This letter is from Duane Millar Barlow, a resident of Essex Town.
Dear Editor,
Across the country, communities are discovering a harsh reality about Amazon delivery stations: they bring far more traffic than promised. In December of 2024, Atlanta residents reported that Amazon broke its commitment to use designated truck routes, instead sending dozens of delivery trucks through residential neighborhoods. Bloomberg News found that traffic more than tripled in nearby neighborhoods after Amazon facilities opened, with some families installing privacy fences to protect their children from the traffic.
Now Essex faces its own proposed Amazon distribution center with "Project Moose," a 24/7 operated delivery station to be located on Kimo Drive off of Route 117/River Road, just a few hundred feet from Sand Hill Rd that would deploy 271 delivery vans daily, countless “flex drivers”, as well as 24 tractor trailers arriving throughout the night. Yet no comprehensive traffic study has been conducted for this type of facility.
The developer's traffic consultant argues that since the projected total peak hour traffic is roughly 50% of what was studied for the entire five-lot subdivision (Saxon Hill Industrial Park Phase II subdivision), that no further traffic study is needed. They gloss-over the fact that the facility would actually exceed the approved traffic limits in some directions, sending more vehicles onto our roads than what was studied or approved. And this is only taking into account peak-hour traffic, which ignores all of the other traffic generated by this kind of 24/7 traffic-intensive facility.
The developer's traffic consultant admitted there's "limited empirical data" for this "newer" type of facility and arbitrarily added a 20% buffer to their estimates as a "conservative measure." When consultants openly acknowledge they're guessing about traffic impacts, shouldn't we demand better?
Amazon delivery stations operate 24/7, with overnight tractor-trailer deliveries, morning van deployments, and evening returns creating concentrated traffic surges throughout the day. There are also massive traffic surges during the holiday season. This is completely different than the traditional 9-to-5 industrial park that was originally studied for the overall subdivision.
But it's not just about traffic volume. Amazon delivery drivers are required to deliver each package in a strict time window before moving to the next stop and are tracked by algorithms monitoring their progress. This places relentless pressure on drivers, forcing them to "skip breaks, rush between stops, and drive aggressively to stay on schedule." Safety experts warn that these rushed drivers are more prone to distracted or fatigued driving.
Other communities have successfully stood up to inadequate planning. Wallingford, Connecticut rejected Amazon's third facility over traffic concerns. A facility in Sonoma County, California was rejected by county officials, who deemed the application incomplete, citing insufficient information involving environmental review and traffic volume. These communities understood
that once the trucks arrive, it's too late to fix the problems. Some communities have had to resort to extreme measures after the fact to handle the unexpected traffic. Last December, Humble, Texas City Council had to revoke the certificate of occupancy for an Amazon distribution facility due to the traffic chaos that it caused. San Francisco issued a moratorium on new distribution centers, again because of the unanticipated traffic generated by them.
The Essex Development Review Board has the authority to require a proper Transportation Impact Study at the developer's expense. This isn't about opposing development—it's about protecting public safety, our quality of life, and our environment. We deserve to know the real traffic impacts—including holiday surges and accurate 24/7 analysis—before 271 delivery vans start navigating our streets daily.
I urge the Development Review Board to follow the lead of communities that have demanded accountability. Require a comprehensive traffic study for Project Moose.
Essex residents who share these concerns should contact the Development Review Board before it's too late. Let's learn from other communities' experiences rather than repeat their mistakes.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here