Essex selectboard approves bonus for Town Manager; Current year budget updated to account for new capital tax rate

Posted

ESSEX JUNCTION — The selectboard extended a bonus of $3,000 to Town Manager Greg Duggan via a unanimous vote at its meeting this last Monday. 

Duggan’s current salary is $143,858. In 2024, he was the third-highest-paid employee of the municipality, after two police positions. The memo proposing his bonus, as sent to the selectboard, came as a request from Duggan himself. 

Justification for awarding the bonus, as funded by taxpayer dollars, was Duggan’s “achievement of [mutually agreed upon] fiscal year 2025 goals and objectives,” according to the memo. 

The selectboard’s discussion about whether and why to give the requested bonus took place in private, during an executive session, with Duggan present. Evaluation of a public employee is allowed to be discussed in executive session, per state law. 

Bonuses are not specifically budgeted for in advance, and are considered “rare,” Selectboard Chair Tracey Delphia said. The possibility of a bonus for the town manager is part of that particular employment contract. 

“No staff positions are commonly considered for bonuses, apart from the annual possibility for the town manager,” Delphia stated in a Sept. 22 email to the Reporter. “Fiscal responsibility is front of mind for the selectboard and is reflected in our goals regularly.” 

Per Duggan’s contract, a bonus may be awarded to the town manager “for his achievement of mutually agreed upon goals.” In the first quarter of each fiscal year, if the town manager requests a bonus, the selectboard reviews whether to grant a bonus, based on his accomplishment of the goals set during the prior fiscal year. 

Essex’s previous town manager got a $5,000 bonus in 2018 and a $3,000 bonus both in 2019 and 2020. Duggan received a $1,000 bonus in 2022, did not request a bonus in 2023, received a $3,500 bonus in 2024 and the most recent $3,000 bonus this year. 

At the Sept. 15 meeting, the selectboard also approved an update to the Town of Essex’s fiscal year 2026 capital budget. 

The capital budget supports large capital projects, such as building renovations and equipment purchases, in the current fiscal year. This mid-year update was made because when the budget was drafted and adopted in January, the town didn’t know whether or not voters would approve a capital tax rate increase, which was on the ballot in March — sure enough, on Town Meeting Day, they did. 

Essex voters approved an increase of the capital tax rate from three cents to five cents, for the purpose of financing capital projects and equipment, which is expected to generate $324,840 in additional revenues per year. 

“One of the pieces that follows the approval of an additional two cents on the capital tax rate is what to do with those revenues, since they weren't built into the capital budget that was adopted in January,” Assistant Town Manager Karen Adams said to the selectboard. 

After considering capital needs which appeared after January, and revisiting priority projects that went un- or under-funded within the adopted budget, staff recommended the selectboard direct the additional capital funding to the following projects.  

All of their following recommendations were approved by the selectboard Monday night. 

Newly-funded projects and purchases 

  • A deposit of $14,840 into the library elevator reserve, to contribute to replacing mechanical controls expected to be needed within about five years, which will cost a total of over $150,000; 

  • An infusion of $25,000 to put toward library improvements for safety, including railing replacements, concrete repair, planter repointing and public wireless access points; 

  • Putting $40,000 toward parks truck replacement, to add onto the $30,000 already set aside in the original capital budget for this purpose, as the existing truck is badly in need of replacement — this will provide enough funding to place an order, with delivery anticipated within approximately six months; 

  • Adding $50,000 in additional funds allocated toward Indian Brook dam repairs; 

  • Contributing $195,000 toward a salt shed, replacing what the town had hoped to receive through grand funds that have failed to materialize and keep that project progressing. 

The total cost of the above projects is equal to the estimated amount of additional tax revenues expected to be generated by the capital tax rate increase approved by voters in March. 

Staff said they landed on the above recommendations by prioritizing safety concerns, regulatory compliance and efficient operations over any other potential projects or purchases. The capital budget plan changes from year to year as circumstances, opportunities and challenges shift. 

There was some discussion about this, with objection primarily from selectboard member Ethan Lawrence, as well as a bit of concern expressed by clerk Kendall Chamberlin on whether the dam repair is critical now, and an inquiry about possibly delaying the vote by Shannon Jackson. 

Lawrence advocated for keeping the money unspecialized in a capital reserve, and waiting until the formal capital budgeting process for the next fiscal year as is standard practice. 

Regardless of when the funds are allocated, it is and has always been up to the selectboard to decide on capital projects. Hence, doing so at any time wouldn’t go around voters’ heads. 

“The way we approved the budget and capital plan was for a set dollar amount,” Lawrence said. “If we set a budget, this is outside of our budget, this is going to be considered excess revenue after the end of the year. You can shake your head, but the only thing that should be happening is the town should be coming and asking for the $40,000 to replace the truck, because they have an immediate need, and the rest of the money should be put into the capital fund and broken down the way the rest of it is on the date we set the capital budget in January.” 

“There’s nothing on this list that I object to, I object to the process of it,” he added. “Let’s say something happens tomorrow… Priorities change — I would hate to have extra funds that we needed to raise, and commit them before we even get to our capital planning for the year.” 

Selectboard member Andy Watts, recognizing this isn’t excess capital, but capital approved by taxpayers to be put toward the most needed projects as soon as dollars are available and to start addressing pressing needs sooner rather than later. 

While Lawrence favored the town requesting capital funds from the selectboard piece-by-piece only when a specific, immediate, desperate needs arise, Watts pointed out fund allocations in specific reserves and not spent on immediate needs could always be reallocated later if needed. 

“This is a bifurcated capital plan,” said selectboard chair Tracey Delphia, sharing Watts’ support for moving forward per staff recommendation. “It was approved for FY26, which is what we’re in now. So I'm not sure why there wouldn’t be the assumption that it would be assigned in FY26.” 

A few of the existing concerns were cleared up by additional explanation from Adams. 

“All of these are based on safety, that's why they got the priority recommendation,” Adams said, providing the following example. “With a staff member getting trapped in the library elevator, that one rose to the top, because of the number of public folks that that building serves to work — and how important access is in that building, because the handicap is at the lowest level.” 

Because these dollars are necessarily allocated in the current fiscal year, the only other options on the table would either have been to reconfigure the numbers of what funds should go where, or for town staff to circle back with individual requests, allocating them in a piecemeal approach. 

Ultimately, the full list of projects and dollar amount allocations recommended by town staff was approved without modifications by the selectboard, in a vote of four-to-one, with Lawrence being the only nay in the room on the matter.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here