Public urges town to decline any future settlement offer in Amazon court case

Posted

ESSEX TOWN— At a special meeting Nov. 10, the Town of Essex selectboard addressed the ongoing legal battle with Amazon over a proposed distribution facility in town. 

Late this past summer, Amazon’s contractors appealed to Vermont Environmental Court the Development Review Board’s denial of their application to build a distribution center in Essex. 

Pretrial proceedings began Oct. 13, and it's expected not to have a resolution for many months. 

“I know I also did say the board will not be discussing this,” said selectboard chair Tracey Delphia, to open this part of the meeting. “It's not warned for action. It’s not warned for discussion either. This is an ongoing legal matter, so the selectboard will not be commenting on this.” 

“However,” she added. “Understanding that there are folks here who likely want to provide public comment, I will open this up for public comment.” 

Delphia allowed the gathered crowd 30 minutes to share their opinions on the matter. Many folks had shown up to petition the Town of Essex not to settle and to see the court case through to the end. 

“A lot of us are concerned the town of Essex is not going to continue fighting,” Joanna Grossman of Phoenix Books said. “That's what we want to hear, is that you're going to continue to defend your appointed DRB, which decided against permitting Amazon to build this facility.” 

The DRB denied the application due to what it stated was “incomplete” and “contradictory” information about the facility’s impact to local traffic. 

Points from the public 

If built, the Amazon facility would have a 70-mile same-day delivery radius, Grossman said, which would undermine one of the few operational advantages Phoenix Books has over Amazon: people’s ability to show up same-day to get a book. 

With the loss of a lot of federal dollars being reinvested into the local scene, means a loss of small business grants and funding for the state’s nonprofit sector, which is why Grossman believes it’s all the more important right now to be shoring up the local Vermont economy. 

“Local businesses are paying into this system, and we're also supporting the Essex Pride Festival, our local Little League teams and all that stuff,” she said. “We're asking you as local businesses to support us and to help us and give us a leg up so we can continue supporting you. It really means a lot to us.” 

Essex resident Gil Allen also spoke, to express support for Grossman’s take, and to address the selectboard’s role in future steps. 

“Maybe the reason people brought this to an item of discussion is that the ongoing battle in Environmental Court could lose its support from the selectboard,” Allen said. 

“And that’s not what I was hearing, by the way you framed this in your diction earlier,” he said. “That basically it's off the table for the selectboard, that this is a matter that is being handled in Environmental Court and will be settled in Environmental Court. Is that what we're hearing?” 

To this, Delphia said, she would think Allen’s framing of the matter to be correct, unless future direction from the judge involved in this case changes circumstances — noting also that she can’t predict what the courts or judge will or will not do. 

Town Manager Greg Duggan said the town attorney has made appearances at court on behalf of the town, and that the town’s approach in court is simply to monitor the proceedings solely to ensure its zoning regulations are understood and interpreted as the town feels they should be interpreted, and that the court and judge can take it into consideration while hearing this case. 

“I think I want to reinforce where people are maybe feeling a bit edgy or nervous about this, in that the DRB made it very clear that the request of Amazon was to provide a study, a proper study, on the impact on local traffic of this distribution center,” Allen said. 

Allen pointed out that any company deserves a thorough vetting process of the impact on local traffic and in this case, what it will do on a two-lane highway with some already “pretty sketchy” left-hand turns coming out of Skunk Hollow Road. 

“And they basically flat-out refused to provide that,” he said. 

“We just need to let this play out in the Environmental Court and see where it goes from there, because I think the vast majority of our citizens want to see how this plays out in that court, because they know they're being stonewalled,” he added. “We are all being stonewalled.” 

Town resident Brian Clifford echoed what had been said by the speakers before him and expressed some concern around whether the town is standing its ground, also noting folks will need to get used to more closed executive sessions for the purpose of briefing elected officials on the latest from Amazon’s lawyers — a topic other individuals at the meeting expressed ethical frustration with, given its prevalence to the public. 

But especially, he warned his neighbors Amazon has the lawyers and budget to wage on. 

“We simply want them to go away, but it's apparently more important for them to prove that they can set up shop anywhere they want, than to respect our consent and to move along to another town that is begging for them to come,” Clifford said. “That’s a red flag.” 

“We've already heard Amazon officials saying we can't stop them because they're here anyway,” he added. “These are just bullies. And I feel like if anybody listening to me right now has the power to stand up to them, please do so, because it's going to get increasingly difficult to do so in the future.” 

