Essex Junction Development Review Board says Taft Street ducks must go in hearing

Posted

ESSEX JUNCTION — In an unprecedented hearing where state and municipal law were conflicting, Essex Junction’s Development Review Board sided with municipal law Thursday night.

Last night’s hearing was held after Essex Junction resident Stephen Wille Padnos was not satisfied with community development director Chris Yuen’s decision to continue to allow Essex Junction resident Jason Struthers to keep ducks in his yard for his Tier 1 cannabis cultivation operation.

The Yuen’s decision had upheld state agricultural law and state cannabis law as opposed to the municipality’s own zoning laws, which states he can’t operate a farm in his neighborhood. 

Thursday’s hearing ruled Struthers continue to cultivate cannabis, but he can’t keep his ducks. Here’s how it all unfolded. 

Neighbors issue with Struthers’ operations

The tension between Struthers’ business operations and his neighbors, like Wille Padnos who lives next door, has resulted in many calls to the police and to the fire department, none of which resulted in citations issued to Struthers.

Wille Padnos and five other residents of Taft Street, or near Taft Street, spoke Thursday night about the smell caused by the ducks and the cannabis, among other issues they’ve faced with a Tier 1 cannabis grower operating on their street.

They also voiced concerns over people circulating Struthers’ property where he grows his cannabis. Struthers said he is aware of this and has security measures in place to address it. 

Parents on the street said they worry about their children growing up around what they describe as an overpowering smell.

“My daughters can’t use the back yard because of the smell[...] and I can’t have Girl Scout meetings in my backyard because [...] the rules do not allow children to be in the vicinity of drugs,” Taft Street resident Rebecca Dwyer said.

Wille Padnos, the appellant, said he and his wife cannot go outside on their porch because of how overpowering the smell of duck feces and cannabis is. They feel they might as well be living in an apartment, instead of their house.

“We have a half-acre lot that we can’t use because it stinks,” Wille Padnos said. “The duck coops are on our side of the property so if there is any wind, it comes right across our deck.”

Throughout the hearing, as his neighbors spoke about their decreased quality of life, Struthers let out chuckles and shook his head at some of the statements he said were inaccurate, such as him having deceased ducks in his yard.

“Frankly, I don't mean to sound insensitive, but I couldn't care less if every single neighbor came to me and said ‘I don't like it.’ If everybody in the City came to me and said ‘I don't like your cannabis,’ I'm not breaking any rules, I'm not doing anything wrong, I'll choose to leave when I'm ready,” Struthers told the Reporter.

Struthers said he was 100% confident the DRB would rule in his favor. This confidence was exemplified in him leaving in the middle of the hearing to put his ducks in their coop, and choosing not to speak during public comment when he returned.

“Legal experts told me not to worry about this, so I’m going to trust their judgment,” Struthers said.

Neighbors issue with the City’s decision

While the inciting reason for the issue was the neighborly dispute, Wille Padnos was not in a hearing against Struthers last night, he was against the City.

Both he and other residents of Taft Street spoke to voice their concerns over the City basing its decisions off state law that protects Struthers’ operations, instead of the municipality’s zoning ordinances, which protects the residents.

“We just don't know whether the City is really intending to support good citizens, or people who just thumb their noses at the law, and do whatever they want,” Wille Padnos said.

Dwyer has been advocating against supporting the City more generally in order to make a point. She’s told other City residents to vote down municipal and school budgets because she feels the Taft Street residents are not being heard.

“We urge people now to vote down budgets in the City of Essex Junction because we don't think it's the kind of place where lawmakers are making laws that support family living,” she said.

The issue of the laws

Vermont’s recreational cannabis industry is still very new, turning a year old in two weeks. Struthers’ operation is a result of state laws working faster than municipal law.

His operation was approved by the state before the City’s Local Cannabis Control Commission was created, a commission that initially did not allow indoor cannabis cultivator Passion Fruit Farms to operate, citing cannabis must be grown in the Planned Agricultural Zoning District.

After an appeal Passion Fruit Farms was able to get its license despite not being in the agricultural district and has been fully licensed and in business since February.

Taft Street is not in the Planned Agricultural Zoning District, but Struthers’ property had been excused from the municipal law because the state approved the agricultural operation. 

This state approval allowed him to have up to 100 ducks on his property. As of now, he has 25 adult ducks and 15 baby ducks.

 On Nov. 9, 2022, Struthers asked for an exemption from the City’s chicken ordinance after receiving complaints about his ducks from his neighbors.

The ordinance states residents can keep a small number of domesticated female chickens so long as it does not “adversely impact” the surrounding neighborhood.

But his neighbors argued the chicken ordinance should be enforced on Struthers’ ducks. 

“If you guys don’t make this a priority then I’m going to have to slaughter all of my ducks,” Struthers said at that Nov. 9 meeting. “I would prefer not to do that.”

This exception request was made months before May 4, 2023, when the Vermont Agency of Agriculture issued a determination that Stuthers’ operation met the definition of a farming operation and the municipal exception was no longer needed.

Last night, the DRB unanimously voted to overturn the City staff’s enforcement of the state’s agricultural operation approval, requiring Struthers to cease operating a “farm.”

“However, we find that cannabis cultivation is subject to different rules and we agree with the administrative officers’ portion of the decision on cannabis cultivation,” DRB chair John Alden said.

This means Struthers can continue to operate as a Tier 1 cannabis cultivator, but he can no longer use his ducks in this process.

“I’m very happy they decided to enforce the farming, that’s a relief,” Wille Padnos told the Reporter. “Half the smells will still be there, but the [duck] noises won’t be.”

Wille Padnos is optimistic the laws around cannabis cultivation will continue to evolve.

“Maybe things will get better later,” he said.

This article was updated Sept. 28 at 9:10 a.m. regarding the status of Passion Fruit Farms.

#jason struthers, #vermont, #taft street, #cannabis, #cannabis control board, #essex junction, #city of essex junction, #ducks, #drb, #ernltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here