Letter to the Editor: Against merger at this time

Posted

The vote on merger failed because the majority voters had a serious lack of confidence, fueled by the inability to get straight forward answers to a number of questions, especially those relating to finances. Why is it so difficult to have the financials clearly spelled out so all can readily understand, and not have to plow through the minutia of an annual budget to find details?

Petitioning a revote is certainly the right of any resident, however, before time and effort was spent securing signatures, I feel the selectboard could have reached out to the both communities and recommended a breather, during which time a better understanding of why the merger failed. It was a missed opportunity to show responsibility, and demonstrate leadership, which by the way, is the mark of good governance.

There seems to be a faction that’s driving the merger issue before the voters in both communities are fully aware of the consequence of a merger. Under the village charter, one advantage is the additional revenue collected by the village that’s not shared with those living outside the village. The additional revenue is used at the discretion of the village, and answerable only to the village residents. The ability to collect and keep this additional money is a key component of the village charter, and virtually the main reason for the village charter.

It wasn’t that long ago when the village did an excellent job meeting the needs of the village with the additional revenue, while keeping property taxes low, and throttling back on discretionary spending when fiscally prudent, certainly good financial management. As an example, when I purchased our first house in Essex, my property taxes would have been $1000.00 less if it was purchased in the village, and many of my colleagues moved to the village for that very reason.

The increase in village taxes didn’t happen overnight, but increased over time. What happened, and how can it be fixed? Some feel the spending problem can be fixed with a larger pocketbook, by way of merger. I disagree, without a thorough understanding of past spending, both necessary and discretionary, and the lack of discipline to curb spending, taxes will continue to increase.

If the vote to merge cannot be achieved by a meaningful margin, for years to come merger will be a millstone around our neck. Virtually every issue before the selectboard will be challenged by one group or another, affecting the health and growth of both communities. If however, an open and honest accounting of the monies collected and debts incurred are better understood by the average resident, and the financial obligations and responsibilities are accurately and fairly identified, cooperation would replace confrontation, and merger would have a better chance passing by a reasonable margin.

I feel voting to merge at this time is ill advised, it’s like bandaging a wound before cleaning it. It will just make matters worse. Merger should be considered only after all the concerns raised by both communities are openly and honestly discussed and resolved.

Paul Austin

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here