Letter to the Editor: We must do better than nicer cages

Posted

This letter is from Brian Clifford, a resident of Essex Town.

In June of 2023, the Essex Selectboard approved a Declaration of Inclusion, committing to protect residents of Essex from discrimination, violence, and oppression, along lines of race, national origin, gender, ability, ethnicity, age, class, and more. If we allow a prison to be built here, we will break this commitment.

I believe that any facility operated by the Vermont Department of Corrections (DOC) will cause harm along all the lines mentioned above, but I would like to focus on race, gender, national origin, and ability.

Prisons are central to systemic racism in the US. If you look at those jailed and incarcerated across the country, you will find populations that are disproportionately Black and Brown. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) reports that Vermont is no different; in fact the Vermont Department of Corrections maintains some of the worst prison racial disparities in the country. The Vermont Racial Justice Alliance reports that since the beginning of 2020, Black Vermonters account for around 9% of the prison population, despite only representing 1.5% of the state's population.

Abuse along lines of gender has been well documented, most notably within the current women's prison. In 2019, Seven Days reported on a pattern of sexual abuse against women at Chittenden Regional Correcitonal Facility (CRCF). This pattern was confirmed by an investigation conducted by Downs Rachlin Martin in 2020. This July, the DOC eliminated the Corrections Monitoring Commission, which was tasked with providing independent oversight of sexual abuse in VT prisons. Now the DOC is left to oversee themselves. If we proceed with the construction of a new prison, we do so knowing that we will be creating a space where gendered sexual violence will occur.

Transgender neighbors are also abused in VT prisons. While answering the Essex Planning Commission's questions in June, the DOC mentioned that trans people are particularly vulnerable to abuse and violence within the US prison system, but it's worth mentioning that the DOC has faced legal backlash for mistreatment of transgender women. This has occurred both in men's facilities as well as CRCF.

The Vermont prison system also discriminates based on national origin through its partnership with Immigrations & Customs Enforcement (ICE). We have learned recently about the extent to which CRCF and Northwest State Correctional Facility in Swanton have aided in denying due process to hundreds of immigrants, the overwhelming majority of whom don't appear to have committed any crime other than crossing the border. ICE has trafficked over 600 people through VT prisons in 2025, including around 250 women at CRCF. Any new women's prison will be used to hide immigrants, detained through racial profiling, in blatant violation of the law.

The DOC also has a long track record of abuse against people with disabilities. In August of 2017, Vermont's Human Rights Commission found the DOC committed disability discrimination by putting people under court order for psychiatric care into correctional facilities instead. In 2021, the US Department of Justice reached a settlement with the DOC, requiring them to pay $80,000 in compensation to people harmed.

DOC leadership and local advocates argue that a new facility will address these problems, but meaningful progress will take an overhaul in DOC culture and leadership. The recent appointment of former Burlington Police (BPD) Chief Jon Murad as DOC Commissioner raises doubts, as he oversaw alarming declines in both staff and morale at BPD. The DOC running the proposed new correctional facility will be the same DOC that has made CRCF the unlivable trauma-generation machine that it is today.

I plan on living in Essex for the long term. I don't want to watch this shiny new prison deteriorate, be repurposed, become notorious for abuse, and ultimately used as a justification to build a new prison somewhere else when it becomes uninhabitable. With all due respect to columnist Marybeth Redmond, this will not be the last prison Vermont builds.This will be the prison the DOC puts into the powerpoint they use to pitch new prison construction.

The good news is that building a prison in Essex is not the only way to close down CRCF. State Rep. Brian Cina has written a bill in partnership with FreeHer VT, which proposes a different approach. H.456 outlines a vision replacing regional prisons with a community-based network of residential treatment programs, secure housing, job training, pathways to stable housing, employment, and more.

The DOC is telling us that there is only one way to proceed, but that is not the case. There is a path forward that begins with rejecting the State's application for the zoning amendment, so we can build systems of accountability and care that are more reflective of our values as a community.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here