Essex Westford School District’s budget survey results are in

Posted

ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — The Essex Westford School District’s community budget survey results are in, with concerns around health insurance costs being front-of-mind. 

This year, the survey saw over 1,100 participants, including 494 parents and caregivers, 349 staff members, 113 current students and 196  community members. 

“In all those [response rate] numbers, it was much greater than what we had seen in prior years,” school board chair Robert Carpenter said at a Dec. 16 meeting. “So again, thank you to our community for being engaged, involved and giving a significant amount of feedback.” 

“One of the highest commented upon items was health insurance and statewide cost drivers,” he added. “So not even anything local to us; it was health insurance. And I want to put this one on the record, because I think we're going to be doing a lot more with this.” 

Some of the responders identified health insurance as the No. 1 problem, noting  taxpayers’ difficulties trying to  cover insurance increases on top of their own while expressing a desire to see something done about the cost of premiums with a systemic, state-level reform. 

As explained by Carpenter, 80% of the budget goes to staffing, with health insurance benefits raising tax bills the most. Being that these are negotiated by the state under Governor Phil Scott’s direction, folks also demonstrated an understanding that many of the cost drivers are outside of the district’s control. 

“These are the sentiments of our community,” Carpenter said. “And I think our community is finally starting to see that our board has zero control over health insurance.” 

Since 2018, the cost of health insurance has increased by over $7 million, forcing school budgets to limit spending in other key areas to accommodate skyrocketing premiums. The coming year’s health insurance premiums for staff is set to increase by 7.3%. 

The other items in the report at the top of the list of community concerns were primarily focused on how the district can continue to prioritize quality core academic instruction, as well as making sure needed facility repairs are addressed and invested in in a timely manner, particularly among parents. 

“There was definitely an appetite to invest now, not to continue kicking the can down the road,” Carpenter said. 

Many of Vermont’s schools are critically aging or reaching the end of their safely-usable lifespans, despite dedicated and conscientious use and maintenance, including in EWSD. More detail on EWSD’s facility needs can be found here. 

According to survey summaries, the cost to maintain buildings will increase year-over-year to the point at which maintenance costs will approach a large percentage of replacement costs. At that point, the district will either need to pay unprecedented rates to maintain buildings, or build new facilities. 

The projected cost of maintaining current building integrity for the next decade is $137 million. 

Other big themes from the survey are as follows: 

  • The prioritization of teachers and other student-facing staff and concerns about class sizes; 

  • Strong and conflicting opinions as to the future of Westford Elementary; 

  • Concerns about a “top-heavy” district and a desire to trim indirect administrative staff costs; 

  • The desire to maintain AP and honors classes, the Center for Technology Essex and special education; 

  • The urge to address overcrowding and deteriorating buildings, particularly at Hiawatha and Fleming; 

  • Support for preserving arts and extracurricular opportunities for academic and social-emotional reasons; 

  • Mixed views on the future of school transportation; 

  • Conflicting opinions on the need for counseling and support services; 

  • Discourse on whether EWSD is overspending on technology; 

  • And an overarching concern about taxpayer affordability. 

The meeting also centered some guidance and guardrails to support the finance committee in the development of next year’s budget proposal. That committee will meet Dec. 18, Jan. 8, Jan. 22, Feb. 5, Feb. 19 and March 5. The board will continue to research and review all existing factors as it balances its new budget, with multiple opportunities for public engagement and then ultimately finalize the fiscal year 2027 budget to present to voters this coming April. 

The board is considering possible budget scenarios, with an intent to focus on maintaining level programming, addressing facility needs and fund balance reserves to support that work, with a plan to revisit these decisions, and a general overview slated for its yet-to-be scheduled January meeting — while acknowledging the importance of early information dissemination to avoid community shock. 

As for expected salary increases, the district is entering into contract negotiations with staff again currently, and the administration expects to know more later about those impacts to the budget at a later date.

The board also anticipates receiving a more clear projection for the Common Level of Appraisal for FY27 via a state tax letter in January, informing further budget development. 

The results of the budget survey, with some additional context, are accessible here.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here