Jacob St. Amour, 20, of Williston pleaded not guilty to second-degree murder charges in Chittenden Superior Court on Tuesday after prosecutors said he stabbed a man at the Champlain Valley Fair late Sunday night.
Police say 22-year old Ryan Durkin of South Burlington was fatally wounded just after 11 p.m. on Sunday and was pronounced dead at the hospital.
An autopsy detailed in the affidavit showed Durkin suffered a single stab wound to the torso.
The courtroom was full as St. Amour appeared before Judge James Crucitti. Family and friends of the victim were emotional as they waited for the arraignment to start.
St. Amour’s friends appeared to record the proceeding on cell phones, shouting their support as he was escorted out.
The judge ordered St. Amour held without bail.
St. Amour was arrested just after 11 a.m. on Monday near Best Buy at Maple Tree Place in Williston, police said. Officers were actively searching for him, warning the public not to approach.
Essex Police Chief Brad LaRose said a family member spotted St. Amour in a car, called Essex police and stayed on the line as officers worked to apprehend him. By the time Essex officers arrived on scene, Williston PD had St. Amour in custody.
The victim and suspect knew one another, police said, noting the stabbing was not a random act. Investigators are still looking into the circumstances leading up to the confrontation.
According to the affidavit, several witnesses saw the stabbing take place. An unnamed juvenile witness said a physical altercation ensued between the victim and a third party before a knife was pulled.
LaRose said police originally believed St. Amour’s friend might have also been involved in the stabbing but soon determined he was not responsible.
Court documents show St. Amour has been arrested multiple times before and sports several tattoos, including one of a swastika.
At press time, LaRose said his department interviewed 25 witnesses and will continue to talk with folks who saw the incident unfold. A department-wide debriefing will also take place.
The homicide occurred in the last hour of the 10-day event, LaRose said, bringing the Champlain Valley Fair to a saddening close. An assault on the fairgrounds early last week was the only other violent incident of note, he said.
“There’s always going to be incidents that will involve the police,” LaRose said. “Generally speaking, the fair this year [had gone as] smoothly as it has for the past several years.”
Essex officers are largely responsible for policing the event, though they do hire out extra help from other agencies, LaRose said.
Expo communications director Chris Ashby said the grounds already have a firearms ban that is difficult to police. A policy against knives, he said, would be even harder to monitor.
“We certainly don’t want to have a knee-jerk reaction to this incident and put something in place that is ineffective and impractical to enforce,” Ashby said.
Bag checks usually only take place at major concerts or special events and are conducted by private security guards, according to LaRose.
Ashby said the fair might consider implementing those bag checks or metal detectors at the gate but says he doesn’t want to rush any decisions.
“[It was] a very tragic situation that unfolded here in the last hour of what was a very good fair,” Ashby said.
This is only the second fatal incident to happen the fair’s nearly 100-year history, Ashby said. The other was in the 1960s, when a body was found in one of the barns, he said.
LaRose said this is the certainly the most serious crime to happen at the fair in his tenure. He said he understood concerns about security, but cautioned fair-goers to evaluate this event in context.
“Safety is certainly on everyone’s mind,” LaRose said. “But what we have to be cautious of in a situation like this is keeping things in perspective.”
If convicted, St. Amour’s charge carries a sentence of 20 years to life in prison. The next court date was not set at press time.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here