Recreation district nears judgment day

Posted

A who’s who of Essex civil servants filed into the town offices Monday evening to discuss the progress of the proposed recreation district.

Up for discussion was the recreation governance study committee’s date of dissolution, the potential fallout from a no vote and the proposal to phase in tax equalization.

The joint meeting, between the selectboard, board of trustees and the prudential committee, comes nearly eight months after the two municipal boards created the RGSC.

Since voting to pursue a merger between Essex’s two recreation departments into a union municipal district, the RGSC has met 15 times, including two public forums. It has also released two informational videos, answered more than 20 FAQs on its website and provided a prospective budget.

RGSC chairman Michael Smith said the committee will continue its work until the vote in December, including four more public forums. The next set for Thursday at 6:15 p.m.

Some town residents, like selectboard member Irene Wrenner, felt the committee is overstepping its charge.

“According to statute, their work is over,” Wrenner said.

“If the selectboard wants to allow this committee to meet, using town resources — town lights, town heat, town building — that’s great,” she continued. “But why not open it up a little bit more [to new members] … because it’s no longer the committee we appointed.”

State law says joint survey committees like the RGSC have the power to “provide for the distribution of information resulting from such surveys, studies and programs.”

Those opposed to the plan have had ample opportunity to share their opinion, village president George Tyler said.

“I don’t think anyone’s speech has been stifled at all,” he said. “It’s been robust.”

Tyler also explained the rationale behind the trustees’ resolution.

The resolution states the trustees will work with the prudential committee to transfer Essex Jct. Parks and Recreation over to the village in the event of a no vote. They’ll then explore finance and governance models to maintain EJRP’s budget separate from the village general fund.

Tyler said although it seems like an “obvious solution” to consolidate EJRP under the town, doing so right after the trustees assured the prudential committee they would assume oversight “wouldn’t have been appropriate.”

“It would have tarnished our integrity,” he said.

Tyler also addressed concerns from residents who felt the board’s resolution was an unfair ultimatum.

Consolidation isn’t “totally off the table,” he said, “but I think we’re trying to depoliticize this as much as possible.”

Perhaps the most significant discussion for residents is the plan to phase in the tax increases for town voters. The plan would incrementally increase taxes in the town over five years instead of one large increase. The trustees supported the plan in their resolution last month.

Voters got their first look at how it might work via a prospective budget at the first two public forums.

In fiscal year 2018, owners of a $280,000 home could expect a $103 bill in the town outside the village, a $16 increase from the current year.

Village homeowners could expect a $269 bill, representing an $11 decrease.

The budget assumes the village phases down its additional recreation support, starting with cutting 5 cents in the first year and reducing by 1 cent each year.

The next four years would result in annual $12 increases for town residents until support equalized at $163 in FY23. At the end, village residents would see a $116 decrease from current recreation taxes, while town residents would see a $76 increase.

RGSC member Jason DiRosa is opposed to the plan. Village voters would still pay extra in the first four years, he said, without reaping the benefits, like having first choice in recreation programs.

Unified school board and prudential committee member Marla Durham disagreed. She said the plan shows a “spirit of cooperation between the two communities.”

The plan would ultimately need approval from the recreation board, which will be elected at the Dec. 13 vote. Though that date has been discussed for months now, it’s not official until the two boards agree to warn the vote.

The trustees unanimously voted on Monday to place the item on its Nov. 8 agenda. The selectboard also agreed to discuss the warning at its Nov. 7 meeting with a 4-1 vote. Wrenner had the lone dissenting vote.

district, essex, essex reporter, forum, irene wrenner, meeting, recreation

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here