ESSEX JUNCTION — Last week’s City Council meeting covered plans for a stormwater utility, renovations to the city office and strides toward rebranding.
The council met April 9 to discuss each initiative’s progress and trajectory, with one action item culminating in a 5-0 vote to designate additional funds toward the 2 Lincoln St. renovations.
Also, during public comment, attendee Resa Mehren asked if any of the city’s federal grant funding is earmarked for cancellation. City Manager Regina Mahony said there are two federal grants the city is tracking — they’ve confirmed federal funding for the Connect the Junction project is secure, though there is concern about the grant related to the Amtrak project.
The Amtrak project grant has not yet been obligated at the federal level, Mahony said; it’s only been preliminarily approved. City management will keep an eye on it as things unfold.
The meeting kicked off with a public hearing on a new stormwater utility ordinance. The decision to create a stormwater utility funded by user fees as opposed to funding it via the general fund budget is a common decision in cities with lots of development and paving.
“Because we can't measure stormwater like you can sewer and water usage on a property, we use something called impervious area,” water quality superintendent Chelsea Mandigo said. “And we're not alone in this way to fund stormwater projects and management and programs.”
Stormwater utilities are utilized most heavily by users who own more impervious surfaces than others — impervious surfaces being anything impeding precipitation from being absorbed directly into the ground.
Mandigo’s presentation covered the history of stormwater management and how user fees are calculated for stormwater utilities, the city’s proposed credit manual for its stormwater utility, and the proposed or amended stormwater chapters for municipal code.
She outlined a number of problems this utility aims to address, especially stormwater runoff leading to degraded water quality in Lake Champlain. Stormwater utilities can aid in distributing the financial burden of this service in a way that ties payment more closely to personal use.
Pre-separation, stormwater was handled jointly by the town and city, via the general fund. Now its own municipality, the Junction is tailoring funding mechanisms to its needs.
“It provides a fair and equitable and stable source of funding currently in this budget cycle,” Mandigo said. “So that is something that we need to get established again so we can work on meeting our requirements for the phosphorus total maximum daily load [of runoff].”
Impervious area is calculated to determine the standard unit of charge for the stormwater utility so the fee can be fairly calculated for each residential unit. Non-single-family properties can apply to receive credit toward their stormwater fee by demonstrating stormwater treatment practices, by holding certain permits, or by teaching stormwater or water quality curriculums, with properties holding credits needing to re-certify for them every two years.
The newly-proposed chapter in the city’s municipal code that establishes the stormwater utility, chapter 21, outlines the administration, development and procedures of the utility, assignment of billing units, credits, billing and collection procedures, and creating an enterprise fund for it.
Next steps will include the establishment of the rates for fiscal year 2026 and the mailing out of the first round of stormwater utility bills in October 2025.
Mahony noted the city is also recommending an additional 10-50% credit option to acknowledge the variety of stormwater permits in existence and the work required by larger properties to maintain them, with the suggestion of removing specificity around the types of credits accepted within the ordinance — instead maintaining that specificity in the credit manual.
Tim Shea, executive director of the Champlain Valley Exposition, spoke up during public comment about the Expo’s 33 acres of impervious surface, with all but five of them being treated for stormwater and with work ongoing to bring the grounds up to current state standards.
With contribution calculations as they stand, the expo would pay an annual city stormwater fee of approximately $35,000, which Shea believes to be exorbitant for a nonprofit organization. He advocated the council continue exploring the credit manual and credit options in ways which could help reduce the burden of that cost for his organization.
Mandigo said city staff would like to have the council’s input on several items related to the credit manual, including the 10% credit for properties holding current state and federal permits, and a credit to recognize the unique situation of Global Foundries, which already treats a portion of its stormwater through a combined sewer and stormwater system.
Councilor Elaine Haney asked about the likelihood of larger parcels achieving a full 50% credit, to which Mahony said not many users are taking advantage of similar credits for other utilities, noting the city is in a unique position in that it is developing its utility in tandem with many property owners having to grapple with three-acre permitting requirements from the state.
Per staff recommendations, councilors agreed to a phase-in approach of implementing the utility budget over two years, leaving capital funds out of the budget in its first year of implementation.
They also agreed to make available the 10% credit for properties with an existing permit, as well as to amend the ordinance to remove the specificity around the types of credits accepted in its language, and to add a credit manual option for combined sewer treatment of stormwater.
