How EWSD is working to improve low math and literacy scores

Posted

ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — U.S. News recently published its 2023-2024 best high schools list, with Essex High School ranking 8th in Vermont and 2,293rd in the nation out of 17,680 schools ranked.

EWSD’s ranking sparked frustrated discussions on Facebook and brought Essex resident Lynn Smith before the school board on Sept. 19, Oct. 3 and Oct. 17. Smith read out the ranking of EHS and its proficiency levels across math, reading and science.

During the 2022-2023 school year, EHS students were 36% proficient in math, 66% proficient in reading and 57% proficient in science, according to U.S. News reports.

“Why, in a heavily-funded system, are the academics suffering so badly?” Smith asked on Sept. 19.

One answer: the COVID-19 lockdown. Effects of the four-month pause on in-person learning are still showing up on student assessment scores at EWSD and across the country, now described as a “learning loss.”

“The declines in reading and math for 9-year-olds were the largest in several decades,” a 2022 PBS article on the long term effect of COVID states. “Math scores dropped even more among Black students. And the declines were sharpest among students still struggling with very basic math skills and simple reading.” 

Though math scores in Vermont and the U.S. were steadily declining well before COVID, the pandemic exacerbated an already present issue spanning the past 20 years.

“Scores in grade four reading and mathematics have been declining since 2003 in Vermont,” a 2019 report from Vermont’s Agency of Education states. “The average scale score in Vermont was higher than 9 states, not significantly different from 24 states and lower than 18 states.”

How does EHS compare to other Chittenden County public high schools?

Essex High School is fifth among eight of the Chittenden County public high schools in the U.S News ranking, though data for Colchester and Winooski is incomplete, most likely contributing to their lower rankings.

Champlain Valley Union School District is most comparable to EWSD in student enrollment and budget. It ranks number one in Vermont, while EWSD is ranked eighth. The two high schools scored relatively similarly in science, with CVU scoring 4% higher.

The biggest difference in subject proficiency was math and reading, with CVU scoring 11% and 14% higher, respectively.

The 2023-2024 best high schools list also takes into account the number of students who take and pass Advanced Placement exams. Forty-five percent of CVU students took AP exams and 40% passed. There is only a four percent difference in the number of EHS students who took AP exams, but of the 41% who took the exams, 34% passed.

A passing grade on an AP exam is a three, graded out of five. A three is also what most universities accept for a student to earn college credit for their AP coursework.

Students who were in Essex High School at the time these scores were collected were in sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth grade when the COVID lockdown happened in 2020.

What can be done?

During the Sept. 19 school board meeting, Smith said parents deserve substantive inquiries as to why students are performing poorly. EWSD has been making these inquiries, recently performing a math audit which was discussed during the Oct. 17 school board meeting. A literacy audit is set to take place this school year.

Results of the math audit include recommendations for 17 aspects of school operations and 20 recommendations for improving EWSD’s math program. Of the recommendations, the most contentious one for the school board was for algebra. 

“All students need access to high-level (accelerated) math instruction, regardless of entry point,” the audit states.

This is not currently the case for EWSD middle schools. Students in seventh grade must prove their algebra abilities on a test that, if they do well on, will place them in an additional algebra class in eighth grade. This sets the student on a track that will place them ahead of other students for high school.

Superintendent Beth Cobb said the middle schools’ algebra extension program is great, but every student should have the opportunity to take the course, instead of having to test in. EWSD’s current program creates a social separation of “algebra” and “non-algebra kids” and sets these groups of students on different tracks.

Tracking in education is when students take one test that determines the education they will receive. If they do poorly on that one test in middle school, they are put on a trajectory to never experience higher level math courses.

Changing this is not going to be immediate, which Cobb said she has already spoken with the middle school math teachers about. The specifics of the change are yet to be determined and will come from future conversations about what is best.

“This is something that we should really think about and have conversations broadly with high school teachers, all teachers, parents, it would take some time to change,” Cobb said.

De-tracking a program is more than just a schedule change, Cobb told the Reporter in an Oct. 30 email.

“It requires shifts in beliefs about who is capable of doing and understanding mathematics,” Cobb said among three other systemic changes that would need to be made.

The concept of being capable/in-capable ties labels to students at a young age, labels they carry with them to their adult life.

“This will be tricky in the community,” Cobb said. “We have a lot of people, even teaching staff who think this is the way to go.”

School board Vice Chair Scott Brown disagreed with this recommended change to the math program. 

“I totally understand the equity piece, but there are obviously kids that are ready for algebra at eighth grade or earlier. And I can't imagine we just want to hold certain kids back that can excel in certain subjects before a certain age,” Brown said.

This recommendation isn’t saying to get rid of algebra in middle school, which is a part of the math that is taught within the curriculum of the general eighth grade math class. 

Instead, Cobb would like to see students prove their capabilities outside of a one time test, that if they pass, will put them ahead of other students when they’re in high school. The goal is to increase the math capabilities of all students.

Student school board representative Samantha Donahey, one of the students who took the two math classes, spoke of one of the issues of the two subjects being taught in different spaces for those who took the class.

“Eighth grade math does have algebra, but it's a lot more basic algebra than the algebra 1-200, so I was doing stuff that was in my regular math class that was below what I was doing in algebra class,” Donahey said.

This led to boredom for her and more work for her teacher, who was having to come up with different work for her to do during the standard math class.

“She was kind of triple teaching because she was giving extra support to some students and teaching the baseline to some students and trying to also give challenges to some other students,” Donahey said.

Some other recommendations given by the math audit include:

  • Technology should be part of a blended learning approach

  • Teachers need to ensure their classroom assessments are better aligned with the progression of high expectations

  • Need more opportunities for students to show thinking visually

The district plans to take all of these recommendations into consideration, and when possible, apply them to other subjects in the curriculum.

“I don't think there's one that will say ‘we're not going to do that.’ They're all good recommendations. Some will take more time than others,” Cobb said.

#vermont, #math scores, #math audit, #u.s. news’ 2023-2024 best high schools, #ewsd, #burlington high school, #champlain valley union high school, #colchester high school, #essex high school, #milton high school, #mount mansfield union high school, #south burlington high school, #winooski high school, #ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here