Separation would decrease taxes for Essex Junction, increase them for town

Posted

ESSEX — If separation comes to fruition in Essex next year, both City of Essex Junction and Town of Essex residents can expect a change in their municipal taxes. 

For future city property owners, the change is almost certain to be a decrease, while residents of the town outside the village (TOV) face a challenging increase. 

That’s all because a plan to merge the two communities failed in April by 27 votes, sending village leaders to go for Plan B — becoming an independent city.

“There are very deep emotions about this,” Town of Essex selectboard chair Andy Watts told the Reporter. “[We’ve] been incredibly impacted by the rapid turn from ‘Let's merge’ to ‘Let's separate.’”

If Essex Junction voters adopt the proposed new charter on Nov. 2, villagers would become city residents and separate themselves from the Town of Essex. That would result in saving those residents money because they no longer would financially support both local governments. 

“Residents can continue to expect the same high level and quality of municipal services and pay less in taxes,” Village President Andrew Brown explained during a public hearing on Oct. 12. 

Trustees say village property owners can expect a 7.25% decrease in municipal taxes under separation because they would no longer be paying for duplicate services from the Town of Essex like parks and recreation and public works. 

For the owner of a $300,000 home, that savings equates to $195 annually. 

“The city would cost approximately $800,000 less than what we are currently paying,” Brown said during the Oct. 12 hearing.

TOV residents, though, would need to make up for a 42% loss in the tax base, according to an analysis by finance director Sarah Macy. 

To compensate for this loss, Watts told the Reporter the TOV will have two choices: a sharp increase in the tax rate or a decrease in services. 

Even if village voters approve of separation next month, the charter still needs to be approved by the Vermont Legislature and eventually the governor. The selectboard, Watts said, is to some degree waiting for that final word from Montpelier to solve its tax problem.

“We’re waiting to see how things flesh out with the Legislature before we talk about the possibility of cuts — the things we might discontinue doing or figure out a different way to do,” he said. 

City: Saving on services

By becoming independent, the village would experience budget savings in 12 of its 19 cost centers — the most significant of those being public works, recreation, fire, library and community development. 

Cost increases, though, would occur in categories like senior services, of which the city would need to create its own, and police. 

The village contributes to the budget of the Essex police department based on its portion of the grand list, which equates to 42% of the entire town of Essex. In the police services contract the trustees are working on with the selectboard, the future city would instead be charged per capita, or 48%. 

This means as an independent city, Essex Junction would spend approximately $400,000 more on police services than it currently does. 

At a public hearing on Sept. 28, a handful of community members expressed concern about the reliability of the tax decrease. 

“Are you close to 100% confident the taxes are going to go down that 7% you are talking about?” Andy Suntup asked. “If you aren’t approaching 99% confidence … it just doesn’t make sense, when it’s one of the only things people really do care about.”

“Speaking for myself, yes, I am 100% certain based on the information that we have that taxes would go down by that amount,” Brown responded. 

Trustee George Tyler followed by emphasizing that the taxes raised would also stay local, within the city, a consideration that he thinks is important. 

Easing transitions for TOV

The selectboard has been working with the village trustees to mitigate the ramp rate of any tax increase by negotiating agreements for shared services. 

If the vote passes and the Legislature takes up the separation conversation next session, the town anticipates being invited to hearings and asked how it will be impacted. 

“That’s a potential additional point of negotiation,” Watts said. 

The town can explain that the merger plan that was posed to voters in March had a 12-year plan for the gradual equalization of tax rates between the village and the TOV. 

“This separation plan makes that shift in taxes much more abrupt,” Watts said.  

In addition to sharing the police department for at least 10 years, the village has asked for four or five years of transitional support from the town finance department. In that case, villagers would continue to pay some portion of the cost for a still-undetermined period of time. 

Because the town expects to soon be asked by the state to conduct a reassessment, the village has agreed to contribute to the budget of the assessor’s office. 

“If [reassessment] starts before the separation actually happens, it's likely to span into a period of time after separation,” Watts said. “We’ll want continuity throughout that whole process.” 

Information technology services will also likely be shared between the two municipalities for some time, and the town is looking to get compensation for that too. 

“Work is going to be required of town employees to enable the village’s transition to a new IT system,” Watts said. 

FURTHER READING

#ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here