Gov. Phil Scott rolls out school district consolidation plan; EWSD board weighs-in

Posted

MONTPELIER — Gov. Phil Scott’s administration unveiled an overhaul of Vermont’s education system on Wednesday, a plan that includes consolidating the state’s 52 school districts into just five.

School officials in the Essex Westford School District are still absorbing the announcement, but board members already are criticizing the plan for its lack of action on healthcare costs and local control.

“It is somewhat shocking that after this abysmal failure on the Governor’s part on managing state-administered health benefits, his solution does not in any way reference solving the fallout of healthcare costs,” the EWSD board said in a statement. “Instead, it looks to double down and eliminate the last, limited measure of local control and local taxpayer-lead accountability in education through massive consolidation.”

Secretary of Education Zoie Saunders presented the proposal during a joint session of the Vermont House and Senate. She said the plan will provide financial relief for Vermonters while enhancing education quality.

“Our current system does not deliver on that promise, despite increased investment and good intentions,” she said.

In addition to consolidating districts, the governor’s proposal recommends adopting a foundation formula. In such a model, districts are provided a base amount of money per student. While Saunders did not specify a dollar amount, she did say the allocation would be “very generous.”

This concept ensures students from rural or less-advantaged communities have the same opportunities as those from bigger or more wealthy towns, she said.

The funding plan would also account for students who are more expensive to educate, including English language learners, economically disadvantaged students and those with disabilities.

The proposal eliminates “supervisory unions” and suggests five regional school districts instead: the Champlain Valley region, Winooski Valley region, Northeast region, Southwest region and Southeast region. Each district would have roughly 10,000-15,000 students, except for the Champlain Valley district, which would have closer to 34,000.

Chittenden County schools would be included in the Champlain Valley district and grouped with Grand Isle and Franklin counties.

The five districts would have part-time elected, paid school board members. The plan also proposes “school advisory councils” to make up for the decrease in local control. The councils would have representation from families, educators and students and have input on budget development and strategic planning.

At the individual school level, Saunders said consolidation could create “regional comprehensive high schools, central middle schools and local neighborhood elementary schools” while considering the challenges of transportation and geography.

How we got here

While still light on details, the Scott administration’s proposal does lay out the reasoning behind the changes, pointing out how trends felt over decades have steadily created an inefficient education system.

During her presentation, Saunders contended that past efforts to reform education have created a highly complex system for Vermont’s schools, with the resulting organizations being too bureaucratic and cumbersome to ensure that officials can meet the challenges that come with generational turnover – such as rising costs and decreased enrollment.

Additionally, the system itself often encourages competition for state dollars. As the nation wrestled with the aftereffects of the COVID-19 pandemic, schools often found themselves focused on a fight for survival while student outcomes continued to languish. Both math and reading proficiencies are trending downward for Vermont’s students.

In response, the schools added more staff to help prop up the system, eventually adding two more employees per every 100 students since the pandemic’s start. Despite the renewed staffing effort, fewer students are graduating.

With that said, Vermont’s problems align with many of the challenges that schools face across the United States. There are just less and less kids entering the education system nationwide after numbers began to flatline following the Great Recession, according to the National Center for Education Statistics. In Vermont, student enrollment numbers have dropped by roughly 20% since 2002.

The growth in socioeconomic needs faced by today’s children also likely plays a factor, as more and more time and money is needed to educate students with wide-ranging behavioral and educational needs.

Scott’s proposal emphasized a Whole-Child approach to education to help tamp down on those issues by connecting a child’s academic development to a wider sense of belonging as well as physical and mental health.

Locals react

The EWSD board of directors’ statement, released on Friday and signed by Chair Robert Carpenter, Vice Chair Laura Taylor and Clerk Marlon Verasamy, also shares concerns about consolidation.

The board cites research by the National Center for Education Statistics that found the 100 largest districts in the U.S. have lower graduation rates and higher pupil per teacher rates than smaller districts.

“Consolidating districts has no guarantee of decreasing costs, but comes with the well-researched problems tied to large institutions: high administrative cost, redundancies, inefficiencies, negative educational outcomes, poor workplace culture, disconnect from communities, and more,” the board stated.

After Saunders’ presentation Wednesday, House Speaker Jill Krowinski (D-Burlington) and Senate President Pro Tem Phil Baruth (D/P-Burlington) issued a joint statement commending the governor for bringing forward the proposal.

“The Legislature and the Governor are aligned in the belief that we must take on the serious task of transforming our education system so all Vermont kids have the opportunity to thrive,” they said. “In the coming weeks, House and Senate committees will be hard at work…hearing from Vermonters, parents, educators, administrators and students. The details matter and we need to get it right.”

The unified call for education reform rang loud after education property taxes rose an average of 13.8% last year. This year, the tax department has predicted a 5.9% increase in property taxes.

Tax Commissioner Craig Bolio, who joined Saunders for her presentation, said the new finance system will provide more transparency for voters around how their vote impacts their tax bill. The EWSD board feels the opposite.

“Eliminating meaningful local-level accountability will ensure that Vermonters will be as powerless to address education issues as we are in the face of our healthcare costs,” the board stated.

#ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here