VERMONT — The state legislature is reviewing a transportation bill that may fundamentally change the landscape of rural transportation in Vermont, amidst a search for possible cost savings opportunities.
Green Mountain Transit was originally implemented to serve Chittenden County, the most urban region of the state, but for the last decade it has also provided public transportation to Franklin and Washington counties. Though a transportation service will continue rural service provisions in Vermont, GMT might return to its original mission of serving Chittenden alone.
Now, Vermont is just one of three states with a single transit service covering both rural and urban routes — perhaps because of the limited practicality and potential costliness of the model.
The idea to cut rural service came from an organizational assessment that was done at GMT in 2023, as a result of heavy leadership turnover at the time. Both GMT’s Board of Commissioners and the Vermont Agency of Transportation were concerned with the sustainability of staffing at GMT, so they conducted the assessment with outside consultants.
Transit organizations typically choose to administer service for either urban or rural areas, and not both, because funds for rural and urban transit aren’t legally allowed to mix. So, it was determined that GMT had the administrative staffing necessary to manage a small urban transit network, like the one it has in Burlington, but not to manage an additional rural service.
That conclusion led the legislature to conduct a study to see if it would make sense to have GMT go back to being an urban-only provider, as it was prior to 2004. The study was completed by the end of 2024, and it did indicate that there could be cost savings to transferring the rural service to other available providers.
That brings us to where we are now. The two potential nonprofit providers that were identified — Tri-Valley Transit for Washington County and Rural Community Transportation for Franklin County — are taking stock of their options and considering whether they want to do it, because if they were to accept, the overall number of rides these organizations would provide would more than double, Clark said.
“We're not talking about a small change,” said GMT’s general manager Clayton Clark.
The transportation bill this year is currently being worked on by the Senate, and the House version of the bill that crossed over would make some changes to state statute. Currently, the statute indicates that GMT is the provider in Chittenden, Franklin, Grand Isle, and some of Lamoille.
Assuming the Senate passes the bill as the House modified the statute, the change would essentially guarantee GMT remains the provider for fixed routes in Chittenden County, and leave the responsibility for transit in rural areas open-ended.
If GMT provides any other service, it will be through the state grant process administered by the Vermont Department of Transportation, rather than via the state’s overarching transportation budget.
In the future, VTrans will decide who is the best provider for service outside of Chittenden County. That decision will be based on a VTrans affordability assessment, as well as whether the other two organizations identified express interest by applying for VTrans grants to fund the program.
House Transportation Committee Chair Matt Walker (R-Swanton) said every one of the providers, including Green Mountain transit, testified in favor of the bill.
“We want to make sure it's permissive, that whatever is negotiated and goes back and forth between the agency and the providers, that any of them could continue the service,” Walker said. “This is an 18-month process before anything will change. It would be next summer, at the earliest, before you would see a provider change, because of the negotiation of the grant.”
“And the bill passed 11 to zero,” he added, referring to the bill’s time in the House. “As a Republican chair, I want to be very clear — there's six Democrats on the committee, and they all voted for the policy and the budget.”
Though the bill has yet to be completed on the Senate’s side, there is no outcome in which service goes away in rural areas, because Clark said GMT would commit to continuing to provide rural transportation if others are unwilling or unable.
The reason for the statutory change is largely in effort to try to find cost savings for the taxpayer, but the reasoning also spans beyond that motive.
“The thinking goes that with GMT being the largest provider, and with our assessment showing how overstretched we are, that if we had a mission that was more in line with our capacity, that we would probably be able to be more efficient in our service,” Clark said.
“And that would then lead to cost savings for the system,” he added. “So I believe it's certainly sort of rooted in cost containment, but there's also improved management.”
Walker said ridership hasn't recovered to the pre-COVID levels, partly due to the state-at-home work options available now, and the many state and federal employees don't have to go to work anymore — so the ridership isn’t enough to support extensive public transportation.
But Clark said ridership hasn’t meaningfully decreased in the wake of the pandemic, and that ridership levels have little to no bearing on the reason behind the skyrocketing cost of service — rather, the issue has been the cost of providing service is rising faster than revenue growth.
“For our urban service, we're already sort of back to our pre-pandemic levels of service, with the exception of our long-distance commuter routes,” Clark said. “Those are about half the ridership previous. That's one of the reasons why we saw a decrease in [link runs] that we’re operating.”
Generally though, one of the largest primary drivers of cost increases to GMT is the inflationary impacts that came about after the pandemic, Clark said, as well as the scarcity of Commercial Driver’s License holding drivers, which has greatly increased the cost of labor.
