Letter to the Editor: Let’s focus our energy on addressing the real education cost drivers

Posted

This letter is from Bethany Clark, a resident of Essex Junction. 

As a concerned resident of Essex Junction and a taxpayer and former student of the Essex Westford School District (EWSD), I wholeheartedly agree with Governor Scott on one critical point: our highest priority must be guaranteeing every Vermont child access to an excellent education at a cost Vermonters can afford.

However, I must push back strongly on the Governor’s belief that sweeping, top-down redistricting is the necessary cure for this problem, especially for successful, already-consolidated districts like ours.

The Governor paints a compelling picture of a system riddled with inefficiency and "too many districts" (119 statewide). While consolidation is necessary in some parts of the state, we must remember that EWSD is a product of Vermont's previous consolidation effort (Act 46). We are already a large, regionalized district, serving approximately 4,000 students across three communities: nearly matching the national average size cited by the Governor in Act 73 legislation.

Our local School Board has raised significant, common-sense concerns about mandated redistricting under Act 73:

Loss of Local Identity and Control: Our district has spent years building a cohesive identity, optimizing resources, and ensuring accountability to the voters of Essex and Westford. Mandating that EWSD—a successful, efficient regional entity—be dissolved or merged into an even larger mega-district risks diluting local voices and losing the community-specific knowledge crucial for supporting our students.

Administrative Efficiency is Already Proven: The Governor suggests too much education spending goes to "unnecessary administrative costs."

Here in EWSD, we are fiscally prudent. Our administrative services (Central Services) account for roughly 6% of our total budget, which is actually below both the Vermont state and national averages for districts our size.

Simply put, further consolidation will not yield significant administrative savings because those efficiencies have already been realized locally. The real cost driver (80% of our budget) is personnel and benefits, and benefits are controlled by statewide bargaining and mandates, not local governance structure.

Disruption vs. improvement: Imposing an arbitrary new district map on established, high-performing consolidated districts creates massive, expensive disruption. It would force us to reorganize systems, reallocate resources, and renegotiate contracts, potentially diverting valuable time and millions of taxpayer dollars away from the very things the Governor wants to fund: direct student instruction, the arts, CTE, and closing the achievement gap.

We should absolutely be looking at how to fix educational opportunity gaps and low test scores. But instead of blindly focusing on drawing new, larger boundaries, (a metric that, on its own, does not guarantee student performance) we should empower existing successful regional structures, like EWSD, to share best practices and resources with their smaller neighbors.

Let’s focus our energy and resources on addressing actual cost drivers (health care) and academic excellence, as the Governor suggests, but let’s stop the obsession with dismantling functional districts.

True excellence and equity will come from supporting great teachers and data-driven programs, not from dissolving strong communities into ever-larger, less responsive bureaucracies.

I urge the Governor and the Legislature to temper their zeal for massive, disruptive change and ensure the Act 73 process respects the districts that have already done the difficult work of consolidation and achieved proven efficiency.

A Concerned Taxpayer,

Bethany Clark, Essex Junction, VT

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here