School board drafts contingency bus plan

Posted

By AMANDA BROOKS & COLIN FLANDERS

The Essex Westford School Board has rolled out a new draft of its transportation policy that tells administrators to prioritize busing for youngest students if the district’s ongoing bus driver shortage continues.

The revisions, led by the board’s transportation subcommittee, bolster what administrators say is an overly vague policy directing them to furnish busing to students when “reasonable and necessary,” language out of a model policy from the Vermont School Board Association.

“It was the feeling of the board that that wasn’t providing sufficient guidance for what we wanted to happen for transportation,” said Keeley Schell, an EWSD board member on the transportation subcommittee. “For the most part, what we’ve added is stuff discussing our vision and expectations that endeavors not to prescribe too many details.”

Under the new draft policy, transportation is instead defined as a “privilege” – not required or mandated for “most students.” It codifies previous decisions, like the creation of walking zones, and permits administrators to establish which students can be served by either public transportation or congregated bus stops. Among the factors used to establish routes are:

  • Availability of sidewalks or pedestrian paths
  • Condition and class of highways
  • Traffic speed and density
  • Students’ age, maturity, health and physical ability
  • Route time and distance
  • And any other factors the superintendent deems appropriate.

The policy also says the district must publicize bus schedules by August and compels the superintendent to submit any purchases, leases or contracts over $15,000 for board approval.

Board member Patrick Murray expected to finalize the policy within the next month following last week’s initial reading.

At that same meeting, board members learned the status of their current transportation workforce. According to chief operating officer Brian Donahue, the district has lost and gained five drivers since the start of the fiscal year to hold steady at 18, while six more are working their way through the pipeline. That would bring the district to 24, which Donahue said would allow the district to expand busing into the village.

He said getting full service to the village by December is still possible, but questioned whether starting a new busing routine just before winter break was the right call. Getting full service “as soon as possible” is still administration’s goal, he said.

In an email to The Essex Reporter, Murray said “full service” means all students in the district have access to some form of transportation outside of walking zones. However, this could mean rides on public transportation, not necessarily door-to-door service, he said.

“Rather … we will have stops for all students within established walking distances,” he said, “barring any safety issues or other mitigating circumstances.”

The draft requires creating a contingency plan if the district again loses drivers – a real possibility given that school officials say the issues plaguing their local search show no signs of slowing nationwide. Under the policy, the superintendent will prioritize rides based on grade level, starting with kindergarten, and account for various route factors.

The idea, subcommittee members said, is the youngest students would have the hardest time getting to school without busing because they rely on it more than their older peers. Data from the first several months of the school year shows about half of the student populations at Essex Elementary and Founders Memorial rode the bus while only 35 percent of Essex Middle School students did. That total shrinks to 14 percent for EHS students who live outside the village.

Though much of the draft is aimed at helping administrators run the system as efficiently as possible, one section may actually add bus stops. It says no student can be required to use a congregated bus stop that’s located farther from their house than the walking zone for their corresponding grade level.

Board chairwoman Martha Heath asked how that would play out in Westford, where she said many homes are more than a mile away from the nearest pick-up location. She wondered if anyone asked the bus vendor how viable that plan was, and said it may be better to apply the section to K-8 busing only.

Murray said the subcommittee agreed that while the stipulation may add bus stops in Westford, that fact alone shouldn’t negatively impact students there.

“I don’t see any reason why a Westford high school student should be forced to try to get three miles to the closest stop when we don’t expect that from anyone else in the district,” Murray said.

Board member Brendan Kinney said the subcommittee would explore potential ramifications prior to any vote on the policy.

The brief discussion underscored the policy’s attempt to address a theme central to the school board’s work over the last several years: equity, and what that means across three municipalities, each with unique characteristics.

“That’s the challenge,” Kinney said. “We can’t make things the same, but we need to provide certain equity of access, so things are going to look different from community to community.”

essex westford school board, essex westford school district, ewsd, keeley schell, patrick murray, school bus

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here