ESSEX TOWN — A proposed subdivision and road in Saxon Hill Industrial Park were denied Tuesday by the state’s land use review board.
The District 4 Environmental Commission for the State of Vermont Land Use Review Board rejected the permit on the basis of Act 250 criterion 10, conformance with the Town of Essex’s 2024 town plan.
The town’s planning and zoning regulations prohibit construction on slopes of 20% or steeper. Allen Brook Development submitted the application and appealed the initial decision by the Town of Essex on the basis that “the steep slope provision in the Town Plan is ambiguous and unenforceable.” The commission disagreed with these claims.
Allen Brook Development submitted the proposal, which would have developed 4,100 linear-feet of public roadway leading from Lot 9 to eventually Lot 13, where an Amazon distribution facility had been proposed for.
The Amazon facility was denied by the town’s development review board in July 2025, but representatives later appealed the decision in a separate case to Vermont’s Environmental Court.
Amazon is not party to the Allen Brook Associates case and the court appeal is ongoing. It is unclear how the Act 250 permit denial for the application from Allen Brook Development will impact the development of a potential Amazon facility.
Jared Carter, an attorney who represented the interested parties group ACRES (Alliance of Concerned Residents Envisioning Solutions) said the two developments are related in that the road and subdivision would lead directly to the Amazon facility.
“The road and the subdivision are, in my view, legally and factually speaking, prerequisites for the Amazon facility,” Carter said. “So, if this decision stands at least as currently constructed, there can be no Amazon facility.”
ACRES, made up of Essex area residents, advocated against the development of the Amazon facility and the Allen Brook Development application, citing concerns for traffic and character of the neighborhood.
Peter Gill, executive director of the Land Use Review Board, said there are between 350-400 land use cases each year; of those, approximately 0.2% are denied. Approximately 1-3% of the total number of the land use permit applications reviewed are appealed.
“Roughly one or two every year or two are denied,” Gill said. “So, denials are fairly infrequent.”
The case is currently active. Allen Brook Development has fifteen days to file a motion to alter and 30 days to appeal to the Vermont Environmental Division of Superior Court. In accordance with state statute, the developers could reapply within six months with a revised project addressing any deficiencies.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here