Letter to the Editor: Governor's fixation on Act 73 is detached from reality

Posted

This letter is from Sen. Martine Larocque Gulick (D-Burlington) and Rep. Edye Graning (D-Jericho). 

Governor Scott’s recent State of the State address was not, in fact, a reflection on the state of Vermont. Instead, it was a narrowly focused, one-topic plea for a political win — one not grounded in data, not supported by research, and not respectful of Vermont’s children, families, or rural communities. His singular fixation on Act 73 as a cure-all for Vermont’s challenges felt less collaborative and hopeful than personal and oddly detached from reality. While the Governor’s address may have been a master class in political messaging, it was strikingly light on policy, and told us everything we need to know about why he is not the right person to lead us through education transformation in Vermont.

The Governor took particular aim at the Act 73 Redistricting Task Force, dismissing its work as a failure and labeling it part of a “political strategy.” This characterization is deeply misleading. The task force, which we co-chaired, was composed of members from across the state with extensive experience in education. Over four months, we studied data, examined research, and reviewed efforts in other states. What we found was that the mandate to simply “draw new district lines” was far more complex than suggested and would require additional time and information to do responsibly.

Despite this reality, the task force produced thoughtful recommendations to lower education spending, pursue strategic consolidation where appropriate, and incentivize the creation of regional high schools — all while respecting Vermont’s diverse communities. The prevailing strategy was not, as the Governor said, “political,” but rather apolitical and focused only on improving educational outcomes while controlling costs and honoring local voices.

Ironically, during his address the Governor urged the legislature to “act on what the data actually show is best,” and to “manage thoughtfully, strategically, and with students’ best interests at the forefront.” That is precisely what the task force did. After hearing from more than 5,000 Vermonters, it centered the needs of students, families, and communities in its roadmap for the future. Dismissing this work because it did not align with the Governor’s preferred outcome undermines his own stated principles.

The Governor also spoke at length about lowering taxes while simultaneously increasing teacher salaries and expanding housing investments. Vermonters are left to wonder how this math adds up. In the short term, the only way to dramatically reduce education spending is to remove substantial funding from the system. How, exactly, does that improve quality or student outcomes? It is easy to say what one wants; it is much harder to do the work of demonstrating that it is viable. Facts and details matter.

Governor Scott noted that 10 years ago Vermont ranked among the top five states for educational outcomes, including fourth-grade reading. What he did not acknowledge is that he has been Vermont’s governor for nearly that entire decade. He has shaped policy, overseen spending, and appointed leadership at the Agency of Education. If outcomes have declined during this period, that decline occurred on his watch.

This matters because entrusting sweeping education reform to leadership without a record of educational success is a risky proposition. After the retirement of former Secretary of Education Dan French, the Governor left the position vacant for more than a year. Today, critical roles at the Agency of Education — including leadership positions essential to special education and program oversight — remain unfilled. Strong systems require stable leadership, and Vermont’s students have paid the price for its absence.

We want to work collaboratively with the Governor and his administration. We want to work together to build the best education system in the nation. But we cannot accept hypocritical and misleading narratives that shift blame while avoiding accountability. One can call for higher teacher pay while condemning rising education costs, but one cannot responsibly do both without a credible plan.

We are left to wonder how different things might be today had the Governor devoted the same focus and urgency to improving student outcomes a decade ago, when Vermont’s standing first began to slip. We cannot change the past. But we can — and must — resist a misguided reform effort that risks harming thousands more students in the years ahead.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here