Letter to the Editor: School budget process needed more transparency, community input

Posted

This letter is from Linda Hansen, a resident of Essex Junction. 

As I look back at the budget process, here’s what I know. You had in your plan; repurposing Summit School, changes in preschool locations, consolidating Summit and Hiawatha, expanding the ARC program, grades 6-8 at Westford being sent to the town, and grade level reconfigurations. All of these will help with the district “vision” for a unified curriculum, enhanced learning, stronger collaboration, equitable access, and improved support for students. So, we were told. I believe there were things which should have taken place at the very beginning, even perhaps before you put together a budget plan at all. The community should have been involved from the start. Impact studies should have occurred. Information about obtaining modulars should have been shared with the community. Transparency and informed decision making! But instead, we voted on April 8th and on April 9th were told modulars wouldn’t be pursued. And now perhaps modulars are being considered again. I really don’t know. It’s all very confusing to me. The timing of the vote and the e-mail about the modulars is very questionable and to be honest suspicious. In some ways we were intimidated into supporting the budget because we were informed there would be more cuts if we didn’t. The night Christine made the motion to revisit the Summit issue, it was asked if a motion could be put on the table for a level funded budget first, very strategic on your part. You vote for less funding making it impossible for Christine to pursue her motion of saving Summit. That was not the first time Christine’s concerns were put aside. Brian Donahue, whom I think played a major role in this budget plan, and who is no longer here, put her idea about Summit down once again. You say you are a collaborative group and that not one person makes any decisions in isolation, but there are people on this board who never speak, Christine has been put down, and the community is allowed two minutes to share concerns. And to add to that, community comments are not even part of your published minutes. Something doesn’t and hasn’t felt right to me from the start. Trust has eroded, integrity is in question, leaving me to wonder how this can continue into another budget cycle. I am frustrated because I feel like no one will accept the responsibility for the mess we are in. I am angry because all of this could have been avoided. I am extremely saddened for the children of this community. They look to adults for comfort and security. You have let them down. The fact is the children of this community are “collateral damage” to your poor planning. Those are your words, Robert, from Universal Meals meeting at the Montpelier State House.

Here's the present reality. The budget has passed. Since then, we have an overcrowding issue at Hiawatha, Westford kids are having a longer bus ride, kids are being shuffled around to create a K,1, 2 school at Hiawatha/Summit and 3,4, 5 school at Fleming, art and music are on carts, physical education classes are going to be doubling up, the nurse’s office is being moved into a tiny space, preschoolers will have no nurse, no librarian, and there continues to be a lingering safety concern for our youngest children. There is no equity here and quite frankly, there never was any in this plan. How can you feel good about closing a beloved school and creating such uncertainty? Ever since first coming to these board meetings my purpose was always to advocate for the children of this community, so I addressed every item in this plan not just the preschool which directly affected my grandson, but all of it. Having said that, I never supported the repurposing/closing of Summit School and I still don’t. Unfortunately, it doesn’t really matter because that decision was made early on and without community involvement. It was very clear you had your minds made up on that issue and you were never going to change your decision. I know that now. I will continue to advocate for the children of this community and in doing that I will also be looking for better communication early on, transparency, and accountability.

Respectfully submitted,

Linda M. Hansen

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here