Impact fees, housing and LOT; how Essex Town plans to grow

Posted

ESSEX TOWN — From the local options tax to impact fees and housing commission updates, the Town of Essex selectboard contemplated how to grow Oct. 5. 

The selectboard debated whether to increase impact fees and to approve educational materials for the local option tax, which will be voted on by residents on Election Day. The board also discussed a presentation from members of the Housing Commission.  

Housing Commission updates 

Housing Commission Chair Lois Whitmore and Vice Chair Lorraine Zaloom presented their commission’s work from this past year. 

Whitmore and Zaloom described their objectives: to provide affordable housing to working class individuals and families.

“Essex’s housing challenge is not limited to people in acute crisis,” Whitmore said. “It also affects the people who keep our community functioning.” 

Part of their proposal included a design not yet implemented in Vermont, but popular in other regions of the United States and Europe. The design for housing development in Essex Town Center detailed a square shaped structure hosting residential units and commercial first floor space with a private, inner courtyard. 

Their ideal is for the structure to have a portion of the housing affordable and the rest at market rate. The design is intended to give residents a respite from other surrounding development via use of the courtyard and a neighborly, social feel from the commercial space and common area. 

Whitmore and Zaloom asked the selectboard for $50,000 to $75,000 for a pilot budget. The budget would include $7,500 for technical assistance and research and $30,000 for initial seed funding. The board did not indicate any decision to approve the commission’s request for funds. 

Impact fees for fire and recreation

Impact fees are fees applied to developers and collected by the town. The town then uses those fees to pay for needed builds or repairs related to that new infrastructure. For example, if a developer builds new housing, the town collects a fire impact fee which it might use to cover the cost of a new ladder truck now necessary due to the growth of the community. 

The board passed increasing impact fees related to fire and recreation in two separate votes. Board member Andy Watts made the both motions, which both passed 3-2 with Chair Shannon Jackson and Vice Chair Ethan Lawrence dissenting. 

Board members remained split on their viewpoints about impact fees. 

“I view an impact fee or allocation fee and such as a buy-in from any resident who comes into the town to take advantage of the facilities that the existing residents have already paid for,” board member Kendall Chamberlin said. “So it is really just owning up to a share that a resident has that everybody else has carried until they get here.” 

“Another analogy for this is [...] let’s just say I’m a builder for a living. I need to feed my family and I build new houses,” Lawrence said. “Well, now the fees just went up to build a new house in Essex. As we all know, especially from farming, we don’t control the market. So when the market pays us X dollars, and all the fees increase to reach the same product, all that means is there’s less money left and I make less money to feed my family and pay my taxes.” 

Educational materials for the local option tax ballot article

The board considered whether to approve educational materials with a “facts and questions” pamphlet about the local options tax article on the Nov. 3 ballot. Lawrence pointed out a potential discrepancy in the legal language in the ballot article and the educational materials after consulting a lawyer prior to the meeting. 

Lawrence said the way the question is written on the ballot, the town must use 50% of the overall sales tax for taxpayer relief, then give 25% to the state, and 25% as the selectboard assigns the funds. The discrepancy Lawrence proposed was in the wording “proceeds” versus “net proceeds,” meaning before or after taxes. 

“The numbers in the chart, this is based on sales data for potential revenue, so that does not change with the wording of the question,” Deputy Town Manager Karen Adams said. “The revenues to the Town of Essex also wouldn’t change in this. It’s really whether the 50% applies before you take that out or not, and I think we have to have a legal opinion.” 

The board held a lengthy discussion about how to proceed, but ultimately voted unanimously to authorize town staff to make several small changes, like clarifying the local options tax applies to prepared meals but not to groceries items, and to consult the town’s legal team to determine an accurate description of the ballot article.

Last night’s decision had no impact on the LOT ballot article, which the board previously voted July 13 to place on the ballot on Election Day. 

The LOT questions as written on the ballot are: 

1. Shall the Town assess a one percent (1%) tax on retail sales, pursuant to 24 V.S.A. §138(b), with fifty percent (50%) of proceeds of such sales tax being dedicated exclusively to offset Town municipal property tax rates?

2. Shall the Town assess a one percent (1%) tax on meals and alcoholic beverages, pursuant to 24 V.S.A. §138(b), with fifty percent (50%) of proceeds of such sales tax being dedicated exclusively to offset Town municipal property tax Rates?

3. Shall the Town assess a one percent (1%) tax on rooms, pursuant to 24 V.S.A.§138(b), with fifty percent (50%) of proceeds of such sales tax being dedicated exclusively to offset Town municipal property tax rates?

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here