ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — Each year the school board proposes a new budget for the Essex-Westford communities to vote on, drawing sighs from some frustrated taxpayers.
From paying the electricity bills to funding district administrative support services, the budget has expenses that can be difficult to understand.
With the complicated nature of how education funding works in Vermont, EWSD chief operations officer Brian Donahue and director of finance Heather Bushey — two experts in the budget process — understand how voters can get frustrated by the process.
“I came in responsible for building budgets,” Donahue said. “I, right away, just couldn't wrap my head around the line item detail telling me anything.”
When Donahue joined the district 23 years ago, it was still using giant binders filled with endless tables. This past budget season, Donahue explained EWSD’s $90.7 million budget with a slideshow presentation and infographics that broke down the information.
But for those unfamiliar with the process, this still amounts to a bunch of numbers.
“The hardest part is ‘what percentage do you want to talk about’ because I'm constantly saying ‘budget’s going up eight, our cost per pupil is going down three, our tax rate is going…and it sounds like I'm trying to confuse people,” Donahue said.
Public education in Vermont is not funded solely by individual communities, and it hasn’t been since 1997 with the creation of Act 60, the equal opportunity act.
When EWSD voters approve the budget, it’s paid entirely by the state education fund, which is financed by property taxes (homestead and non-homestead) and Vermont’s sales and use tax.
Non-homestead education property tax is paid, for example, by landlords, property investors and owners of second homes and commercial spaces. It is the largest contributor to the state’s education fund.
The homestead education property tax is what Vermont homeowners pay for education, though most Vermonters pay this tax based on their income, not their property value. The Vermont Property Tax Credit assists Vermont homeowners with their taxes.
Because of this, the first thing to keep in mind during the school budget process is, your taxes are not the only thing funding the budget.
“That's a big misconception, [someone asking] ‘Well, wait a minute, my son’s bus was canceled last Tuesday. So am I getting a refund?’ and that kind of stuff. Sorry, folks, we're working on a much bigger common goods statewide basis,” Donahue said.
The second thing to keep in mind is a budget increase does not necessarily mean a tax rate increase.
“That was a big realization for me coming in. I thought ‘budget goes up, taxes go up,’” Bushey said. “So the first year when we were doing the budget where the budget went up, and the taxes went down, I was like, wait, how can that be?”
Or, in a more frustrating case, there can be a zero percent budget increase, but due to the common level of appraisal, taxes still go up. This happened one year in Westford where the budget went down 8%, but the taxes went up.
“And they said ‘you don't want us to cut anymore [of the budget]. You really don't. You'd rather reappraise right now but then have us cut,’” Donahue said.
Essex and Essex Junction are currently going through the reappraisal process, which won’t have an effect on homeowners for at least another year.
With all of these different aspects determining how the budget is created and how residents of the district are taxed, the impulse is to focus on one number, or one aspect to explain everything to those who don’t understand.
“I think focusing on just one thing over simplifies it,” Bushey said.
For example, if the district only focused on getting the budget number across to voters, the nuance of how taxes will be affected is lost.
But what do those expenditures mean? What does “instructional support services” actually look like? While not all money going into the budget is from the individual taxpayers, a portion of those line items is from EWSD residents. How is it being spent?
The Essex Reporter took photos that bring faces and visuals to the expenses in the budget below.
Direct instruction: activities directly relating to teachers and students inside and outside of the classroom, activities of aids and classroom assistants, and athletics and co-curricular activities.
Student support services: includes costs associated with Guidance, Health Services, Psychological Services, Speech Language Pathology, Occupational Therapy, Physical Therapy, Social Work Services, Social & Emotional Learning, Student Behavior Specialists, Restorative Practices.
Instructional support services: includes instructional staff training, curriculum development, library/media services, instruction related technology.
District administration support services: activities that establish and administer policy for the district.
School administration support services: includes office of the principal, school clerical staff, Special Education leadership, ELL Leadership.
Central services: includes fiscal services, human resources, planning, information technology.
Facilities and district safety: keeping the physical plant open, comfortable and safe for use. Keeping the grounds, buildings, and equipment in effective working condition. Maintaining safety in buildings, on grounds and in the vicinity of the schools.
Student transportation: transporting students between home and school, and on school trips/activities.
Other support services: includes equity.
Operation of non-instructional services: includes the child nutrition program.
Facilities acquisition and construction: acquiring land and buildings, remodeling buildings, constructing new buildings, installing or extending service systems and other built in equipment.
Debt service and other: payments of principal and interest long-term debt of the school district.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here