Essex Selectboard approves fiscal year 2026 budget for Town Meeting Day ballot

Posted

Essex Town — The Essex selectboard finalized a 4.76% budget increase for fiscal year 2026, amounting to a budget of about $16 million if voter-approved. 

The finalized municipal budget was adopted Monday night in the precise amount of $16,365,963, with support from three out of five selectboard members, and Ethan Lawrence and Kendall Chamberlin voting against its passage. 

This budget amount excludes human services funding, which will be voted on Town Meeting Day as a separate ballot item. 

The primary function of last night’s meeting was to provide the public opportunity to comment. Just one resident showed up to make his voice heard, but selectboard members had their own points of contention. Here’s what they had to say. 

Community concerns 

Essex resident Walter Adams has lived on Indian Brooke Road for 50 years, and up until about 10 years ago, he was pretty happy to live there. Now, he says, it’s getting too expensive. 

In particular, Adams is displeased with the selectboard’s approach to funding the capital budget. 

Per a Jan. 6 discussion, the selectboard chose to move a $250,000 leftover fund balance, formerly designated for future tax rate reductions, to the capital budget — a fund used for future projects larger than can be managed by traditional operating budgets, and for unanticipated emergency expenses, like flood recovery efforts. 

Other revenue sources agreed upon at the Jan. 6 meeting to support the 2026 capital budget and its associated five-year plan include a transfer of $216,000 from the fiscal year 2026 operating budget over to capital, and another $500,836 from the FY2024 end year fund balance, in addition to revenues from a capital tax totaling $487,000, plus some interest revenue. 

The purpose of the capital budgeting process is to “save up” over time for big expenses that can’t reasonably be taxed for all in one year. In the long run, it aims to save taxpayers’ money by avoiding or reducing reliance on loans that would cost them extra money in interest. 

But Adams would like to see the selectboard take that $250,000 fund balance initially meant to be used for future taxpayer relief and apply it instead to next year’s operating budget, reducing the amount residents that year have to keep pay in. 

“I'd like to see the taxpayers get their money back, by way of reducing the budget,” Adams said, addressing the selectboard. “Or at least [altering] the use of those funds to reduce the tax rate.” 

The other concern Adams mentioned is the appropriation of a full 1% of the total operating budget over to human services specifically, particularly given that the selectboard had thought it was a good idea already to remove about $3,000 out of the library’s budget. 

“You can find $150,000 for [human services] and you can't give the library what they want for money? And then instead, you want to build them a 20,000 square foot building, and God knows how much money is needed to make a 20,000 square foot building work,” Adams said. 

Selectboard member Dawn Fleury asked Adams to clarify whether he’d prefer the town not fund human services at all, to which he replied he just thought 1% was too big a portion of the pie. 

The proposition on the table — approved later that evening as a ballot item — was to appropriate 1% of the total year’s operating budget to human services contributions. Local area social, health and human services nonprofit organizations are eligible to receive these funds. 

“There's no other community funding human services to a level that we are,” Adams said. “I was on the selectboard in 1979, and it was difficult for the selectboard back then to find $1,500 to give to the Little League Baseball team — and suddenly there's $150,000 to spend? I mean, I understand there's certainly a need, but you have to decide how much is too much.” 

Adams is concerned about how the future expansion of town offices and other municipal spaces will impact resident tax bills, not only with the tens of millions of dollars of construction to pay off, but also with the utility costs and bigger custodial services that come with an expanded space. 

“Based on your comments, I think you'll be happy the budget we're hoping to approve and pass to the ballot this evening does not include the amount for the human services funding,” said selectboard chair Tracey Delphia. “That will be a completely separate question on the ballot.” 

But Adams also expressed discontent with the way the ballot is structured: That folks either have to vote yes or no on that item, rather than having the ability to vote to reduce it to a lower amount — resulting in running the risk of not having any money at all for human services, or having to put it to a second or perhaps even a third vote, depending on initial voter support. 

But Adams wasn’t the only one in the room with two cents to offer — or to be taken. 

