ESSEX TOWN — Green Mountain Transit’s general manager Clayton Clark presented to the Essex Town selectboard last week to help inform its decision on whether to remain a member.
The town is considering withdrawing its formal membership status to the provider of public transportation, as a result of GMT’s financial strain and dwindling route offerings. No decision was made, but the selectboard is aiming to come to a final decision by the end of June.
If the town chooses to withdraw for fiscal year 2027, it will need to give GMT one year’s notice, and rejoining down the line would involve negotiations with GMT’s board of commissioners. Clark presented alongside Paul Bohne, GMT treasurer and Essex Town’s GMT commissioner.
The bottom line is there will be a $3 million budget gap for FY27 at GMT, with a need to accommodate for it through further service reductions. Changes announced thus far to the #10 route will mostly reduce service to Williston, maintaining rides to Essex and Essex Junction for now.
“We've reduced our annual operating costs by about a million dollars a year,” Clark said. “The #10, which presently connects the Town of Essex and Essex Junction with Williston, had been on the list of the poor performers for about a decade.”
The Vermont Agency of Transportation puts together that list, ranked by expense per passenger. Last year, that was about $21 per ride. The next highest after Route #10 in GMT’s urban transit offerings is just over $10 per ride, driving the #10 toward the chopping block.
The number of rides last year given by the #10 was around 30,000. As a comparison, GMT’s #2 route does almost 500,000 and the #1 does well over 500,000.
Because about 70% of the ridership within the #10 was coming from the loop within Essex Town and Essex Junction, GMT is cutting Williston from the loop and reverting to a previous version of the route, a circulator through the Essex area, which had been successful before.
That change in particular is likely to go into effect either in June or August this summer.
But there are still more cuts on the horizon, yet to be determined, in the years ahead.
“When I'm trying to guess the future and what's likely to happen, I see a very wide range,” Clark said. “I could see us having to cut another $3 million worth of service as a potential outcome. I could also see we are starting to get some folks at the Statehouse who are worried about these cuts, and I could potentially see us having already gone through all the cuts that we need to do.”
“Unfortunately, we won't know what our FY27 budget will be until about a year from now,” he added. “And so what that means is we are probably going to be back in another pattern where we are wondering what's going to happen to the #10.”
There’s no penalty to the town for rejoining after discontinuing a membership, but all new memberships require fresh negotiations for contributions for equipment, buses and stations, and making a decision now as a town would mean making a best guess through a lot of unknowns.
Selectboard member Ethan Lawrence told Clark he is not against GMT’s efforts or public transit at large — he’s just considering the best financial choice for residents.
“It's not a jab by any means,” Lawrence said. “I just wanted to thank you.”
Clark himself is a resident of Essex, and agrees it's important to look out for the taxpayers.
The Town of Colchester receives GMT’s services and SSTA services, despite Colchester’s lack of membership. The big difference between them and the Town of Essex is that, as a member, the Town of Essex has voting power. The downside of that is GMT can assess voting members.
Member municipality assessments look at the contributions and share of usage by member municipalities in connection with GMT’s budget annually to decide whether membership fees need to increase and by how much. The cost of each assessment is levied through the taxpayers’ contributions to their town’s general budget, and is paid to GMT every July.
And although Colchester doesn't have a vote, if the town has questions or concerns about what they're paying GMT, they can negotiate it, because GMT can't legally force them to pay.
“Colchester's town manager is a former assistant general manager for GMT,” Clark said, of Colchester’s Aaron Frank. “I think he is a really brilliant human. I would recommend talking to him, because I think he has set up Colchester pretty well.”
Essex Town Manager Greg Duggan pointed out another difference: that Colchester is situated between municipalities that have service, so there's a line running through regardless, which is not likely to change. If Essex were to leave, GMT doesn’t have a need to go to Essex anymore.
As members, Duggan sees Essex in a position with more negotiating power to keep service.
Selectboard member Kendall Chamberlain noted that if the town withdraws, GMT has a charter provision noting the town would still be liable for existing indebtedness, but Clark said there is no existing indebtedness to be considered, as GMT has not done any bonding.
Per a question from selectboard member Andy Watts, Clark said Colchester receives non-emergency medical transportation entirely through Medicaid, as well as older and disabled persons transportation, which is offered everywhere in the state through VTrans and SSTA.
Generally, communities that have GMT service don't contribute much for O and D because they already have access to that service. Clark wasn’t sure if Colchester contributed any extra, but if they did, they would essentially just be buying more rides.
“One of the things that you all do for cost containment is your senior van, which you would be able to continue leasing from us, whether you had an agreement with us or not,” Clark said. “The senior van is actually taking folks who otherwise would be traveling the O and D program that VTrans would be funding.”
Watts also asked about GMT’s aid in helping students get transportation to school.
“If we were to leave, are they left high and dry, because there's no bus anymore?” he asked.
Indeed, that GMT bus is handled through an arrangement with the municipality, not through the school — unlike the EWSD classic yellow school bus fleet.
If GMT can find some additional revenue sources, it would offset the higher cost per rider of that bus — though it’s been a challenge supporting routes like this one.
“Everybody is trying to pick everyone else's pocket these days,” Clark said. “And we're finding most pockets pretty empty, but that certainly is something that we would want to explore.”
In re-working the Essex circulator, Clark hopes the bus schedule will be more in line with school district schedules, which may help ultimately to save the #10 altogether.
Leaving GMT as a member could put the school district at a disadvantage. Figuring it out this year would be ideal, so the school can plan around such a decision in constructing its own budget. Sometime this fall, it will be clear how much student ridership is on the re-worked #10 circulator.
Clark said ultimately, the preservation or termination of that route isn’t based on whether or not the town remains a member — but rather, upon whether GMT is able to run that route efficiently. It’s also possible that if the town remains a member, the #10 still ends up having to be cut.
“But as a Town of Essex taxpayer, I would definitely want to make sure that we had an arrangement that meant that you weren't paying something for nothing,” Clark said.
Garry Scott, interim director of operations for the Essex Westford School District, came forward during the meeting to note how critical the GMT service has been to students in light of district budget cuts — this year by $6 million, with future cuts to come likely impacting EWSD busing.
Scott advocated for trying hard to keep the service going, as over 1,100 student rides happen on the GMT route in heavier use months. This figure is likely inclusive of district students from outside of the town, as it traverses along both Route 15 and Sand Hill Road.
This will remain a part of the loop route being planned for the #10, for the time being.
“It's critical to us to have that service,” Scott said. “Especially for high school students, who struggle to get into the door. We've been seeing significant absenteeism since COVID-19… This is an alarm for us going off.”
“We've done some other things, to have a late arrival for our high school students, to sort of fix our other bussing issues that we have,” he added. “We want to get as many routes as we can get in the door. We need them. We're struggling already to get kids into school.”
Scott also said the school is struggling to meet its student needs with its own internal transportation capacity — GMT’s route not only assists with this, but also enables kids to do extracurriculars outside of regular school hours.
More to come on this as the selectboard approaches a decision.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here