Indeed, Walker said the state’s public transportation budget has no less funding in the new bill as it’s drafted than it did last year — but that inflation has outpaced the state’s ability to keep up.
“Our single biggest expense is the cost of benefits and salaries for our driving workforce, because the biggest percentage of our staff is that driving workforce,” Clark said. “And with there not being enough CDL drivers in the state to fill all of the various buses.”
However, there are stakeholders for whom those salaries and benefits are paramount: GMT’s union-member drivers. VTDigger reported in February that those drivers may lose union representation if they seek employment at one of the new private, rural providers, and with that, some of the pay and benefits they earned through bargaining.
Moving from public to private employment could bring several changes to drivers.
On the one hand, the scarcity of CDL drivers could help to protect employees assuming they have to seek employment with other orgs. But on the other hand, the CDL certification might be devalued through the ability to rely on smaller vehicles in rural places.
As far as Washington County goes, Tri-Valley Transit drivers already have Teamsters representation, just as GMT drivers do. But labor concerns may lose particular leverage in Franklin County, given the proposed provider would be a non-union provider: RCT.
“In Franklin County… Those staff are, I think, rightly-concerned that benefits and wages that they have earned through the negotiation process may be lost,” Clark said. “There definitely is a labor relations component to the decision to transfer the service in Franklin County.”
Ultimately, though, Clark believes that at least for CDL drivers, they’ll be unlikely to take a significant pay reduction simply due to RCT’s difficulty recruiting or retaining those folks. In rural areas where service can be completed by non-CDL drivers, of course, this may not hold up.
Curtis Clough, Teamsters Local 597 president, the union representative for GMT’s Chittenden, Franklin and Washington drivers, has always felt Washington County drivers would fare just fine.
“GMT has had a rocky relationship with the community down there, the drivers have had a rocky relationship with GMT because they've always been short staffed,” Clough said. “And under federal law, there’s no hours of service limits — but once they become a private vendor, the company won’t be able to put the drivers to work more than 10 hours a day, which will likely increase driver satisfaction significantly.”
“I feel like employees have more rights as government employees, and I think I would support them remaining government employees,” he added. “I'm generally speaking against privatization, but we also understand why the state would look into privatizing that group.”
Clough doesn’t anticipate it would save the state much money, but that it could improve rural relations, given that GMT has been unable to get the level of routes and services the community desires and that taxpayers don’t seem interested in contributing more funds to the cause.
The City of Barre for example, he said, would like more transportation service, but residents only pay about $38,000 a year, and they get 160 hours of service per week, or about 8,000 or 9,000 hours of service a year.
“They feel like they're paying a lot of money, but realistically, it doesn't even buy one bus,” Clough said.
As far as heavy driving hours go, Clough said drivers’ experience has gotten a little better under Clark’s management team — as Clark has drawn something of a line in the sand around how much service they can offer per employee, despite a lack of legal limits on the public sector.
“He saw that his employees were complaining,” Clough said. “Before, a lot of the drivers were working 12, 13, 14, 15 hour days of just driving, which would be illegal in the private sector, and they were feeling pretty stretched.”
But as GMT drivers’ current employer, Clark expressed a commitment to their wellbeing.
“I'm very concerned about our existing employees, and I want to make sure that if they're transferred to other providers, that those providers are going to treat those employees at least as well as we would,” Clark said. “Because I do feel a commitment to caring for our existing staff.”
“And I'm also sort of optimistic that if transfers do happen, that there's the potential that the workload crisis among GMT staff could be lessened,” he added. “There's multiple pressures here, that don’t make it clearly obvious that one pathway is absolutely the right pathway.”
Clough, on the other hand, has his worries about the possible rural transfer trajectory, as far as the future of Franklin County drivers is concerned, if it were to move into the hands of RCT.
“If RCT comes in and gouges their wages, the way the consultant claimed they were going to do before the legislature, the drivers will go on strike,” Clough said — and there are fewer barriers preventing a strike if these drivers become private-sector employees.
But the state-commissioned study obtained proposed compensation numbers from RCT that appear much lower than what RCT is presenting to workers about their package, Clough said.
Sure enough, based on the testimony he’s heard, Rep. Walker of the House Transportation Committee expects any group that takes rural transit over won't be offering what GMT’s unionized drivers have now, which would be the primary driver resulting in taxpayer relief.
“But I would argue there's more reasons than that for savings,” Walker said. “Regional provider service is different from what Green Mountain Transit is best at… And Green Mountain Transit testified they are okay with going down this path.”
These other possible savings could come from the use of new, nimble AI-generated mapping software that tracks most popular routes that keep routes updated in line with call volume and data about the known need. Those routes, along with some modern micro-transit routes, could more efficiently replace oversized fixed-route busing in less densely populated areas.
