Forum on proposed Amazon warehouse in Essex abruptly ends before getting started

Posted

ESSEX TOWN — Eighty-plus attendees filed into Essex High School’s cafeteria and over 100 joined virtually last night to make their voices heard about an Amazon warehouse proposed for Saxon Hill Forest. 

Except before even getting through the first agenda item, the Essex Development Review Board meeting came to a swift and total halt due to technical difficulties with the online viewership. 

The board voted to transfer the entire agenda from the May 1 meeting to its next meeting. 

According to the town clerk’s website, the next meeting is scheduled for June 5, but community development director Katherine Sonnick told the Reporter this morning the town is working to try to find a sooner date and location to accommodate the next DRB meeting. 

On Thursday night, the formality of asking the other board members if there were any objections to the premature adjournment yielded nothing but a solitary shout of “yes” from the thick crowd of people who had carved time out of their lives to be there. Other attendees buzzed in agreement. 

But because the meeting was advertised as a hybrid offering, to have carried on without online attendees’ being able to access the audio stream would have rendered the meeting not-public and hence, invalid. The entire agenda from Thursday will have to be delayed as a result. 

The board spent a half hour or more attempting to resolve the issue before making the call. In addition to issues accessing the audio for remote viewers, folks in-person also had complaints about the intensity of the speaker volume associated with the remote viewership’s stream. 

“Something’s not right in Denmark,” said one DRB member, Hubie Norton, of the issue — implying that perhaps online viewership had disrupted or stalled the meeting intentionally. 

Another shout arose from within the crowd of in-person attendees: “Maybe it’s Amazon.” 

One attendee, on a megaphone, voiced they see such a failure from public officials — whose job it is to run hybrid public meetings effectively — as entirely unacceptable. Despite having spoken at a public meeting, the person declined to identify themself to the press. 

Others, however, viewed what happened as an honest mistake — in spite of the shared feelings of frustration around stalled discussions and wasted time. Essex resident Alexis Dubief said she doesn’t think what happened was a result of conspiracy. 

Like many of the meeting’s attendees, Dubief is anti-Amazon. 

Back on March 20, the DRB first reviewed a proposal for a 100,000 square-foot Amazon distribution center on a parcel of Saxon Hill Forest zoned for industrial use. Since then, Essex residents and others have taken sides on the issue.  

Essex resident Brandon Badeau said he recently purchased a home in the area, which he would not have done had he known there was a possibility of a megacorporate delivery warehouse popping up in his new neighborhood. His reasons being two-fold: a possible decline in property-value on his investment, and an almost-certain uptick in noise pollution. 

As many folks filtered out of the meeting, a small group of activists convened on the lawn in front of the school to discuss what had gone down and what their next steps would be. 

One member of the group, Joanna Grossman, is the community relations manager at Phoenix Books in Essex. She told the Reporter she has been active at local meetings and in local area political campaigns in Chittenden County, but has never witnessed a total crash of meeting-supportive technology shut down a public meeting. 

“Phoenix Books has just had a really incredible experience with the community here,” Grossman said. “And we want to make sure that we're supporting them too.” 

“Essex actually has a really forward-thinking town plan — it specifically names economic development and supporting entrepreneurs as a priority,” she added. “And yet, they're bringing in an organization that's going to take money out of Vermont and send it right up into space.” 

Grossman named a great number of concerns around the potential negative impacts to locals if Essex moves forward with becoming the first municipality in Vermont to host an Amazon facility. 

“We know this development is terrible for the community’s roads, traffic, noise pollution, flood resilience — and we want to make sure that we're protecting our community with everything they've done for us,” she said. “And you know, we believe in supporting local businesses. Phoenix isn't going anywhere. We're going to be okay, but we want to support our community.” 

Amazon spokesperson Steve Kelly, of Nashville, Tn., was also present at last night’s meeting. 

“One thing I want to start off with is, this is about providing faster delivery and better service for customers living in and around the Burlington area, right?” he told the Reporter. “Like, the opening of this delivery station doesn't change what's available to people who live in Vermont on amazon.com, it just gets it to them faster.” 

Kelly said no one is going to be able to walk up to this building and buy a book; it's a logistics hub. Orders will come already packaged and boxed, just to be loaded onto a van. 

“And it's the same process that's already happening at FedEx and or at UPS and the USPS,” he said. “We're just going to be doing it ourselves, removing some of the barriers that we had.” 

He referred to concerns about property value as “anecdotal in nature,” but stressed that the site pertaining to the application, in Saxon Hill Forest, is zoned by the town for industrial activity, and hence, Amazon’s application is in line with the town’s intended use for the space. 

“What I can tell you is this,” Kelly said. “This is their priority, to have this sort of operation.” 

In terms of traffic concerns, if approved, Kelly said tractor trailers that would be coming to the building and the vans that would be leaving it to deliver packages will all follow a flow that entirely avoids peak-traffic times like rush hour, with operations designed to minimize impact. 

“The other thing I think is really important for people to understand, is we have more than 600 small and medium sized businesses located in Vermont that use amazon.com to sell their products,” he said. “This facility is going to get those products out faster for delivery.” 

Worker safety and labor rights have been an ongoing issue at the company for years globally, according to workers with lived experiences of neglect and abuse in Amazon warehouses. 

Kelly said the safety reports Amazon puts out each year have demonstrated progress to the federal government, with a reportable injury rate over the last five years having gone down by over 30% and a lost time injury rate decreasing by 70%. 

“We really strive to make these buildings warm and welcoming for employees,” he said. “Safety is our top priority. We're not going to stop until we're best in class, but we've made significant gains over the past five years.” 

Kelly said all employees earn at least $18.50 starting wage, with Amazon’s average pay across the board within the U.S. being $22 per hour. 

Thanks to the labor of workers keeping the operation alive on the ground and increasing stock values, Amazon’s owner, Jeff Bezos, makes approximately $7.9 million per hour in total net worth and assets. He owns over 10% of the company’s stock as its largest shareholder. 

To learn more about the proposal, and to hear additional perspectives from Essex residents and nearby Vermonters on the proposal, read the Reporter’s last story here. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here