ESSEX TOWN — A proposed subdivision and road in Saxon Hill Industrial Park were denied Tuesday, July 7 for a second time by the state’s land use review board.
Allen Brook Development Incorporated submitted a proposal for 4,100 linear-feet of public roadway through Saxon Hill Industrial Park to the lot where an Amazon facility had previously been denied by the town’s development review board in July 2025.
The District 4 Environmental Commission for the State of Vermont Land Use Review Board rejected the permit on the basis of Act 250 criterion 10, conformance with the Town of Essex 2024 town plan.
The town plan prohibits construction on slopes of 20% or steeper under planning and zoning regulations. The Allen Brook development was denied previously April 7 under the same criterion despite Allen Brook's appeal claiming the regulation was "ambiguous" and "unenforceable."
Robert Rushford of Gravel & Shea PC, representing developers Allen Brook, made a motion to alter the decision April 23. The motion to alter asserted the commission relied on a finding from a prior draft from town documents that “was intended to be deleted” and the town does not regulate man-made slopes from prior development. The motion also argued the steep slopes provision is “not enforceable because they are vague and ambiguous.”
Town Manager Greg Duggan submitted a second motion to alter the decision representing the Town of Essex April 23.
“Our opinion is that operating under this absolute interpretation would be impractical and extremely restrictive,” Duggan wrote in regards to the 20% steep slope criterion.
The Land Use Review Board countered the motion to alter stating the commission did not rely on town approval to make a decision, the criterion states “some development,” and the Town Plan is not ambiguous.
Citizen-run opposing party Alliance of Concerned Residents Envisioning Solutions has asserted the case is “underlying Amazon’s proposed Essex delivery station” because the road provides the necessary infrastructure required to build the facility.
Amazon is not party to the proposed subdivision and road case. It is unclear how the Act 250 denial for the application from Allen Brook will impact the development of a potential Amazon facility.
“This is a win for every small town in America that wants a say in its own future,” Anne Miller, ACRES Vermont co-founder, stated in a press release. “Towns should get to decide whether they want Amazon's logistics network, data centers and other large-scale corporate development — or whether they want to keep building an economy that's rooted here. This decision says a community's plan for itself means something.”
The Town of Essex has currently assembled a task force within the Development Review Board to amend the steep slope criterion. The task force is still in preliminary stages of redefining how and when developers are to use the steep slope criterion.
Allen Brook and the Town of Essex may appeal the July 7 decision to the Environmental Division of Vermont Superior Court within 30 days. ACRES said they are “preparing” for legal action to come.
The decision can be viewed on the Act 250 Land Use Review database here.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here