Rec directors’ letter causes stir

Posted

A letter from Essex’s two recreation directors has led to some residents alleging a violation of the town’s communications policy just days before voters hit the polls to judge a proposal to merge the departments.

The letter, penned by Brad Luck, director of Essex Jct. Recreation and Parks, and Ally Vile, director of Essex Parks and Recreation, was emailed last week to all addresses on file with the two departments.

“We support the formation of a recreation district between the town and village.  It is time to become one,” the letter reads.

Residents later learned their email addresses would be made public because residents made public records requests for the list used by Luck and Vile to distribute the letter.

As a result, residents may receive emails from third parties, Vile wrote in a subsequent email to residents obtained by The Reporter.

Essex resident RaMona Sheppard made one of the records requests. She said Tuesday, the day of the vote, she wanted to see why she and her husband, John, were on the list.

Sheppard is one of a number of residents alleging Luck and Vile’s letter constituted a breach in the town’s communications policy. She was shocked to see the department heads use their position to advocate in an election, calling it “inappropriate.”

Sheppard said she made formal complaints to both the town and the Chittenden Central Supervisory Union, which oversees EJRP.

Reached Tuesday afternoon, joint municipal manager Pat Scheidel said the matter was turned over to legal counsel to investigate whether there were any violations on the town’s side.

Multiple attempts to reach Vile were unsuccessful.

School employees can engage in political activity as long as it doesn’t affect their professional performance in a “demonstrably deleterious manner,” CCSU’s conflict of interest policy says.

The policy adds any such employees “will make it clear they are speaking and acting as individuals” and don’t represent the school district.

Luck, a CCSU employee, declined to comment on the matter.

A handful of residents said they appreciated the directors’ efforts to inform the community, posting the praise in an Essex Facebook group.

Some weren’t as impressed, however, taking to Front Porch Forum to air their frustrations.

“I find it disturbing that my email address on file with them has been used to try to sway my vote,” Lynn Smith wrote.

Brian Cuseo wrote he was disappointed to learn his email was now in the hands of an unknown entity because of the recreation directors’ actions.

He asked for whoever requested the emails to respect privacy and “destroy it without sending unsolicited political content.”

“Your neighbors did not submit their emails to the town to get political information. Instead, we just wanted to be reminded when to pay $10 to renew our Indian Brook pass,” he wrote.

After receiving the list, Sheppard admits she considered sending a mass-email encouraging a no vote but decided against it. She has no plans to do anything further with the list, she said.

Though Sheppard voiced her displeasure with the proposal at a handful of selectboard meetings throughout the summer, she stopped showing up in September. In a letter to the board, she explained why.

“I am no longer comfortable going to meetings in such adversarial surroundings. Life is too short to fill so many evenings in such toxic environments,” her letter read.

Sheppard’s opposition continued behind the scenes, however, including numerous posts on Front Porch Forum and letters sent to The Reporter.

She can’t recall another issue as charged in her nearly 20 years in Essex, she said, and wasn’t quite sure what about recreation spurred the debate.

essex, essex jct., essex reporter, letter, recreation

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here