Governance discussion advances

Posted

Essex’s elected boards are advancing a conversation that could radically change the town-village relationship and mark this decade’s biggest move toward a fully merged community.

Last week’s joint meeting covered what information officials will need to tackle on governance while highlighting some of the likely sticking points that stand in the way.

The agenda item picked up minutes after officials accepted a report that recommended continuing their consolidated public works model. And just a mile away, their recruiter spoke with residents about the ongoing manager search.

“Clearly the momentum is moving us towards changing things the way they are,” village president George Tyler said.

Suggestions included seeking out speakers who have experience on different governing models, a joint retreat or work session to help spur the discussion and a look at other town-village mergers, both state and nationwide.

Among the various challenges is addressing the town and village charters, voting systems, organizational charts and local codes.

Selectwoman Irene Wrenner said the boards should include the new manager in the discussion so they have that person’s buy-in.

She suggested compiling a running list of the “low-hanging fruit” and then coming up with a to-do list. But she also questioned if governance is the appropriate next step considering not all municipal departments have merged.

To date, consolidated services include departments of finance, town clerk, stormwater and public works. Big-ticket items like libraries and recreation remain.

Wrenner wondered how a joint board would govern separate, outlying departments.

“[Let’s] be totally honest with ourselves,” Wrenner said. “If this is indeed a bottom-up merger, the boards are last.”

Wrenner’s comments clash with the consensus among the trustees, who believe future consolidations don’t make sense before first addressing governance.

To that end, trustees shelved recommendations to merge planning commissions in July, citing concerns over their degree over control for the shared entity.   

Then, they offered three options: maintaining two chartered governments indefinitely, dissolving to force consolidation or continuing a gradual approach with an explicit goal of forming a unified government.

The last option appears to be preferred by both boards, Tyler said at the time, though he hoped to reaffirm the course during the manager search.

If officials do pursue a unified government, some of their biggest decisions will be prescribing what a merged board looks like, such as the number of members and the breakdown between town and village.

And while they may find some inspiration from other municipalities that have undergone a similar transformation, trustee Elaine Sopchak said the boards should not pursue an existing governance model simply because it already exists.

Instead, they should be willing to “take risks” and “consider unusual ideas,” she said.

“This is a very clean slate, and we’re probably one of the only communities in the country having this conversation,” Sopchak said. “We’re in the vanguard, let’s act like it.”

essex, governance, selectboard, vermont

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here