ESSEX TOWN AND JUNCTION — The town- and city-wide reappraisal process, initially slated for completion this coming spring, is now expected to take an additional year to complete.
The updated grand list of reappraised property values across Essex Town and Junction will now come out in June of 2026. The timeline extension comes as a result of staff turnover and hiring issues at the firm contracted to complete the reappraisal.
The additional time needed to complete the process will come at no additional cost to taxpayers.
Essex Town announced the change last month. They were notified by the contractor in November that the first phase of the project, collecting data on homes in Essex Town, was just 55% complete — let alone Essex Junction, which hasn’t yet been touched at all.
“Having to recruit and retain those appraisers has been a challenge, because they want to find qualified people to do it,” Essex assessor Karen Lemnah said. “They'll find some qualified people, they may not work out, they decide they don't want to do it, just like any industry.”
Lemnah is overseeing the reappraisal process in both municipalities despite their official separation, because the city hasn’t yet hired an assessor of its own. The Junction contracted with the Town to have Essex continue to do this work for them, for this particular appraisal cycle.
The process began Sept. 13, 2022, when the town placed a Request for Qualifications out to announce it was bidding for local and regional firms. From there, the Town evaluated applicants to decide who to contract with in order to conduct the reappraisal.
On Dec. 5, 2022, the town contracted Patriot Properties Inc., which is now operating under the name of Catalis Tax and CAMA Inc. Catalis data collectors are working in Essex Town directly, and will start on Essex Junction in due time, though the firm is headquartered in Massachusetts.
Thus far, the entire process from then until now has consisted of data collection. Lemnah estimates that about 60% of homes in the town have been touched by now. The entirety of the Junction is also still awaiting data collection.
The next step after data collection will be a market analysis. The contractor will analyze the market based on the last three years of fair market sales, meaning “arm’s length transactions” between an independent buyer and seller acting in their own best interest, so the analysis excludes situations of undue stress, sales within families and sales influenced by other factors.
Both data collection and market analysis results will ultimately accurately evaluate modern-day property values in the Town and Junction and publish a fresh grand list.
“Our data is very stale and dated,” Lemnah said. “Every year, I do stay on top of permits. If a permit is issued for a swimming pool, if something gets demolished, those things are taken into account every year on properties.”
But despite tracking major changes between the last reappraisal and now, the market value has changed on that property regardless, necessitating a reappraisal anyway.
The town and city’s last reappraisal was completed in 2007, and Lemnah says the market has changed substantially since that snapshot was taken. And Essex is not alone in responding to these market changes — many municipalities are in the midst of reappraisals.
“From what I'm hearing and seeing on our end, the market has changed drastically during the COVID-era, and sale prices have skyrocketed because of that, and that's the market,” she said.
“What caused the city and the town to decide to do this reappraisal was what's considered our common level of appraisal, what the state has us do when we analyze sales every year to see listed value versus the sales price,” she added.
The CLA is currently 54.85% for Essex Junction and 54.83% for Essex Town. A number less than 100% indicates property is generally listed for less than its fair market value. A number less than 85% used to trigger a mandatory reappraisal, but since the municipalities began the process in 2022, the threshold has been changed by the state.
The new mandated trigger is the Coefficient of Dispersion, another factor used in the annual equalization study with the state. The COD is a ratio that measures equity among all properties, including residential, commercial, raw land and beyond, and aims to ensure that all property owners are being treated fairly in all measures.
The COD trigger for new reappraisals going forward is now 20%.
“The misnomer [about reappraisal] is, ‘If my house value increases by 42% from the last evaluation, it means my taxes are going up 42%,’” Lemnah said. “That is not correct.”
What actually happens when the grand list and property values increase, is the tax rate gets pushed down. A reappraisal is largely looking for a baseline average change in property value.
“Say, everybody's houses increased an average of 42%, based on the analysis,” Lemnah said. “If your value is above that 42%, you might see an increase in your taxes. If your value decreases below that 42% average, you might see a decrease. Or if you're at 42%, you may not see a huge difference in your taxes.”
This is because the budget is the budget regardless of assessed property values — it doesn’t mean the municipality is going to try to collect more taxes from the public just because property values all went up over time. The purpose is more so to ensure people are paying their fair share.
“I want to say thank you so much to the property owners,” Lemnah said. “They've been wonderful and cooperative. I’d just stress the importance of exterior and interior inspections, because we really need to capture everything inside. You can't tell everything from the outside.”
Although the state expects assessors to inspect home interiors to capture the most accurate measure of value possible on each property, interior inspection compliance isn’t mandatory.
That being said, those inspections capture appreciation and depreciation, so for some folks, taxes could go down as a result of interior inspection compliance, with no interior photos taken.
“Just be patient, and we'll get there,” Lemnah said. “Once we get closer to next year, we will be posting a lot of information about the process in formal hearings. There is going to be every chance for property owners to make sure that their data is correct [and make appeals as needed], because that is what we need to have an accurate assessment.”
Those interested in learning more may do so on the Essex Town assessor’s webpage.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here