Letter to the Editor: Grateful the DRB decided to enforce its farming regulations

Posted

This letter is from Stephen Wille Padnos, a resident of Essex Junction.


I write to address the community after certain misstatements and misinformation made by my neighbor Jason Struthers about his dozens of ducks and his commercial marijuana growing operation on Taft Street.

My Taft Street neighborhood is in the RESIDENTIAL 1 (R-1) zone. The purpose of R-1 is “To provide areas for large lot single family residential dwellings and accessory uses.” I have lived in Vermont since I was 1, and my wife and I have lived on Taft Street since 2002. We love Essex Junction and we love our neighborhood. Before Jason Struthers moved in next door, it was a perfectly serene and quiet residential neighborhood and we often enjoyed summer evenings on our back deck.

Unfortunately, the peace of the neighborhood has been completely disrupted by his activities, which are not permitted in the R-1 Residential Zone. Among other things, the Land Development Code prohibits the following activities in the R-1 Residential zone:

1) Raising “Livestock or Other Domesticated Farm Animals”.

2) Agriculture, which is defined in the Land Development Code as the “use of property or structures for common farming-related activities necessary for crop and animal production.” “Agriculture” is not permitted in zone R-1 the Land Development Code; and

3) Raising commercial quantities of cannabis, both as a “Cannabis Cultivator Establishment” and as “Agriculture”.

The facts are not in dispute – nobody is denying that there are ducks and commercial cannabis being grown on Mr. Struthers property. The neighborhood has long asked the City of Essex Junction to enforce its zoning regulations but until recently, the City has felt paralyzed to do so. I am grateful that the DRB decided on September 21, 2023 to enforce its regulations against farming in residential neighborhoods. If appealed, I am confident that the Environmental Court will likewise enforce the regulations against growing commercial marijuana. It is plain that the State of Vermont’s legalization of marijuana was not intended to allow commercial crops of marijuana to be grown in residential neighborhoods and next to schools (our property is near the Essex High School) when prohibited by zoning. We, like other residents of Essex Junction, deserve to have the zoning regulations enforced in order to protect our rights.

Contrary to Mr. Struthers’ accounts, the neighborhood has for years attempted to get him to comply with his obligations. Mr. Struthers has been approached multiple times, by multiple neighbors, about the odors coming from his property. This has been going on for a long time.

Time after time – Mr. Struthers has chosen the path of confrontation instead of cooperation with our neighbors. Just recently, in June 2023 I texted Mr. Struthers, "Hi Jason. There's a putrid smell coming from the black bins you put right next to the property line. Please move them." His response: "Those are compost bins, they smell."

The DRB hearing itself last week was not a surprise to Mr. Struthers. This hearing was after multiple complaints and my appeal letter (which was mailed to Mr. Struthers on August 8). The DRB set a hearing last Thursday – which Mr. Struthers attended – to address the issue.

My wife and I are not against farming nor are we against legalized commercial marijuana, no more than we are against cement factories or rock concerts. It is just that there is a proper place for cement factories, rock concerts, farming, and commercial marijuana – in a zone where it is proper and not where it disrupts quiet neighborhoods. Farming and raising commercial marijuana are legal in many places in Vermont and in the Planned Agriculture District (PA) zone in Essex Junction. We look forward to Mr. Struthers relocating his operations into a place where it is legally permitted and away from this residential neighborhood and Essex High School.

We are grateful for the DRB deciding to enforce the Essex Junction code against farming in residential zones and we look forward to the future enforcement of the zoning regulation against Cannabis Cultivation in this residential zone.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here