EWSD school board looks at potential funding models for facilities’ renovations

Posted

ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — Ahead of the 2025 budget season, the Essex Westford School District school board looked at different avenues for facilities renovations over the next 10 years at its Tuesday evening meeting.

Facilities master planning

In 2021, facility and construction cost firm Gordian conducted a conditions assessment of all district schools. In October of this year, the district re-engaged Gordian to update their facility conditions assessment data. 

Freeman French Freeman architect Shawn Brennan, who partnered with Gordian on the project, presented the findings at the school board’s Tuesday evening meeting. 

After assessing the 19 buildings and additional sites across the district, Brennan’s team looked at what costs would be for the renovations to the buildings over the next 10 years. Gordian identified areas for renovation in each building, and the timeline by which it would have to be completed. 

Gordian analyzed EWSD facilities through a “facility condition index,” also known as FCI. FCI is a measure that looks at the ratio of facility needs, divided by the asset’s “calculated replacement value.” 

“With a present FCI of 0.41 (or 41%), our district’s buildings collectively fall into the ’Poor category’, signaling a clear need for strategic maintenance and upgrades over the next several years,” said a letter released on the EWSD website. 

Gordian identified the most need for renovation at Essex High School and the Center for Technology, Essex. Upward of $42 million would need to be done in renovations to the schools over the next 10 years, including $20 million in renovations needed within a year of inspection and $10 million needed within two years of inspection.

Essex Middle School comes in second for most-needed renovations, followed by Albert D. Lawton in third and Founders Memorial School in fourth. 

Gordian also identified needs in supporting buildings and other district sites. The Essex Skating Facility and other site elements at EHS and the Center for Technology, Essex were perceived to have the highest renovation needs of support buildings and other sites.

Identified needs were also broken down by category, with Brennan citing that of the total $137 million in identified needs and renovations over a 10-year period for the district, 43% of that is to do with buildings systems such as mechanical and electrical, 33% is to do with cosmetic improvements, 10% is to do with building exteriors, 8% is to do with safety and code compliance and 6% is to do with grounds and utility needs. 

Lastly, as what Brennan described as the “crux” of the presentation, he showed multiple different funding model routes the district could go down when it comes to renovations of their facilities, including what costs would look like to maintain conditions of the buildings as they are now, as well as to improve the conditions of buildings over the next 10 years. 

“It’s a lot of decisions to be made, because you have a lot of buildings…it’s going to be a process to get from point A to point B…there’s no one size fits all,” Brennan said. 

Based on the slides, school board chair Robert Carpenter noted that it would be $40 million over the next 10 years to have “low-level maintenance,” $93 million over 10 years to maintain buildings as they are now and $124 million over 10 years to improve functionality conditions of buildings. 

With all this taken into consideration as the district moves toward budget discussions, EWSD announced it will launch a “community visioning process” that will involve students, educators and other community members with architects and school design experts, and will ask for questions and feedback on how district facilities can best support students.

More information will be provided regarding the visioning process in the spring.

#ernltop, ewsd, schools

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here