment, criminal activity and other factors in their young adulthood. 

With evidence to support their ideas, the district has continued to do work toward implementing these practices. 

Implementation of SEL practices

With ten different schools under EWSD’s purview, it’s not always easy to keep uniform implementation of SEL practices. Yet there are some resources each school can use. 

One such resource is DESSA, a nationally-standardized measure of K-12 students’ social-emotional competencies, including self-awareness, self-management, relationship skills, decision making, optimistic thinking and more. 

Scores on the DESSA are reported in the “strength,” “typical” and “need for instruction” ranges. EWSD has compiled data over the past few years regarding K-8 students’ DESSA scores. 

In the spring of the 2021-2022 school year, EWSD reported 59% of K-8 students who participated in the DESSA to be in the “typical” range. 34% of students were in the “strength” range and 7% of students were in the “need for instruction” range.

In the spring of the 2022-2023 school year, the district reported 61% of K-8 students in the “typical” range, 32% in the “strength” range and 7% in the “need for instruction range.”

In the fall of the 2023-2024 school year, the district reported 69% of K-8 students in the “typical” range, 23% in the “strength” range and 8% in the “need for instruction” range.

Though the number of students in the “need for instruction” range has remained fairly consistent, the number of students in the “strength” range has decreased over the past few years, down 11 percentage points from the spring of 2022 to the fall of 2023. 

Yet the number of students in the strength range has remained relatively consistent; DESSA data from fall of 2023 simply polled more EWSD students than in spring of 2022, increasing the number of students in the “typical” range by 10 percentage points from spring of 2022 to fall of 2023, thus showing slight improvements.

McNamara said the district is working on designing resources for students based on this data.

“We’re now trying to identify, if a kiddo is struggling on the DESSA or a teacher reports there are some kids struggling, then we can have some groups in place or some interventions in place that can support those specific skills. So, our coaches support that type of work,” he said. 

Along with the DESSA, EWSD has adopted a program called Second Step for K-5 students. The program provides instructional materials including media, activities and interactive components for students to learn from their own teachers about what social and emotional wellness looks like.

After three years of implementation in EWSD elementary schools, Second Step is up for renewal. The district will assemble a task force soon to look at how the program has worked in schools and to collect data from teachers to determine if the program should continue. 

McNamara said the district also wants parents to have an idea of how SEL skills are being implemented in the classroom. Because of this, K-8 students’ parents receive progress cards throughout the year of how their children are doing with the SEL programs provided by their teachers.

While the district doesn’t currently send out SEL progress cards to high school students’ households, McNamara said it’s not certain yet whether that will ever happen. With high school students having anywhere from six to eight teachers, though, challenges as to who would be doing what reporting abound.

The future of SEL in EWSD

The district does not have any plans to quit on its SEL programming. For the future, McNamara said it’s all about refining and improving SEL resources put in place to help as many students as possible. 

And in the coming school year, McNamara said the district is also looking at a potential shift to a more integrated model when it comes to school coaches. Instead of having a reading coach as well as an SEL coach, coaching roles may be combined to support staff across different areas.

While part of this potential integrated model is due to cost savings, McNamara also said it may simply be a more effective model. 

“If you’re asking a classroom teacher to meet with three different types of coaches versus one, I think that we’ll get a better bang for our buck with a coach that can support all different things,” he said. 

Yet McNamara also stresses that understanding how best SEL practices can be implemented should not come solely from district leaders. Implementation is an ongoing effort that requires input from everyone involved in education.

“It’s not me and central office saying, ‘Everyone needs to use this program.’ We’re bringing together school counselors, SEL coaches and teachers, and getting teacher feedback around tools to use,” he said.

#ernltop, ewsd, schools, sel coaches, social emotional learning

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here