These articles were first published in The Hive, the student newspaper at Essex High School. Emma Cross, Katerine Lacourciere and Ruth Knox are EHS students.
By Emma Cross — EHS The Hive Staff Writer
As of August 2026, Vermont has implemented a statewide phone-free learning environment, affecting students all over the state.
The Vermont Legislature passed Act 72 (H.480) in 2025; Phil Scott later signed it on June 27, 2025, creating a statewide requirement for district school boards to adopt and enforce a policy to keep cell phones out of the schools during the school day.
In a newsletter sent to all students, staff and families, Essex Westford School District stated students should not have access to their devices and “students should keep devices powered off and stored in their backpack, locker or designated storage location throughout the school day.”
The district says “devices” include phones, smartwatches, wireless headphones, smart glasses or any other personal electronic devices with wireless capabilities.
This has created much confusion and frustration among the students.
Junior Oona Osborne thinks the system for how students receive their schedules and the phone policy do not align.
“If we’re expected to be on time to class but can’t check the room number on a phone or watch where they are given to you, how are we supposed to be on time?” Osborne said. “I was late to several classes because I didn’t know where to find them.”
Sophomore Kale Odom believes this phone ban makes it hard to complete schoolwork when some teachers require images.
“It’s hard for me when I am in study hall because I need my phone to do some of my homework,” Odom said.
However, EWSD School Board Student Representative Emma Cappelluti thinks the new phone policy can be beneficial for students because it creates opportunities to stay focused, engaged and present during the school day.
“I think it’s important for students and families to understand that this policy comes from the Vermont state government, and EWSD is implementing that requirement in our schools as the School Board and Superintendent see fit,” Cappelluti said. “As we move forward, I think we, as students, should step out of our comfort zone of texting and social media at school to be present and acknowledge the positives that will bring our day-to-day life.”
Katerine Lacourciere and Ruth Knox — EHS The Hive Co-Editor-in-Chief
In June 2025, Vermont policymakers passed Act 72, banning the use of personal electronic devices, including cell phones, earbuds, smartwatches, tablets and personal computers, from bell-to-bell.
While this has become widely celebrated among administrators and districts as a step towards regaining focus in classrooms, there has been significant pushback within student responses.
This system isn’t new for EHS. For the past two years, the district adopted a phone caddy system, where students would place their phones into a pocket before the start of each class. However, there was no ban on phones during passing periods or lunches under the previous system.
Aspects throughout the school have been affected due to the new rules, along with a variety of mixed reactions from students and faculty.
Impacts on Athletics and Learning
For athletics, the phone ban means more than not checking texts in between classes. It has been a long-standing tradition for EHS athletes to take team photos on competition days, typically after lunch block. Normally, these photos are taken on an athlete’s phone, which is then uploaded to the team’s social media to help alert other students of that day’s event. However, due to the phone ban, athletes are no longer allowed to take photos on competition days.
“We are fully supportive of continuing the tradition of taking team photos and sharing them ahead of each competition–but it will need to look a little different this year,” an email from Devin Wendel, the athletic director at EHS, said. “We cannot allow students to take team photos during the school day with their cell phones, but there are three viable, alternative options.”
The alternatives provided were that athletes could take team photos before school, after school, or ask a faculty member to take an image for them. However, some athletes are still frustrated about the situation.
Molly Gilbert, senior member of the Varsity Girl’s Soccer team, found it difficult to connect the student body to upcoming games due to the lack of photos.
“It’s been difficult because now since the phone [ban] we can’t take pictures during advisory or flex, a time that everyone has, so it is harder to get everyone in one spot,” Gilbert said. “Before and after school people might have off blocks and before practice is hard because some people need to go to the trainer and we all get to the locker room at different times.”
Despite the expressed difficulty to gather everyone in one spot at an alternative time, Gilbert shared that she hasn’t noticed a difference in successful promotion of upcoming games.
While alternatives are viable options for athletes, Act 72 does allow for leeway regarding phone use during school if phone use is approved by an administrator for an academic, school-sponsored athletic, or cocurricular purpose, for the most limited use reasonably possible.
For student-athletes, this caveat raises questions about whether or not team photos fall under the umbrella of a “school-sponsored athletic purpose.”
Unfortunately, journalism students have faced similar challenges, as the class previously relied on phone usage to fulfill curriculum requirements.
Students are no longer allowed to use phones during the day to record quotes or take photos. As journalism students, this means missed opportunities to understand the basics of photojournalism or grasp the technology behind operating and transcribing a live quote.
“I think that not having my phone for Journalism has been super difficult to navigate,” Emma Cross, current journalism student and Media and Communications Manager for The Hive, said. “When interviewing other students or teachers during the day, we have to write our quotes down by hand; this makes the process a lot slower and less accurate.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here