ESSEX TOWN – A proposed housing development for 60 Colonel Page Rd. has encountered difficulties with approval by the Essex Town Planning Commission.
On Thursday, Sept. 14, the commission held a hearing with the developers of the project and voted unanimously to continue the application process. The project's first hearing was more than a year ago, on Sept. 8, 2022.
The Colonel Page Road project would include a nine-lot subdivision with single family homes centered around a cul-de-sac. The proposed development is in a scenic resource protection overlay district, low density residential district and partially in a floodplain district.
The lot at 60 Colonel Page Rd. is currently completely undeveloped and has an open meadow, a row of trees and a brook. The development would be built in the meadow, which is the closest of the natural features to the road.
As a part of the scenic resource protection overlay district, the proposed development would be required to preserve the visual character of the site to align with a rural aesthetic.
During the hearing on Sept. 14, town planner Kent Johnson highlighted several challenges that town staff faced when determining how to evaluate the application.
“The applicant has not provided adequate documentation on the existing scenic resources and how they would be impacted and mitigated in the development proposal,” Johnson told the planning commission.
Because of this, he said town staff was unable to review if the development was aligned with the requirements of the district. He said staff recommended a denial or continuation of the application.
Some other issues with the application include the road and cul-de-sac designs are not complete and the cul-de-sac might need to be smaller or possibly removed. There are waterline issues that need to be corrected to satisfy the public works department’s requirements, and trees need to be moved out of the utility areas on the plans.
Additionally, Johnson said the Essex Conservation and Trails Committee, which had met on Tuesday, reshared an earlier concern that the proposed housing is in a floodplain area. The committee wondered if the open space in the development plans would remain open and how it might be used in the future.
The engineer for the project, John Stewart, said the town had already written to the developer saying the project complies with the scenic protection overlay district and quoted a correspondence approving the sketch plan in December.
Stewart said he was frustrated with the “whack a mole” approach he has had to take with addressing the commission’s concerns and the accumulating expense of application fees the landowners have had to pay.
He said lots 2 and 3 had been moved to a separate driveway, and lots 6-9 had been pushed deeper into the lot towards the wooded area to make sure the area keeps its scenic character, as seen from the road.
Additionally, he and his team had created plans with grades to show the steepness of the driveway in order to fulfill Essex Town Public Works requirements. In response to notes that the cul-de-sac was too large, he said there were no specific regulations stating how large the driveway should be.
Stewart also said the town used out of date information from FEMA that classified the flood zone as larger than it is.
“It was not a viable metric but that’s what ended up in your zoning regulations and maps,” Stewart said. “The landowners paid a lot of money and reclassified the zoning area.”
There was no part of the Colonel Page Road development in the updated 100-year floodplain from FEMA, he said.
In an email to the Reporter, Johnson confirmed the updated FEMA flood map shrinks the size of the current floodplain district, making more of the land eligible to be built on than in the current maps the town was using.
The reevaluation was done at the request of the developer and Johnson is now using the new maps for the development review, he said.
The new FEMA map becomes effective on Nov. 24, after a period of public comment.
The commission voted unanimously to continue the application so the developer could keep working with the town to meet its standards.
The developers will have to submit another application to the planning commission, a process that requires money and resources, but preserves their options if they want to continue with the project.
If the commission had approved it, it would have been with conditions, which commission chair Dustin Bruso said could be risky for the applicant because if they were found not to be following the conditions mid-development, they would have to apply for approval again.
The planning commission meets at 6 p.m. on the second and fourth Thursday of each month at the town offices at 81 Main Street and via Zoom. You can watch the hearing for 60 Colonel Page Rd here.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here