The Town of Essex will allow commercial scale wind farms and solar arrays in its commercial and industrial zones, provided they have no impact on the town’s most scenic vistas, according to a Nov. 1 submittal to the Chittenden County Regional Planning Commission.
The CCRPC is developing a countywide map of where renewable energy projects can and cannot be sited in response to Act 174. Passed last year, the legislation gives localities greater say in energy project applications in front of the Vermont Public Service Board. The CCRPC is requesting input from the county’s municipalities as it develops its map.
Last week, the Essex Planning Commission approved the Nov. 1 memo from Essex community development director Dana Hanley. The memo refers to the town plan, updated earlier this year, saying the town supports commercial-scale wind and solar development in commercial/industrial zones, defining commercial scale as greater than 500 kilowatts of generation.
Hanley noted the commercial/industrial zone boundaries in the Saxon Hill Forest are subject to change under the outline of an agreement the town recently reached with the Saxon Hill Forest landowner. The agreement won’t be finalized, however, until a land use review under Act 250.
Any project “shall have zero impact on views identified as ‘most scenic’ in the town plan,” the memo states. The town’s most scenic views were inventoried in a 2009 “Scenic Protection Manual” developed by Smart Growth Vermont.
A patchwork of commercial/industrial parcels — two near the Jericho town line, one along the Winooski River banks south of River Road and another abutting the Colchester behind Fort Ethan Allen — are developable without regard to scenic vistas, according to the memo.
The memo also states that non-commercial-scale projects — those generating less than 500 kW — are allowed in all other zoning districts.
Under guidance from the state, the CCRPC will exclude flood zones, river corridors, federal wilderness, rare and irreplaceable natural areas, vernal pools and wetlands from renewable energy consideration. It also considers agricultural soils, conserved lands and deer wintering habitats not preferred as energy sites.
“Conserved land may not always be inappropriate for renewable energy development,” Hanley wrote. “However, some conserved land may be so sensitive with regard to views, public recreational use and natural resources that renewable energy development should be prohibited.”
Hanley also suggests incentives to increase rooftop arrays, rather than using undeveloped land, for solar generation as the state pursues a goal of getting 90 percent of its energy from renewable sources by 2050.
Hanley’s submittal applies only to the town outside the village of Essex Jct. Village development director Robin Pierce weighed in with an Oct. 28 letter, bypassing input to the CCRPC and addressing Department of Public Service commissioner Christopher Recchia directly.
Pierce skewered the idea of harvesting renewable energy on undeveloped land and instead urged small-scale projects in developed areas. Such an approach would keep the energy generated local rather than transmitting it to the statewide grid. It would also be in keeping with “the Vermont brand,” Pierce wrote.
“It would be more than ironic if we despoiled the Vermont brand in a rush to add renewable energy to our list of achievements,” Pierce wrote. “We don’t think the two are mutually exclusive. But, we do need to insure that when we make renewable energy decisions, they are compatible with our brand.”
Pierce said the PSB should review each renewable energy proposal first on whether it is compatible with the development pattern of compact villages surrounded by open, productive farmland. He suggested artful wind turbines and rooftop solar arrays.
“We should be right-sizing renewable energy installations so that they produce the energy needed for the place they are in,” Pierce wrote. “The optimal site for energy production should not be the deciding factor … Looking back, we would be proud to think the way we moved our renewable energy future forward is a model for others, rather than a warning of what not to do.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here