ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — In 2020, Burlington High School was shut down when PCBs, a hazardous material, were found in the school. Now Vermont is requiring all schools to test for these materials, and EWSD’s process is set to begin this fall.
The testing of all Vermont schools built or renovated before 1980 is required under Act 74, passed in 2021. Vermont’s Department of Environmental Conservation states the testing will be completed by 2027.
The human-made chemicals were used in everything from paint and ink to caulk and other building materials until PCBs were outlawed by Congress in 1979. Materials that contain PCBs can release the chemical into indoor air.
PCBs can cause serious health problems, according to the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources. The potential for health effects from PCBs depends on how much, how often and how long someone is exposed to them.
Essex Elementary, Essex Middle School, Hiawatha Elementary and Thomas Fleming School were initially scheduled to be tested between the months of July and September, but the school board reported at its Sept. 19 meeting that the four schools are going to be tested in October.
The exact date is unknown, as the state provides a range of October through December for the testing schedule.
“Generally, the entire process has been tracking from 4-6 months,” said Brian Donahue, EWSD's chief operating officer. “We’re scheduled to start some time around October, so we would not be getting any information from the state with this regard until four, five, six months from then.”
When state-approved consultants tour the campuses and take inventory of building material, they will create a plan of spaces to test that best reflect the state of the entire school. Indoor air sampling will be done in a third of all rooms and spaces.
Parents, caregivers and staff should expect the results of each tested room in a letter sent by the school district. The state has prepared letter templates for districts to utilize depending on what the results are.
Burlington High School was demolished in May 2023 after PCB testing found the chemicals throughout the school, at a significantly higher amount than Vermont’s standards at the time. BHS had “dangerously elevated concentrations,” according to Burlington School District’s lawsuit against Monsanto.
This was an extreme case, and the state’s standards for PCBs have since been updated.
“As we look across Vermont, there have not been schools that have been tested that find themselves in the same situation as BHS. There are different levels of PCB and requirements. These have been revised since Burlington's testing,” EWSD Superintendent Beth Cobb told the Reporter.
In the event that the results of PCBs are higher than the “lowest Vermont school action level,” the Vermont Health Department recommends limiting the number of hours the school is in use within six weeks while the consultants work with the DEC to identify the sources of the PCB.
School districts are not required to adhere to this recommendation. The letter template states if the district does not want to follow the health department’s recommendation, it should cut out the sentence “This decision is supported by the Health Department.”
The health department recommends limiting the number of hours in the school if just one room or space is above the lowest action level. Action levels for PCBs are dependent on the age of the students:
-30 ng/m3 (nanograms per cubic meter) for pre-kindergarten
-60 ng/m3 for kindergarten through 6th grade
-100 ng/m3 for 7th grade through adult
The different actionable levels for the three age groups are due to the difference in body weight of children across grades.
“Food is the main non-school source of exposure to PCBs for most people. Younger children are exposed to more PCBs per their body weight from the food they eat. The school action levels take into account the total exposure to PCBs for students and staff from the food they eat,” the ANR states.
The schools about to start the testing process only make up about a third of the 11 schools in the district, not including the Essex Community Education Center which is scheduled to start the testing cycle between the months of January-March.
The state has scheduled Founders Memorial School and Summit Street School between April-June of 2024, Albert D. Lawton School between July-September 2024 and Westford Elementary School between October-December 2024.
Essex High School and the Center for Technology Essex are not currently on the state’s schedule, last updated Sept. 18.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here