As it is, town representatives say the capital tax hasn’t been adequate on its own as a funding source for capital needs. So, Town Manager Greg Duggan suggested the next step to improving capital funding would be to ask voters if they want to raise the capital tax by two cents. 

This would alter the current three cents on every $1,000 worth of property, to a future five cents. 

“If that passes, that would roughly cover the $250,000 that we reduced from the operating budget,” he said. “If that capital tax vote fails, then yes, to keep our capital funding where we think it should be, we would probably be looking at adding that back in, or some amount back into operating transfers. For the sake of discussion, $250,000.” 

Delphia suggested such a change would put the Town in a much better financial position than it was in the direct wake of its municipal separation from the Junction, and would also serve to increase transparency around how the Town funds capital. 

Lawrence said if such a ballot measure were approved by voters, then the $216,000 transfer to capital from the FY2026 budget should be removed from the general budget entirely. 

Even if it weren’t approved, he argued the town would have plenty of fund balance to backfill the void, via a year-end fund balance that he expects to be large enough to cover for it next year — and if there weren’t enough there, he proposed dipping into reserves and recovering it later. 

“That’s our emergency fund,” Delphia said, pointing out the risk of making a move like that. 

“In the case of an absolutely zero surplus next year in the budget, that would be the situation,” Lawrence agreed. “But in the case of a surplus, you would be pretty even washed.” 

Adams chimed back in from the crowd around this point in the conversation to share concern that the capital budget would be overfunded regardless, reiterating a desire for tax relief.  

However, Deputy Town Manager Karen Adams said the five-year plan shows that even with the proposed increase in capital tax, the town will still encounter a budgetary deficit in fiscal year 2030 on account of projected needs for vehicle replacements and stormwater at that time — the fact is, the town is behind on its responsibility to proactively save for its future capital needs. 

“I'll speak for myself and make recommendations to the selectboard and future selectboards,” Duggan said. “I don't think we're going to be looking to fund more capital than we need.” 

Walter Adams asked if the town had ever taken funds out of the reserve, and was told it happened in the wake of Hurricane Sandy and other flood events. It was reimbursed by federal government money, and saved taxpayers money they’d otherwise have paid in loan interest. 

Outcome of selectboard votes 

The selectboard last night voted in favor of approving a fiscal year 2026 Green Mountain Transit special assessment tax. 

The special assessment would support the public transportation bussing service, which is dealing with financial strain in the wake of post-pandemic-era funding constraints and climbing costs of labor and operating. 

For it to go into effect, all legislative bodies of GMT member municipalities would have to vote unanimously to support the proposed special assessment. Essex Junction — and all other municipalities that have taken it up thus far — have been generally favorable to the move. 

Lawrence and Dawn Hill-Fleury voted no, but the motion still carried three to two. The share for the Town of Essex during fiscal year 2026 for the special assessment totals $4,098, and GMT will only spend that money if the organization deems it necessary. 

The selectboard also voted to approve the adopted municipal budget — though Lawrence had attempted a motion to amend the budget by lowering it by $256,0000 that failed. 

He hoped to eliminate the $216,000 in taxes that were moved from the operating budget to capital budget, as well as to eliminate $40,000 in salary and benefits to turn a few part-time employee salaries into compensation packages for full-time community development positions. 

Nobody seconded Lawrence’s motion. The original motion to approve the un-amended fiscal year 2026 budget passed with a vote of three to two, Lawrence and Chamberlin nays. 

With a few details needing a bit more time and clarification, the approval for the capital budget and its affiliated five-year plan has been tabled, deferred for one last vote at the Feb. 3 meeting. 

The selectboard voted three-to-two to put a question on the ballot about increasing the capital tax rate by two cents. Hill-Fleury and Lawrence voted against the motion. 

The selectboard also solidified the human services budget as a separate article on the TMD ballot, allowing voters to elect whether to appropriate 1% of the general fund budget to a human services contributions fund, with just Chamberlin voting against the motion. 

There will be an informational hearing for folks to learn more about the budget and ask questions at 7:30 p.m. at Essex Middle School, March 3. The vote will be held Town Meeting Day, Tuesday, March 4. 

Stay tuned with the Reporter to view a full list of candidates for local public office. 

#ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here