Selectboard discusses fairness of its electric fence policy, and legality of proposed barbed wire fence policy

Posted

ESSEX TOWN — The Essex Selectboard held a lengthy discussion on the legality and fairness of regulating electric fences during a public hearing on its Zoning and Subdivision Regulations Sept. 18.

The issue of electric fencing regulations came from the Planning Commission’s proposal to include restrictions of barbed wire fences in the same regulation as the already existing electric fencing regulation.

The proposed change to barbed wire in the Town of Essex stated “Electric and barbed

wire fences are only permitted in the C1, AR and R1 Zoning Districts for agricultural uses purposes unless otherwise exempted by the State.”

Selectboard member Ethan Lawrence spoke up, calling attention to the electric fence regulation and how restrictive this is for a municipality that has a large agricultural community. As the owner of Lawrence Farms, he spoke about his own electric fence, but also in defense of any other resident who would like to utilize one.

“It’s not just me, though, it’s anybody that wants to participate in agriculture in the Town of Essex,” Lawrence said.

Whether electric fencing is used for cows, chickens, bunnies, bees, or any other kind of animal, Lawrence was adamant the Town should not restrict residents' use of it for agricultural purposes.

“I'm just using this as an example not because it's mine, but that fence on Towers Road has been there for longer than [these zoning regulations] have been written,” Lawrence said. “The property has since been subdivided and sold. And at no point did the Town raise a flag about it violating the zoning regulations in the review process.”

This comment called attention to the enforcement issue the Town had. While it prohibited electric fences in certain areas, they were still being used.

“It is up to us in this hearing to figure out how to resolve an enforcement issue,” Selectboard Chair Andy Watts said. 

Selectboard member Dawn Hill-Fleury proposed exempting the existing electric fences from the proposed regulation, but Watts said then the Town would need to identify all of the existing electric fences.

Even if this proposal was possible, Lawrence didn’t support including this regulation with an exception.

“It's not about agriculture, this or that. It's just electric fences. It's banned. It says electric fences are prohibited in all of these districts period,” he said.

The three districts the resolution allows electric fencing in, do make up a large portion of the municipality.

Electric fences could also be utilized to keep things off of properties, such as bears.

During the conversation about electric fencing, Watts realized barbed wire was not something the Selectboard should be regulating, as he said it was not something they fully understand the legality of.

Watts felt a larger discussion needs to be had that is dedicated to barbed wire, and that the electric fence issue needs to be considered by the community development department.

Lawrence proposed changing the language to allow electric fences in the Town of Essex. The Selectboard voted to change the regulation to “Electric fences are only permitted for agricultural uses.”

#essex town, #vermont, #selectboard, #eletric fence, #barbed wire, #ethan lawrence, #ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here