Essex Town Manager files motion to alter state decision concerning Saxon Hill development

Posted

TOWN OF ESSEX — The Town of Essex is revisiting the steep slopes criterion that blocked a development in Saxon Hill Industrial Park. 

Back in April, the District 4 Environmental Commission denied a permit for a new road and subdivision proposed by Allen Brook Development. Essex Town Manager Greg Duggan has since made a motion to alter the denial, citing the decision would hinder future development in the town. 

Allen Brook Development’s plan consists of 4,100 linear-feet of public roadway leading through the property and eventually to the site of a proposed Amazon distribution center. The Division 4 Environmental Commission denied Allen Brook Development based on Act 250 criterion 10, conformance with the Town of Essex’s 2024 town plan’s steep slope criteria. 

Duggan said his motion is not related to the potential Amazon facility, which was denied by the town’s development review board in July 2025. Representatives for the project later appealed the decision in a separate case to Vermont’s Environmental Court. The court case is ongoing. 

“Our opinion is that operating under this absolute interpretation would be impractical and extremely restrictive,” Duggan’s motion said. “[...] Recall that a slope of 20% or greater exists anywhere vertical elevation increases by 1 foot over a 5-foot span. This circumstance occurs at least once on most parcels in Essex.”

During this past Monday’s selectboard meeting, 11 Essex residents voiced their concerns with Duggan’s letter. The Alliance of Concerned Residents Envisioning Solutions, an Essex-based group formed in response to the Amazon facility, claimed Duggan’s motion was flawed in relation to the steep slopes criterion and asserted the motion is related to the Amazon facility because the Allen Brook development is necessary for the construction of the Amazon site.  

ACRES and additional community members spoke about the importance of adhering to the town plan’s steep slopes criteria for the benefit of public safety. 

“The motion, as it was written, conflicts with what the town sets out,” ACRES founder Anne Miller said. “The town is very clear about steep slope regulations.”

Duggan filed the formal motion to alter the Environmental Division's decision citing the steep slope criteria as “counter to the community’s goals for growth” and needing additional guidance to interpret. 

According to town management, the town is looking into ways to possibly amend the steep slopes criteria within its zoning regulations and town plan. The Town of Essex Planning Commission organized a working group seeking to clarify it. The working group would specify when the criteria applies and developers are to use it. 

Changes to the steep slopes criteria would adhere to the same process of updating zoning regulations beginning with the approval of the planning commission after a public hearing, followed by an approval of the selectboard after two public hearings. The process would likely take several months. 

In addition to zoning regulations, there would need to be changes to the town plan, which the selectboard and planning commission would approve. Voters would then decide to approve the town plan alterations in a ballot article before the changes would go into effect.

When Miller spoke at the May 4 Selectboard meeting, she said Duggan’s motion did not have the sentiment of Essex residents in mind. 

“In the end, your job is to represent the interests of all of the residents,” Miller said to the selectboard and town manager. “Not a single land owner. What do all of the residents benefit from?” 

Miller said if the townspeople do not like the town plan or zoning regulations, then the town can change those items, but the motion as it stands opposes both the town plan and zoning as well as the well-being of Essex residents. 

Duggan opened the floor to the selectboard, asking the selectboard if they would like him to respond differently in the future. Selectboard member Meg Zimmerman asked if there was a precedent about when the selectboard or the town manager speaks on behalf of the town. 

Vice Chair Ethan Lawrence said the town manager has complete authority to communicate on behalf of the town. The issue, Lawrence said, concerned the development review board more than the selectboard. However, he asked the public to address the selectboard because he said the selectboard is responsible for the town manager. 

“I want to give my full support to Greg. I was fully aware of this the entire time,” Lawrence said. “We knew there was a short timeline, and I didn’t think it was appropriate to discuss at the last selectboard meeting under executive session.” 

Selectboard members Andy Watts and Kendall Chamberlin followed Lawrence with their support for Duggan’s motion. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here