After an extended legislative session that kept lawmakers in Montpelier late into May, The Reporter sat down with all five Essex legislators to get their take on some of the prominent issues that cropped up. In Q&A format, each legislator was asked to respond to five questions. Their answers were edited for length and brevity due to space restrictions. Ellipses were used to indicate breaks in the conversation where content was removed.
You’ve been in the legislature since 2001. What is it like to have a Republican governor again?
It was very nice … but because the Republicans are in the minority, I felt the majority party was trying to make things difficult for the Republican governor. … As for Phil, I think the world of him. … I knew him from when I worked for The Reporter. … He had some great ideas for this year. It’s unfortunate that some of them didn’t come out.
How did this session compare to others?
I felt that we didn’t get a lot accomplished. Forget about the budget and the marijuana and teacher healthcare. We didn’t get a lot of bills. I don’t know if that’s good or bad. … We introduced a whole lot of bills, which we always do, but compared to the past, there weren’t as many that passed.
Is there a piece of legislation that you either sponsored or were heavily involved in that directly affected Essex?
S.135, the Senate introduced the bill and threw it over to my committee and we worked on it for a long time … the state’s main economic development bill. It was a good thing … we got six new [tax increment financing districts.] The other one was S. 136, which was the same thing, and that’s a consumer protection bill. … Most of the bills that I’m impressed with or I’m very happy with are the bills my committee worked on. This is a new year for me because for the past 15 I’ve been on corrections and institutions. I got put on commerce and economic development … completely out of my sphere of expertise.
Why did you vote against the teacher healthcare proposal? Who did you consult?
Initially, Martha Heath, chair of the new Essex Westford School District and previous chair of House appropriations, sent a letter to [Essex reps] and a private email to me that said, ‘This is good for us.’ I also received support emails from the ETSD chair and superintendent. Then when the alternative proposal came forward, I immediately got emails from them saying, ‘This is worse than what we have right now.’ I voted based on those concerns.
Have you ever been part of a veto session before? Do you have any predictions for the June 21 session?
I was surprised Phil vetoed the marijuana bill. I thought he might let it become law without signing it. While I voted against it, I feel it’s going to happen. This summer I’m going to Oregon, a legalized state, so it’ll be interesting to talk to people there. … I am hoping they come up with a plan for the budget and teacher healthcare. … When the budget hit the floor, I voted for it because it was good. But because they’re now hinging teacher healthcare in the budget, I had to vote against it based on what I heard from my constituents.
This was your first session as an elected representative. What was the experience like and was there anything that surprised you?
I found this experience incredibly stimulating and so rewarding in its nature because you’re constantly learning … making you aware of what challenges there are in Vermont and how you might be able to contribute. The healthcare committee has been such a right fit for me. It’s incredible. I can’t say how much I thank the people of Essex that voted me into this office to be able to serve them and the incredible experience they’ve given me. And I feel that I’ve done good work for them.
You voted in favor of the senate’s marijuana legalization bill. What went into that decision? Who did you consult?
Out all the people that have reached out to me, I had probably a 7-to-1 ratio of people that said, “Please vote yes for this.” They had a wide variety of reasons … I felt it addressed the things that we were hearing. Reaching out to people, I went and talked to different doctors and I know that a lot of [them] were concerned about the use of marijuana, that children would be able to get ahold of it. To me, that is a part of the parental concern just as alcohol is … I thought we gave ourselves enough time to be able to do due diligence to all those issues.
Is there a piece of legislation that you either sponsored or were very involved in that directly affected Essex?
The biggest one that I got the most mail on was the telemedicine bill. We have telemedicine for medicine, but we didn’t have it for mental healthcare … took a lot of energy to get that organized. We focused on the fact that there are many people who are shut in because of agoraphobia or other issues that make it hard for them to get to counselors. Or people who have may have moved … and they must choose another person. Now, they’re going to be able to maintain that contact with telemedicine. I had so many people reach out to me on that bill and wanted to have that passed, and many of them were counselors and psychiatrists.
