ESSEX TOWN — The Essex Selectboard shot down a resolution April 6 to opt into Tier 1B land use designation for neighborhoods surrounding Route 15 between I-289 and Jericho Road.
Opting into Tier 1B allows housing projects up to 50 units on 10 acres or less to be exempt from permitting for Act 250. The designation is part of Act 181, passed by the Vermont Legislature in 2024 to accelerate housing development. Tier 1B does not override local zoning.
Selectboard member Andy Watts and new Board Chair Shannon Jackson voted in favor of the resolution. Members Kendall Chamberlin and Ethan Lawrence voted against the resolution followed by Meg Zimmerman after she attempted to abstain.
Monday night’s meeting also served as the board’s reorganizational meeting. Jackson is now the chair, Lawrence the vice chair and Zimmerman the clerk.
Katherine Sonnick, Essex’s community development director, brought the resolution before the selectboard with support from Charlie Baker, executive director of Chittenden County Regional Planning Commission.
Lawrence voiced his opposition to the resolution citing it had not significantly changed since the selectboard voted 2-3 against its first iteration in June. The difference in the second resolution was the removal of a partial region along the midsection of the plan from the Tier 1B designation.
Lawrence said he was “lacking to see the benefit” of Tier 1B since Act 181 does not require the developer to “pass that savings onto the consumer.” He is concerned developers would not build affordable housing with the added financial incentives, but instead benefit from the waived fees for Act 250 permitting, market the housing for the same rate and reap a greater profit.
“All I see is giving the developers a bonus,” Lawrence said. “And taking away another set of eyes for accountability.”
Baker said he was struck by Lawrence's comments and while he was able to “hear” his concerns, the housing market is “very broken” because Vermont has not generated enough supply to keep up with demands for decades in part due to the state’s regulatory demands.
“What we’re trying to do is rebalance the housing market and allow the market to start working more organically to get to a more affordable housing market over time,” Baker said.
In order to comply with Tier 1B designation, a municipality must have adequate water supply and wastewater infrastructure, comply with flood and fluvial erosion rules and bylaws as well as have adopted a planning process and permanent zoning and subdivision bylaws. While permitting requirements are lowered by Tier 1B designation, developers are still constrained by state and municipal zoning regulations and bylaws.
Watts said not opting in would be in opposition to a previous decision to assign some fund balance support to a housing fund. He believed it would put the town “behind the eight ball” and at a disadvantage as compared to other qualifying municipalities who have opted into Tier 1B. He argued housing would as a result be more expensive in the Town of Essex as compared to surrounding municipalities in the long run if the selectboard did not opt in.
“This does not change what can be built or where it can be built, but it may affect how soon it gets built,” Watts said, reminding the selectboard the town was already planning to potentially build high density in these areas.
12 out of 18 qualifying municipalities in Chittenden County have opted into Tier 1B, according to Baker. Colchester along with the Town of Essex has not approved the designation.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here