“Bus drivers are in high demand all over this state,” Walker said. “I think they'll get the offers. Will it be disruptive? Potentially. But any change is. I believe that they're highly qualified, and the salary levels will likely come in pretty darn close, or they will have other options that still return them back to their home every night.”
Clough was unable to find GMT drivers willing to talk on the record at this time.
“If it's the numbers that the state's study has, those drivers are going to go on strike,” Clough reiterated. “There's no protection against that once they’re not public workers. If they don't intend to have a 30%-40% base decrease, they won’t be able to get away with that.”
From the rider perspective, Clark doesn’t anticipate a discernable difference to accompany the possible transfer of rural service — services should remain largely the same, aside from the fact the vehicles will have a different logo on them.
Part of why VTrans has been supportive of the transfers is because it believes not only in the potential for savings, but also that any money saved could then be reinvested back into transit, helping to limit new service reductions, not just at GMT urban, but among the rural providers as well.
That being said, the services that GMT has already confirmed to be cut are unlikely to be restored, unless the legislature has a change in heart around overall public transit funding going forward — the routes already set to be cut are the services that will impact the least amount of people.
Still, Clark made clear that even for lines with low ridership, their elimination often has just as devastating an impact for their few most loyal riders as the cut of a more popular line would.
“One of the things that I bristle at a little bit, is [the assumption] that eliminating routes that have low ridership doesn't cause impacts,” he said.
For instance, a particular early-morning run GMT targeted for elimination last August averaged just three riders a day. In September, there were public meetings to discuss said elimination — and sure enough, at the first public meeting was one of those three riders.
“He talked very passionately about how the elimination of this run would impact his day,” Clark said of that meeting attendee. “Even when you look at a run that's only moving a small amount of people, when you take it away from the people that have come to rely on it, that's just as significant to them as it would be to others on a more populated route.”
“When I look into the future, I see a future where GMT could transfer all of its rural service and everything works out well — I see a future where GMT transfers none of its rural service and it all works out well,” Clark said. “I think there are pathways for it to be okay, in either direction.”
But future cuts still loom on the horizon, especially in Chittenden County.
To-date, GMT has approved about $1.2 million a year worth of urban service reductions from a budget of about $20 million per year in the area — and fiscal year 2027 is slated to see another $3 million gap, hence, is likely to have to deliver service cuts at a value of up to that amount.
“Those cuts are going to be a lot more painful, because just about all of our underperforming routes have been reduced or eliminated with these initial cuts,” Clark said. “So further service reductions are going to start eating into very economically efficient transit.”
GMT has seen a few reassurances from VTrans in relation to the $3 million gap coming up, that the agency can try to meet GMT halfway by coming up with about $1.5 million for the provider, while GMT tries to either come up with the other half via new revenue streams or administers the remaining $1.5 million service reduction leftover thereafter.
While the changes that GMT has had to date probably haven't impacted most of its users, Clark said — probably 90% of its riders haven’t noticed — if it had to do another $3 million service reduction, then just about everybody would be feeling that pain across Chittenden County.
And even if GMT maintains its status as the rural transit provider and somehow those areas fare better, because urban funding and rural funding are fenced off from one another, anytime there is a hole in urban or rural transit needs, fund transfers between the two are out of the question.
Still, public transportation isn’t the only element of the transportation bill that’s hurting for funds. Rep. Walker said the state is conducting just 100 miles of state highway repairs this year, down from last year’s 200, as it’s getting harder and harder to pay for transportation needs.
“We have very positive things happening for the environment in Vermont in terms of burning 65 million gallons less of gas — however, that's $23 million less revenue we have to fix the roads,” he said, referring to the gas tax as one example of lost revenues. “How do you deal with that?”
“There's far more people who are calling me to get their roads paved than the ones that want to ride the bus,” he added. “Even if they’re a lot louder than the ones that are driving on the roads.”
Walker also believes people have a right to be worried about the direction of the current federal administration’s directive in cutting programs and funding to the states — that although public transportation funds haven’t hit the chopping block yet, it’s something to keep an eye on.
“Everybody’s nervous about what’s next,” he said. “That will only make it more complicated.”
But in the long run, Clark’s hope is that Vermont’s legislature will recognize how transit can fundamentally move other socioeconomic goalposts forward in the state — and that ultimately, legislators find an outcome that prevents the further elimination of large swaths of service.
“It helps with climate goals, it helps with social equity goals, it helps with getting people to their medical appointments, it helps with getting people to their counseling services, it helps them with job access,” Clark said. “A lot of the things that the state of Vermont is working towards, public transit is a facilitator of that.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here