In your most recent Message from Montpelier, you had some pretty strong words for Gov. Phil Scott’s healthcare proposal. What are your thoughts on his decision to veto the budget?
He’s trying to hold Vermont hostage to this idea. He campaigned and said he would work with the legislature … He did this eight days before the end of the session. Does he tell us? Does he come to us to talk about that? No. How do we find out about it? There’s a press conference. I don’t think this is working with us … I do think teachers have a right to have a say in this. Maybe they would have been willing to give this up. But no one ever asked them. He talked to the state board. He talked to the other boards in the towns. But he never talked to the other side of the equation. How can you do that? You can’t do that. That’s wrong.
Looking forward to the veto session, what should constituents keep an eye on?
How willing we — [the governor] and the legislature — are to sit down and hear one another. Are we entrenched? I don’t know … I can’t see myself voting to take the teachers’ rights away. I’ve been hoping [they] settle their contracts before we sit down for the veto session … because then it’s settled for this year.
You’ve been heavily involved with many Essex Jct.-based groups and boards such as Heart and Soul and the Board of Trustees over the years. How did your first session in the legislature affect your outlook on the village?
We’re doing really good things in the village. … The development that’s happening is good. If we’re not growing, as a lot of communities in Vermont are not, it’s stagnant. So this helps us do more … Essex might need to start thinking more about services offered. Our community is changing; we’re becoming more diverse … That’s the next place I see us going based on what I see happening in the state. Essex is in a really good spot for the future.
You voted in support of S.22, the bill that would legalize recreational marijuana. What went into that decision?
I voted in support of the House bill, but I did not vote for the tax and regulate, because we’re not ready for that. We don’t have the prevention and education programs in place. Yes, that will help us fund them, but I’d rather have the process in place before the funding comes. The reason I voted for H.170 is the community’s overwhelming support for it. There are people who work in substance abuse within the schools that are against it. We need to listen to their concerns and make sure we’re crafting policy that addresses the problems.
You voted ‘yes’ on the Republican-backed H.509 initiative that would have shifted teacher health care negotiations from the local to the state level. Why?
When the governor first made his proposal, I looked at the headlines that said $26 million in savings. How can we not try to get that? But the more I learned, the more I recognized the unknowns, such as changing everyone to 20 percent of their premiums. What would that do to the non-teachers who make little money? … We had no answer. We had no answers if it was legal for us to take this away from the teachers and separate their collective bargaining rights. I couldn’t vote for that. What we finally proposed in 509 would create a commission and puts a deadline on when the contracts expire again so we can recreate the situation. That is our best path forward to ensure that we’re truly vetting this process. And at the same time, ensuring we don’t hurt the teachers and also respect our taxpayers.
Is there a piece of legislation that you either sponsored or were very involved in that directly affected Essex Jct.?
The piece I was most heavily involved in … it will affect Essex Jct., is the mental health bill we crafted. The Senate started with mental health this year and then passed it to us. We came up with a really good comprehensive bill. … When we start seeing the results, we will have a better idea of how to move forward and make our system better. It’s better in terms of getting people the care they need and for treating mental and physical health as one. … It’s gonna help every community, but I definitely know there’s issues in Essex. There’re people who need help, and we’re not working to the best of our ability to get them the help they need.
Though you’re not stranger to the State House, this was your first session as an elected representative. What was that experience like, and was anything surprising to you?
The legislative session is a really interesting process. You get to know a lot of people. You develop relationships. You work with folks from all over the state. You must be someone who’s willing to work with whomever it is sitting across the table from you. I enjoyed getting into the education committee and learning about our education finance and delivery systems, but I also enjoyed the opportunity to hear feedback from our community as some of the debates heated up. It was a different experience to be the person answering questions and trying to make referrals to get people the answers they needed.
Is there anything you can point to — like a specific bill or topic — that you had to challenge your assumptions?
A great example, and an issue that’s important to a lot of younger families, is the universal pre-kindergarten system … I was at odds with my committee. I was one of three that voted against eight others to make radical changes … I was concerned we hadn’t done enough vetting and we hadn’t dug in. A lot of that concern came from feedback that I got from my neighbors and folks around the state.
