Essex Westford School District to repurpose Summit Street School; board finalizes $94.7 budget

Posted

ESSEX WESTFORD SCHOOL DISTRICT — The school board approved a level budget of $94.7 million last Tuesday, effectively closing Summit Street School and moving Westford middle school students to Essex Middle School. 

Over the course of a four-hour meeting Feb. 18, the board debated the budget’s two biggest changes within the confines of its December decision to maintain level net education spending for fiscal year 2026.

The meeting included over an hour of public comment, as dozens of community members filled the room. 

The board could have voted to grow the budget, even marginally, but ultimately re-affirmed its decision — which aims to stave off double-digit increases for taxpayers — in a vote 7-1. 

“I really struggle with raising the tax rate,” board member Ann Marie Sharp said. “The world we’re in is a scary one. I worry about being able to afford groceries tomorrow…I think that’s true of a lot of people.” 

Summit Street change 

Level net education spending means the district needs to absorb nearly $6 million worth of cuts, as costs outside of the district’s control have increased, like healthcare and contracted staff salaries. 

Effectively closing Summit Street School and moving its 187 K-3 students to nearby Hiawatha Elementary School saves the district approximately $1.2 million. 

Several positions would be eliminated in this consolidation of Essex Junction schools, including a nurse, office coordinator, principal, library media specialist, student management specialist, school substitute, three facility staff and three classroom teachers. The board voted to move the Summit Street counselor to Hiawatha. 

Under this plan, Summit Street School would be repurposed as the home base for the district’s ARC program, which serves approximately 20 students in grades 3-8 with specialized needs.

Hiawatha principal Katherine Grykien said Summit and Hiawatha have been “sister schools” for several years now, and collaboration among staff would continue in order to make the transition as seamless as possible.  

“We would have a transition process that would be welcoming and collaborative, and I want to make sure the families and the faculty and staff and Summit Street School know that,” Grykien said at the meeting. 

Despite this sentiment, some Summit Street parents are disappointed and frustrated with the decision.  

“Summit Street School is an integral part of our community,” Matthew Vaughn, a parent of two Summit students, said. “The burden of these proposed budget cuts falls disproportionately on Essex Junction’s youngest students…I do not believe this is fair or necessary.” 

“Many in our community would be willing to support a reasonable tax increase to maintain current programming and keep Summit Street School open,” he added. 

Board member Christine Gaynor-Patterson passionately urged the board to consider re-instating Summit Street, making a motion to find $1.2 million to cut elsewhere, but the motion failed in a 2.5-4.5 vote, with one member abstaining. 

“I would not be doing my due diligence if we did not have a robust discussion,” she said. 

Superintendent Beth Cobb argued this realignment of facilities is the best option, with district leaders having already turned over every stone. Gaynor-Paterson asked the cuts to come from areas that do not directly support student instruction, but Cobb said that would be near impossible. 

“There is nothing more to drain from the district office,” Cobb said. “It would be devastating to schools if we started cutting administrators and our supports that wrap around our schools.” 

Last year, EWSD cut three of its 11 district administration positions after the FY2025 budget failed to pass on the first vote.

Westford move 

The board considered pausing the move of Westford’s 60 grade 6-8 students to Essex Middle School, but ultimately decided in a vote 5-3 to go ahead after weighing the alternative. 

Moving Westford middle school to EMS saves the district approximately $277,000. If the board had decided not to move the students, it instead would have eliminated one licensed staff member from EMS and two additional Howard Center clinicians, moving the total number of cut clinicians to five. 

Erin Maguire, co-director of student support services, said further reducing mental health support would increase each clinician's caseload. Already, the system is overloaded, with each clinician working with 12-15 students on a regular basis. 

She said schools have taken on more responsibilities in the mental health space in recent years as community partners struggle to recruit staff and provide services. 

“It calls on us to have some conversations with our legislators about funding our mental health agencies to be able to do the work they need to do,” Maguire said. “To say that this district needs to cover all of it is part of the dilemma.”

Class sizes 

Re-alignment of grades and the repurposing of school facilities would lead to an increase in average class sizes across the district. The average class size for grades K-3 would shift from 17 to approximately 19 students. The average size for grades 4-8 would shift from 20 to an average of 22. 

At the Feb. 18 meeting, elementary and middle school principals said staff would be able to handle the increase of 2-3 students per classroom. 

“Do I want to go to 30? No,” Thomas Fleming School principal Matthew Roy said. “But do I think at 24 we can provide a high quality education for our students? I do,” he added. 

Westford School principal Marcie Lewis shared some examples of practical changes that occur when students are added to a classroom. In Kindergarten for instance, it might take more time for a class to move throughout the building or to get dressed for recess. 

In middle school, a teacher might have to spend a bit more time gaining and managing students’ attention and curbing socialization. 

“[Yet] over and over again, during the pandemic and post-pandemic, my teachers have shown me they know how to address the needs of students,” Lewis said. “We have some of the best teachers in the state.”

Essex Elementary School principal Ashley Gray agreed the increased class sizes will be manageable, but only with the same level of staff support. The district should maintain its academic coaches and interventionists, she said. 

Gray also acknowledged that in the end, these changes to class sizes will result in a reduction in classroom teachers, and that is a hard pill to swallow. 

“I also think it needs to be said that no one is advocating to lose amazing professionals who work in our building,” she said. 

Pre-K changes 

Following community feedback, the board voted to create a third Pre-K site, adding one to the Junction. Administrators had previously proposed a reduction to two sites at Essex Elementary and Westford. 

The new site will be located at either Thomas Fleming School or Summit Street School, at the determination of administrators. This will eliminate the need for vans to transport students from the Junction to EES. 

Board Chair Robert Carpenter said the board would re-evaluate the Pre-K program again next year.

As for what’s next, Essex Junction, Essex Town and Westford will head to the polls April 8 to vote on the budget. The board will continue to weigh-in on the budget’s implementation. 

“We continue to check in over the course of the year, is this implementation working?” Carpenter said. “If not, that is when our oversight as a board comes into play.” 

#ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here