Public meeting goes private: Tensions high as Amazon meetings continue, DRB requests modified traffic study

Posted

Editor's note: This story was updated July 2 at 4:50 p.m. to contextualize the nature of the traffic study and to correct the host-location of a previous DRB meeting from March that is mentioned. 

ESSEX TOWN — The Development Review Board has requested a new-and-improved traffic study from an applicant hoping to develop a distribution facility for Amazon in Saxon Hill Forest. 

Prior to this most recent meeting, an amended traffic study was recommended by an independent peer reviewer, Stantec. The applicant conducted the additional study, but the DRB didn’t have time to review it pre-meeting, as it was submitted after the agenda packet was published — so, the DRB requested further review of that analysis for their next meeting. 

The DRB also asked for comparables from similar sites to inform its decision, but the applicant believes after the DRB and staff has a chance to review their study, the board's concerns would be addressed. 

The traffic study discussion followed a private deliberative session behind closed doors took up the latter portion of last night’s DRB meeting — the full meeting run-time being 6:30-10:30 p.m. 

Though it seems many steps remain on Amazon’s road to possible project approval, not without its hiccups, the previously-forested site near a recreation area is zoned for industrial use and is being evaluated to potentially become host to the first-ever facility in Vermont used by the billionaire-owned megacorporation. 

And for countless reasons — from noise and environmental pollution to a lack of harmony with the surrounding area, to concerns about labor rights, endangered species, small businesses, public health and everything in between — the locals aren’t happy about it. 

Last night was the first time in this series since the initial meeting pertaining to Amazon in March to be held in the DRB’s usual meeting spot at the Town Office, as opposed to the larger Essex High School cafeteria they’d borrowed previously, for its enhanced crowd capacity — leaving some in-person attendees last night without seats in the back or even spilling out into the hall. 

It was also the first time in the series the DRB sought private refuge away from its own residents to discuss the topic off-record, leaving behind nearly 60 people in the room and nearly 40 online. 

The reasoning? An assumption of bad-faith engagement on the part of the citizens they serve. 

Private deliberations 

DRB member Dustin Bruso was the first to suggest the deliberative session be held privately, though most of the board agreed and all for all of the same reasons. 

“I am in favor of a [private] session because I think it is a hot topic that we will not be able to have an open conversation with the board without interruption, and I think that that is very necessary with this application,” said clerk Stephanie Bixby. “I've never seen anything like this.” 

For the most part, disruptions by members of the public occurred only to point out perceived injustices or hypocrisies in the proceedings, and never without a prompt, organic return order. 

DRB member Hubie Norton was the most outspoken against the move to go private. 

“I don't think you need to go into a deliberative session yet,” he said. “I would much prefer to talk about this out in the open.” 

Norton, Nick Martin and Trefor Williams all dissented the vote to close the public out of their talk, but were beaten out by the other four DRB members. 

The idea was floated to continue public comment for the remainder of the meeting, though that, too, was shot down, given the amount of time the board has allotted to public comment already. 

“At some point, we have to wrangle what we’re dealing with and come to a conclusion,” said DRB chair Ian Carroll. “I’m feeling like we could just go on forever if we want to have a public comment about the rights or wrongs of this application indefinitely.” 

Allegations of “disrespect” were thrown from the DRB table at the crowd and then back again, just before the board whisked itself away for the hour that followed. Most attendees stayed to await its return. Some brought pizza, snacks and seltzers to share with hungry, tired neighbors. 

One resident in the room, Mary Post, suggested hooking a microphone broadcast from the private room to the main meeting room — which had by this point become a glorified waiting room. 

“I worry about the Open Meeting Law,” she told the Reporter, suggesting a solution. “We would be able to hear how their brains are thinking by having it brought into this room, mic’d to this room, so we could listen. We're not able to interrupt them, because we're not physically there.” 

“We have the right to have the right to hear that, I think,” she said. “This is downright wrong.” 

The idea was not heard by the board, let alone taken up. 

Though the move to turn a public meeting into a private one is legal for quasi-judicial boards such as the DRB, the ethics of the move were questioned and criticized by many in attendance who felt a vested public interest in the application, given the impacts to quality of life neighbors anticipate. 

Ken Signarello, who chairs the town’s conservation and trails committee, told the Reporter he views the decision to continue the meeting behind closed doors as “foolish.” 

“I’m on two committees, I can understand their desire to do that,” he said, then presenting a similar idea to Post’s. “I think what might’ve been a good compromise would have been going into the deliberative session in the other room with the Owl [360-degree conference camera].” 