You voted ‘yes’ on the marijuana legalization bill. What went into that decision? Who did you consult?
We’re in a place in time where states are rapidly evaluating their criminal justice systems and drug control systems. They’re looking at the best use of resources. I talked to a lot of neighbors … there were differing views as to whether we should just remove the penalties and legalize it, whether we should regulate it and create a system that captures resources to address some of the key areas like prevention, education, criminal justice … I also supported an amendment to create a regulated market, which did not pass, because I believe that government shouldn’t just walk away from this conversation.
What are your expectations for the upcoming veto session?
I’m looking at three dates … the first is June 21: The veto session. We need to put aside our political differences and work to set a balanced budget. That’s what we passed in March … that didn’t raise any taxes, that made investments in critical areas I know our neighbors care about … The second date is October 23. That’s when we’ve set time, if we need to, to come back into session, because the federal budget hopefully will have been worked out … The third date: January 3. That’s when we come back for the second half of the biennium. The decisions that are made in June, October and January are gonna determine if we’re going to be able to weather the storm of federal cuts.
What was your thought process as debate over the governor’s healthcare proposal ramped up?
In the education committee … we all recognize that there is a disconnect between how local budget decisions and how local spending decisions impact what a Vermonter pays on their property taxes. I fundamentally support and believe in public education. When I was talking to neighbors, the No. 2 thing I heard is … they support and care about their education systems. Now, perhaps the No. 1 topic that I heard was how can we support an education system where unsustainable spending decisions in other parts of the state are driving up what we pay? For me, the proposal that was put on the table was not the best way to address those two demands.
You voted against the marijuana legalization bill. What went into that decision? Who did you consult?
I guess I can be honest — hey, I inhaled in the past. I understand some of the arguments that are used by those pro- people. And I do have a fairly good streak of libertarian in me. But with that said, given the number of professionals that I heard from in the medical field, law enforcement, several educators and drug addiction professionals … only two wrote to me in favor of legalization. The rest were not just opposed, they were adamantly opposed to it … I just couldn’t ignore it.
You voted in favor of the governor’s teacher healthcare plan? Why?
VEHI estimated about $50 million [could be] given back to the teachers by health savings accounts or health reimbursement accounts … and their total out-of-pocket cost would be slightly less than it is right now. From my perspective, it’s an economic issue. The taxpayers will end up saving around $26 million a year. I don’t see any harm to the teachers, at least economically. The savings of $26 million more than offsets the loss of the collective bargaining on this one issue. There’s still plenty for the teachers to collectively bargain with. I did hear from at least two of the local school board members, I won’t mention their names, and they were in support of the governor’s proposal because they felt that they were outgunned. If Essex feels like it’s outgunned, then what about the smaller towns? Because Essex has the money to hire some outside expertise.
Which bill/resolution did you sponsor this year that you felt most strongly about and why?
One I felt quite passionate about … was the presumption that if a person had a BAC of .05 and had any trace of marijuana in their system then they would be considered impaired … Hearing some of the testimony from some of the scientific professionals, THC can remain in the system for several days and particularly it can show up several weeks later for people who are losing weight … I thought this was not fair, given that with medical marijuana, there’s a lot of people who can legally use marijuana and the testimony from some people was while you may have small traces of this in your system, you’re not impaired … I fought real hard to get that excluded and it did.
For the first time in your three sessions, you voted in favor of the House’s budget (that is, until the teachers’ healthcare issue arose). Why?
There were no new taxes and it basically only grew by around one percent at a rate lower than, at that time, the projected growth in the economy. That was something I ran on when I first ran in 2014 … I believe that Vermont is in serious economic trouble, and I do believe, more likely than not, it’s going to get worse. We can’t afford any new taxes right now.
What should people keep an eye on during the veto session? Any prediction of what will happen?
My crystal ball, for what it’s worth — it’s got a few cracks in it — says that we will achieve those savings but things may not be negotiated at the state level. They still may be negotiated at the local level … but there may be constraints put on what could be offered for health insurance … that guarantee there will be these savings.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here