Town resident Anne Miller told the selectboard the question she hears most often as someone who’s followed the Amazon saga closely, is whether or not the case is going to be settled. 

“My understanding is that, because it's in Environmental Court, the case will be decided in environmental court, but it's not as though the parties can settle, because there are litigants in the case who are not willing to settle,” she said. “So even if the town wanted to settle, and Amazon wanted to settle, the other litigants in the case do not want to settle.” 

“So the case will need to go through the court system and have a decision, whatever that decision is,” she added. “The best thing that we can do as a town is to support that DRB decision. It matters to not undercut the people who need to feel like the whole process works.”

Sharon Zukowski, who serves on the DRB, asked why the town was saying all its attorney is doing is passively “monitoring” the case, as opposed to actively defending the DRB’s decision, questioning whether the choice of words was semantic in nature, to which she got no response. 

Town resident Lorraine Zaloom spoke to express support for the DRB’s decision and reasoning, given the issues around infrastructure and property tax spikes to come with building up in a way not aligned with other economic considerations. 

As a member of ACRES, a group of interested parties who cross-appealed the court case, Zaloom also expressed a desire for a stronger letter of support from staff for her organization. 

Elizabeth and Keith Dunbar of Essex said they attended the DRB meetings, wrote emails and applauded the hard-fought, courageous decision of the DRB in their vote against Amazon’s build, and expressed a hope that the selectboard and town legal team continues to support the DRB and Essex’s town plan. 

Four other residents wanting to preserve the “Vermonty” feel or otherwise hope the selectboard supports the DRB decision, one of whom had a particular concern about the increase to air pollution likely with added trucks and the cascading effects it might have on public health. 

Non-residents at the meeting expressed concern that with Amazon, jobs will vanish, automation will rise, and community members will pay the price of taking short-term gains with long-term costs, stressing the importance that Vermont can choose differently and set itself apart by leading with a vision of investing in people, communities and lasting futures. 

Chittenden County business owners just outside of Essex spoke more to the effect of what Grossman had to say — Bill Calfee, an area business owner, pointed out that small business people are neighbors with limited resources who support nonprofits and rescue squads, as well as local housing development and municipal costs, through real estate taxes — which Amazon tends to pay very few of. Calfee advocated for thoughtful decision-making to keep Vermont’s economic activity circulating in the small, independent, local business sector. 

Other Essex-based business owners said they don’t mind outsiders generally but that they care about how wealth gets circulated and the town plan’s emphasis on creating and sustaining local businesses, economic diversity, and a sustainable working landscape for all. 

One of the final speakers on this segment was Essex resident and ACRES member Duane Barlow, who expressed confusion about the intended response to Zukowski’s question of whether there is a difference between defending and monitoring a court case. 

“I thought that there was a very significant difference between those… Not semantic,” Barlow said. “One, the town isn't really spending money on the lawyer. The lawyer isn't actually doing a lot in court, but just sort of an independent observer. [From what you’ve said,] I thought that was what the town was doing, and that's ery different from actively defending in court, is it not?” 

To this, Delphia provided the answer she’d been giving all night. 

“We will not be commenting on in-process legal matters,” she said. “Essex is represented by its town attorneys. The town attorneys have been, have made appearances in this case, and they are working to ensure that our zoning regulations are properly interpreted by the court.” 

“I believe it's semantic,” she added. “But that's my interpretation and my own opinion.” 

Barlow asked again why everything he’s heard from town representatives has left out the fact that the town has the ability to negotiate or theoretically settle out of court, if it so chooses. 

“That certainly wouldn't stop the litigation from moving forward, but it could undermine it,” Barlow said. “And so I think it's important to clarify that the town has the ability to settle with Scannell slash Amazon in this, and it's not simply at the state level. Can you confirm that?” 

Again, Delphia reiterated that the selectboard will not comment on in-process legal matters. 

“No, no,” Barlow said. “This is just a general question. Towns have the ability to settle, as has happened in the past within this town — that should be mentioned as a fact. It also is important for people to know that that wouldn't stop the case from going, but it could undermine it.” 

“We're asking and we're all here because we understand that there could be the potential for Amazon to ask the town to agree to some settlement, and we just think that there's no upside, for the town,” he added. “You would just lose your voice in the case — and if the ACRES wins the defense, you just lose political points because the selectboard sort of backed out of it.” 

“No matter which way you cut it, there's no upside,” he said. 

Some information from the courts about the status of the case is available here.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here