Police chief: Gun regs need update

Posted

The rules around gun use in Essex are due for a change.

That’s the conclusion of Police Chief Brad LaRose after the selectboard sought a detailed opinion following a shooting incident last December when a Deer Crossing Lane resident found a rifle bullet lodged in a wall of his home.

The Essex firearms ordinance, which maps areas of town where shooting is prohibited, was last updated in 1998.

Since then, the town’s population has grown by about 2,000, and residential development has increased in areas where shooting is allowed. In 2008, Old Stage Road resident John Reiss was killed when a stray bullet entered his home from a neighboring backyard shooting range.

The death sparked a similar selectboard-directed reconsideration of the firearms ordinance. A citizen task force recommended modest enhancements to the ordinance in 2009, but the board never took them up.

The current board, which has three new members since then, received LaRose’s report at its Sept. 12 meeting but did not discuss it.

“The growth and development in some areas has extended into, and adjacent to, areas of the town where shooting is authorized,” LaRose wrote. “The probability of a fired projectile striking a person or property has increased significantly.”

Currently, shooting is prohibited throughout the Village of Essex Jct. and in some of the more densely populated areas of Essex Town.

“The safest approach would be to prohibit the discharge of firearms completely,” LaRose said. The town should at least add no-shooting zones to the popular recreation areas around Indian Brook Reservoir and in the Saxon Hill Forest, he said.

“There are trails there and plans for expansion,” he said of Saxon Hill. “I just don’t see how it’s safe to discharge firearms in that area.”

Indian Brook currently has a 500-foot safety zone around the reservoir that is defined in the park ordinance but is not mentioned in the firearms ordinance.

LaRose pointed out the hiking trails around the reservoir extend beyond the 500-foot no-shooting zone and recommended that the zone be extended to encompass the whole park.

A more nuanced approach would be to ban rifle shooting and allow only shotgun and pistol shooting in areas where shooting is allowed. This would reduce the range of bullets fired from 3-plus miles for rifles to less than 6,600 feet, according to LaRose.

“Some adjustments could be made that would make things safer,” said Adam Stein, an Essex hunter and target shooter who served on the 2009 task force.

Stein said towns in his native New York employ a shotgun-only approach.

“I don’t want that, but it seems to work,” he said.

“There is no easy answer unless you ban [shooting],” he continued. “That’s the easy answer, but that’s not fair … There are a lot of people who do shoot and shoot safely.”

What’s needed most, Stein said, is a designated, public target range. During the 2009 investigation, the Vermont Department of Fish and Wildlife offered to set one up and manage it to reduce the likelihood of a recurrence of the Reiss tragedy, which stemmed from a makeshift backyard range.

“I can’t believe how difficult it is to go find a place to shoot,” Stein said.

Town’s attorney Andrew Bolduc said the town has no authority to regulate existing “sport shooting ranges.” Whether that exclusion covers private, backyard ranges is an unsettled area of law, he said.

“Ultimately, any expansion of the no-discharge area of the town is clearly allowed by Vermont statute,” Bolduc wrote in an Aug. 23 email to LaRose. “A legal issue would likely arise … after the adoption of the ordinance and during enforcement taken by the municipality on any owner or participant of a range it determents does not fit the definition of ‘sport shooting range.’”

LaRose said existing private ranges, even within the no-shooting zone, are beyond the town’s authority. The town could only prohibit new private ranges within the no-shooting area.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here