Essex talks carry on over proposed women’s correctional facility

Posted

ESSEX TOWN — The Essex Planning Commission considered rezoning two potentially-viable sites for a new state-proposed women’s correctional facility.  

At the July 10 meeting, attendees raised concerns about unclear intel from the state, possible impacts on traffic, taxes and local services, fear of major hits to property values and concerns over potential for future changes in facility usage. The public also criticized state cooperation with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, as some state prisons have held ICE detainees. 

Though both parcels under consideration are state-owned, the build would require a zoning change. One site is adjacent to Susie Wilson Bypass, off Colchester Road near the dump on Landfill Lane, and the other off of River Road near its intersection with North Williston Road. 

The state argues it needs a new prison because of declining and even inhumane conditions at the dated South Burlington facility, which has fallen into disrepair. Locals in favor of the project say they want to step up in offering better to women in need of healing. 

The planning commission made no decisions on the facility at this meeting. 

More information is slated to come this fall. 

Although the Department of Corrections has adopted a more rehabilitation-centered philosophy for prisons in Vermont, critics have been sounding off on the new plan. Some say too many inmates would still be under too high-security of conditions, while others claim the prison is just too big. Others still worrie about staffing, ethics, proximity to schools and residential areas, and a fear of property tax increases. 

The Vermont ACLU, for instance, has been pushing back on the project since its inception, stating the continued reliance on “mass incarceration” is out of line with Vermont’s values. Other advocacy representatives, such as those from the organization Free Her, have argued Vermont could instead invest in bail reform, substance use disorder treatment, services for survivors of domestic violence and affordable housing for those otherwise in prison, all at a lower price tag. 

The proposal has been underway for years, with the state’s eyes on Essex since last August. 

Big ideas, bigger questions 

In addition to discussing the women’s facility, the planning commission last night questioned whether the state would consider using whichever site is not chosen for the prison for a new youth detention center, given recent news that the state’s latest youth center is no longer moving forward at its originally-proposed site in Vergennes. 

“I think it's worth the question now as well for talking about two different sites [in Essex] that could be potentially viable,” said member Ian Carroll, bringing the idea to light. “Is there an opportunity where the state might consider using both Essex sites now, and trying to build the youth center on the opposite side of the women’s facility?” 

The state has no formal plans for Essex Town to be a potential host for the youth center. 

But, as discussions about the women’s facility continue some residents have also noted a good deal of opposition to the prison is coming from outsiders not residing in town, pointing to a “letter-writing campaign” largely undertaken by Vermonters from other municipalities, with the intention of dissuading Essex from hosting a new prison at all. 

Ultimately, the planning commission felt more information from the state was needed before proceeding, having found the state’s most recent set of responses to town inquiries inadequate and too vague — some speculating perhaps even “deliberately” so. 

Hence, the commission will invite folks from the state to a larger public meeting in October — likely Oct. 9, pending state availability — for further discussion on the proposal, so the state DOC can respond to remaining questions directly. 

Remaining uncertainties include, among others, a need to better understand the projected impacts to workload and response times of local emergency response services, a need to better understand the proximity to and capacity of public transportation for inmates to get to work upon beginning re-entry, and a need to clarify whether the facility will house inmates from out of state. 

The state can then hash out with more detail its metrics for success at the new facility, before any more-permanent zoning changes are made in town to allow the project to move forward. 

Essex resident and former Democratic state senator Irene Wrenner was the legislative lead for the new correctional facility, and she spent some time Thursday dissuading public concerns. Wrenner said she doesn’t want to make inmates at the South Burlington facility wait any longer to transfer. 

“Conditions really don’t need to wait another three months for us to decide to change the zoning,” she said. “It’s heartbreaking to me that we would make them wait until October.” 

“I’m not happy that ICE is using our facilities either,” she added. “But it’s the governor who’s going to renegotiate whether or not ICE is allowed to deposit people in our only women’s facility… So please direct your questions to your state reps, senators and the governor.” 

She continued to stress the dire need for better conditions than those offered by the current facility as reason to prioritize swiftly moving forward — and the diversity and economic activity the project would add to town. 

“I think it's really important that we show the world that Essex is not what people think it is, that we are open,” she said. “There's a town nearby, I won't mention which one it is. Their motto is ‘small town, big heart.’ And now that we're a smaller town, I would hope that we can think about having a bigger heart — in helping these women who need a second chance.” 

When controversies combine 

In addition to its discussion of the women’s correctional facility, the planning commission also discussed a possible rezoning of the Resource Protection District buffer in Saxon Hill Industrial Park, where a site applicant has been pushing to build an Amazon distribution center in town. 

Among others, some of the ideas floated during that discussion pushed for erosion control and possibly expanding the square footage of buffer requirements and modifying the buffer to also cover noise and air quality — though no decisions were made, nor votes yet taken at this time. 

With both possible developments looming heavy on the horizon, a number of residents are worried. 

“You’re talking about a women's prison, everyone’s talking about Amazon, now you mentioned the youth detention center,” said Essex resident Debbie Gregory. “I don't think any of those things are a positive thing. If all three get approved, it's not going to be a real nice place to live.” 

Though mixed feelings filled the room, numerous members of the public in attendance agreed. 

“If the town approves this, it will be a betrayal,” said Essex resident Su Ughetti, positing all of the above proposals fall out of line with the vision outlined in the town plan, and questioning the purpose of having such a plan if it is to be disregarded in regulations. “This is a democracy right — kind of? If this is a democratic process, the public needs to be involved and invested.”  

Both projects are in pre-approved phases, and the youth center was not even a proposal, but rather just an idea Carroll figured the state might consider engaging. Carroll said he’d highly doubt the speculation that all three would land in town, especially the youth center. 

“I think all are terrible assets, but a combination of all three would be disastrous,” Gregory said. "It's supposed to be a wonderful town, but I think it’s going to ruin our reputation.” 

Planning commission member Dustin Bruso pointed out the town has historically been host to a correctional facility already at Woodside Juvenile Rehabilitation Center, questioning whether that facility had at all “ruined” the town. 

Other residents with mixed feelings pointed to Woodside as an example of what could go wrong. 

The facility was permanently shuttered in 2020, partly on account of federal lawsuits alleging excessive use of force on children-inmates. 

“When [Woodside] was built, it was a great idea,” said Essex resident Diane Percy, who’s lived here for over 30 years. “I was teaching at the time… We sent kids there all the time… But when you have changes of leadership and decisions — as we saw, things can go pretty awry.” 

“Today it’s a women’s concept,” she added. “In the future, it will be what they need it to be.” 

More on the women’s correctional and re-entry center proposal, the existing Q&A between the planning commission and Vermont DOC, letters from the public about the proposition, and more on other agenda items, can be found in last night’s planning commission meeting materials.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here