Certa asked if utility bills will show the number of equivalent residential units for a property in its billing calculations, and finance director Jess Morris said the city is working with its billing administrators to determine what level of specificity will be on stormwater utility bills, but said bills will at least show whether the property is a single-family user or non-single-family user.
There will be another public hearing at 6:30 p.m. April 23 to hear comments on changes to chapter 21 of the municipal ordinance and the ordinance relating to stormwater utility regulation as well as the stormwater user fee credit manual as amended, with the edits discussed.
The hearing will take place in the community room at the Essex Police Department during the April 23 city council meeting.
The council then discussed the 2 Lincoln St. renovation, ultimately voting unanimously to assign $400,000 in local option tax funds to the project and reassigning an additional $100,000 from the city’s building maintenance fund for the project, authorizing Mahony to complete the renovations with these funds, not exceeding the amounts identified.
Present at the meeting was John Alden, architect at Scott & Partners and team leader for the renovations of 2 Lincoln St. — the site of the city’s municipal offices. When the Junction switched its status from a village of Essex Town to becoming an independent city, its need for staff grew and outsized the capacity of the very old structures that had been housing them.
Alden said the initial cost of the project had been subject to new and more expensive discoveries once renovation work began, finding the building was originally four separate structures that were joined together in a manner that was altogether not of the highest quality.
Mahony even told the Reporter last week that not only were a number of internal brick walls and sections of roofing very loosely enforced, but also that surprise fireplaces unexpectedly cropped up in the demolition phase of the renovation process — which prior, had been loosely covered with drywall over the years in a building that’s altogether over 200 years old.
Alden said as a result of some of these discoveries, his team has had to conduct structural reinforcement of the outside walls and stabilize the roof, which has also enabled the conditions necessary for his team to be better able to insulate the walls.
Some of the costs quoted by the contractor have also increased due to difficulty in sourcing subcontractors for some portions of it. They anticipate any future cost surprises from the project to be cosmetic and smaller in nature than this update in particular.
In the long run, these addressed surprises will result in a more structurally sound, longer-lasting, comfortable and more energy-efficient building, Alden said.
“You want to insulate and improve your energy efficiency, so we repair it properly, instead of just kind of putting it back the way it was,” he said. “We know it's painful, but at the end of the day, this is going to be a tremendous building, much improved — more improved than we expected.”
Certa asked if the city could have done anything to get a tighter cost estimate at the outset of the project, and Alden noted there were headwinds for the city, which included a tough bidding climate and coverage issues with subcontracting for the project.
He also mentioned predicting what is behind walls is difficult without removing portions of the wall, so that element was difficult to anticipate. As part of this project, the team is documenting discoveries in the walls and what has been improved, so the city has a record going forward.
Communications and strategic initiatives director Ashley Snellenberger spoke last week to the city’s request for proposals on the city’s rebranding project, ultimately aiming to create a longstanding recognizable brand identity for the city in the wake of its separation from the town.
She said it will include a new city logo, letterhead, report cover memos, signage and banners for the City’s flagpoles, as well as new sub-logos for each of the city’s departments.
There will be three phases of the project: the RFP process with a temporary committee to help facilitate that process to include representation from the city council, followed by a design phase to entail soliciting councilor and community feedback on the proposed options, followed lastly by a phase for implementing the logo changeover itself.
The city anticipates having a logo by July and having all logos changed over within three years.
“I guess I want to understand — if nothing else, maybe it's historical context, or maybe there's a logical reason — and I just want to understand the need for sub-branding,” Certa said. “Because I feel like, based on my cursory understanding, Brownell [Library], [Essex Junction Recreation and Parks], those logos probably came from their historical development.”
Certa also expressed concern about the potential for any sub-branding initiatives to carry forward the city’s current pattern of lacking uniformity of identity across the whole city.
City Manager Mahony noted there is logic to keeping some of the departments’ logos untouched, but said it would be interesting to also solicit feedback from bidders on their suggestions to honor past logos while making the connection between them and any new logo.
Certa also said it’s important to assemble the appropriate committee composition for this work, and Haney mentioned the importance of any design being attentive to and honoring of the mission statements and slogans of each department, requesting this note be included in the RFP. Councilor Tim Miller then volunteered to serve on the RFP committee.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here