Beyond the way the night had unfolded with regard to the deliberative session, Signarello also mentioned his committee’s advice has been misrepresented in public meeting materials and staff reports multiple times, even after he submitted corrections, with respect to the site’s buffer. 

Staff wrote the committee had advised relandscaping the buffer region and waiving existing buffer requirements for the project, reducing the amount of square footage required. In reality, the committee never advised in favor of a waiver, and had favored a fuller reforestation. 

“I reported that error previously and they still didn’t fix it,” he said. “It’s totally contradictory.” 

There was no shortage of people in attendance who were frustrated with the private meeting. 

“What I don't like about it is the fact that they're making all of us wait, and a lot of us are elderly and don't like to drive at night,” said Essex resident Betsy Dunn, during that private portion of the meeting. “If they come back, we don't even know if they're going to have a public hearing.” 

“I would think if they decided not to, that would be pretty bad, because there's a lot of people here waiting for them, but who knows how long it's going to take,” she added. “It would have been better for them to say, ‘Let's finish the public hearing, in all fairness to the public, and then close it, and then we can choose a different time to have the deliberation.’” 

The one conclusion reached during the private deliberation was the request for further traffic study materials, and with that came a necessary re-opening of the public hearing they’d just closed, due to additional yet-to-be-reviewed submissions from Amazon, and the new request. 

However, public comment did not re-open that night — it will be at the next available meeting. 

Community context 

Just before this meeting, a local coalition of Essex community members formed a new nonprofit, launched June 25 — the Alliance of Concerned Residents Envisioning Solutions, which aptly abbreviates to ACRES, a call-back to the forest many neighbors of the area know and love. 

The organization was established to “ensure community voices are considered in decisions shaping Essex’s future,” according to a recent press release. 

The group supports growth that maintains the town’s character, safeguards public health and safety and aligns with the Essex Town Plan — a document encapsulating a shared vision for the town, which entails details many have pointed out as inconsistent with the contrary values and actions a company like Amazon would bring to town. 

In addition to supporting the belief that all development should follow the town’s plan for balanced, environmentally responsible growth, ACRES also supports the preservation of rural and scenic qualities, minimizing noise and air pollution, and notes that town zoning regulations require new developments to adequately protect the public health, safety and resident welfare. 

The group emphasizes a need to consider the impacts of new development on schools, emergency services, pedestrians and cyclists, and the adequacy of the infrastructure. It also highlights environmental risks of erosion and flooding from adding impermeable surfaces and removing forested buffers, waiving buffer requirements and increasing contaminated runoff. 

The group supports new development in town consistent with the adopted Zoning Regulations, including those for the Resource Preservation District — albeit, a section legally zoned for industrial use — within which Amazon’s partner, Scannell Properties, has applied to build. 

ACRES advocates to preserve floodplains, wetlands, essential plant species and to protect animal habitats all of which are threatened by development. The citizens involved in the group now have legal representation from an attorney based out of Bristol, Vt., James Dumont. 

Dumont posited at the meeting that his clients deserved not just the opportunity to comment as individual members of the public, but to demand an equal right to testify, with as much a seat at the discussion table as the applicant and its partner, Scannell and Amazon. 

He holds that his clients are “interested persons,” pursuant to the law, as several live adjacent to the proposed project site, will be directly impacted by its noise and air pollutants and will suffer traffic safety impacts and congestion impacts as pedestrians, cyclists and drivers. 

“We are not a court of law,” Carroll said to Dumont’s request for time outside of public comment. “I appreciate the time you're asking for this. If you would like to make this case further, I suggest that you contact [town] staff, and if staff need to reach out to legal… [they will].” 

Carroll noted during the meeting that some citizen concerns would be better addressed during other, later portions of the permitting process under other bodies, such as the Act 250 review. 

In addition to representing ACRES as a nonprofit group, Dumont also represents Essex residents Lisa Allen, Logan Allen, Duane Barlow, Fina Barrett, Natalee Braun, Lee Bryan, Brian Clifford, Patty Davis, Betsy Dunn, Lisa Goodrich, John Hill, Tom Jaros, Robert Lalancette, Anne Miller, Bruce Post, Mary Post, David Skopin, Missie Thurston, Cheryl Van Epps, Taylor Wagner, Lois Whitmore, David Whitmore and Lorraine Zaloom, in countering this site application. 

Also new since last meeting, Phoenix Books has launched a public campaign @phoenixrisingvt on Instagram, “supporting Vermont” and “fighting back” against the corporate behemoth. Phoenix Books is a small Vermont-based bookseller with a location in Essex Town.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here