Petitions urge Essex High to change GPA system

Posted

A pair of online petitions calling on Essex High School to modify its grading scale say the current system has long disadvantaged students when applying for college and scholarships.

The petitions aim to address how EHS converts numerical grades to a grade point average. Currently, an EHS student with an 85 percent average earns a 2.4 GPA, while the same student at Champlain Valley Union earns a 3.0. Similar differences can be found up and down the grading scale when compared to schools around the county.

“This is unfair and hurts Essex students when they apply to college, try to get jobs or apply for scholarships. Our hard work deserves to be recognized,” reads a petition started by an EHS student, which has garnered over 175 signatures. That petition appeared after a similarly-themed petition started by parent Erynne Ross.

The petitions are the latest development in a long debate over all facets of EHS grading. In 2016, The Reporter detailed discontent with the district’s passing grade of 70 — 10 points higher than seven other county public schools — and faculty previously led a failed effort to convince the school to reexamine its scale in 2009.

EHS principal Rob Reardon acknowledged the historical frustration and said the petitions come at a useful time, given the requirement for Vermont schools to move to a proficiency-based system by 2020.

That transition is about two years from completion and will include a discussion on whether to keep the traditional 100 scale or shift to a new system altogether, perhaps a 1 to 4 scale or letter-based, Reardon said.

As part of the transition, Reardon said he and fellow EHS administrators plan to propose a grading system to the school board this spring, one that’s more consistent with other county high schools.

Still, Reardon said the current system’s impact on scholarships and college prospects “depends on who you talk to.”

“If they were all local scholarships, I guess that would be true to a certain degree,” he said. “But usually there’s more to it than one indicator.”

He called GPA just one of “many variables” factored into scholarships, and said the list of college destinations, including various Ivy League schools, “speaks well” to whether EHS students are disadvantaged.

Reardon’s comments illustrate the lack of consensus over how — or if — a school’s grading system impacts a student’s chances to get into college.

Some admissions counselors, including one The Reporter spoke with from the University of Vermont in 2016, say they review applications within the context of the school system, which can be seen through the school profile submitted for each student.

Ross, the petition starter, dismisses that argument. She said while Vermont colleges are likely familiar with local grading systems, many EHS students attend secondary education out of state. And not all schools have time to recalculate grades, she said, using the example of the University of California, Los Angeles, which fielded over 100,000 applications in 2016.

A Wall Street Journal article last month reported that with so many more students applying for college than before, some elite schools now employ a committee-based evaluation — staffers divvy up portions of applications instead of one person reviewing the entire file —  giving single applications less than 10 minutes of face time.

Plus, Ross said, parents she’s spoken with say some schools don’t recalculate GPA when their children apply for scholarships, nor do insurance companies that offer “good student” discounts.

“There’s this nagging feeling for a lot of parents that [our children] are being presented in a worse light than what they’ve actually achieved,” she said. “So when they go to apply, they look like a worse student.”

Ross believes more and more students are impacted each year the district fails to remedy the disparity. She said the school needs to implement a fix before the next class of juniors apply for college.

While the high school’s planned proposal does mark some progress, Ross said she’s waiting to see real action.   

“Then we’ll be satisfied,” she said.

ehs grading, essex high school grading, gpa

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here