Four stories are enough, according to the village board of trustees, who agreed last week to nix a waiver that could allow up to six stories in the village center.
“It just isn’t worth it,” said trustee Andrew Brown, citing pushback he’s heard both publicly and privately. “The appetite isn’t there at this time.”
The issue came before the trustees during their Sept. 13 meeting, the second public hearing to readopt the land development code, updated every eight years.
The code represents the minimum standards for development and land use. It currently caps buildings at four stories; however, the planning commission can issue waivers for an extra two.
Residents at the first public hearing on August 23 urged the trustees to remove the waiver.
Resident Linda McKenna read a statement reminding trustees that landowners and taxpayers encourage growth “through the word of mouth.”
Making way for bigger buildings and more cars in an “already impossible intersection” will make the “aesthetics of being a New England village further from the truth,” she said.
Anne Whyte shared these fears, saying the trustees seemingly have a different vision for the village than residents. People think of Five Corners when they picture Essex Jct., she said.
“I’m not thinking of that,” she said, pointing toward 4 Pearl St. The five-story building is visible from the windows behind the trustees. “That now is a blight that is not going away.”
“I’m afraid the decisions you make today are things we’re going to have to live with for a very long time,” she added.
The trustees appeared to take note; at their following meeting on September 13, they agreed on a hard cap of four stories for the village center while still allowing waivers for up to six in the light industrial zone, which includes Global Foundries.
They planned to vote on the final version of the LDC on September 27.
While favoring a height limit for the village center, village president George Tyler worried it may appear as lacking faith in the village’s planning commission.
“I trust that they would not have allowed a six-story building in the village center anyway,” he said.
Trustees Lori Houghton and Elaine Sopchak empathized with the concern but felt the commission’s judgment shouldn’t be the only factor at play.
“We’re just asking to give them more clear guidance before they make their decision,” Sopchak said.
Not everyone was on board, however.
John Alden, vice chairman of the planning commission, asked the trustees to keep the status quo, believing the village should be able to at least consider six stories.
“Believe me, everybody is on full alert,” Alden said. “If it comes in over four stories, we’ve got to really know this is what we want.”
The waiver was put on the books in 2007 at the request of the then-board of trustees, who hoped to encourage a hotel in the village center, explained community development director Robin Pierce.
No one has applied for six stories, Pierce said, but a number of buildings in the village are actually five stories, including 4 Pearl St., despite only appearing as four from the front.
The building serves as a visual reminder for some residents who felt they had little input its development, igniting both interest and ire in the planning process.
Others are encouraged, like village resident Maura Collins, who lauded the officials’ efforts to do “an excellent job being thoughtful about our growth,” she wrote in a June letter to the editor.
“I want more buildings to house more people because I want more of the village to be more affordable, and more housing will do that,” she wrote. “I want more diversity so my kids can experience differences and not just read about them.”
The building height issue raises another question, one significant for the village’s future: What should growth look like?
“I have gotten more comments from residents than I can even remember about building height,” Sopchak said.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here