ESSEX TOWN — As Amazon continues its push to set up shop in Essex at a 107,000 square foot distribution facility in Saxon Hill Industrial Park, local voices against the project grow louder.
After public officials failed to run the previous Development Review Board meeting through to its conclusion, the board managed to see last night’s makeup meeting through — hearing dozens individuals speak out against the corporate behemoth coming to town.
Ultimately, folks with more to say were turned away so the board could deliberate internally with the time remaining in the nearly-three-hour meeting May 29 at the Essex High School cafeteria.
There were 50-plus stakeholders in the room on top of public officials and the press, with around 45 more online. Not having yet had the time to come to a vote to formally approve or deny the project, the DRB intends to continue the Amazon meeting series at a fourth date.
The continuation will be held at the DRB’s next “available” meeting, which has yet to be determined. Folks interested may keep an eye out for upcoming DRB agendas here.
The DRB’s main concern at this point is whether the traffic study on file is comprehensive enough to approve the applicant, Scannell Properties — whereas the primary concerns of citizens have centered around labor rights, workers’ safety and dignity, habitat destruction and loss of biodiversity, environmental and noise pollution, local business viability, power and greed encroaching on an already-struggling regional economy, and class warfare at large.
There were also some more project-specific concerns raised by both members of the public and DRB members about the developers’ buffer waiver for stormwater management at the site.
In essence, the Essex DRB has made clear to the public its legal function is solely to approve any applicant that complies with the town’s zoning regulations and site plan review criteria — not to vet applicants through any moral, ethical, political or values-based standards.
“Comments that don't pertain to site plan review criteria may not be considered by the DRB,” said Chair Ian Carroll, to initiate the forum. “Comments regarding business practices, economic impacts, employee policies, or how business competes with other businesses are not relevant to the review of this site plan application.”
Though DRB Vice Chair Sharon Zukowski said the board has a responsibility to consider the town plan, member Dustin Bruso said the DRB has no formal obligation to enforce or honor it directly, or to ensure applicants fit into residents’ shared vision for the town’s growth as outlined by it.
“The use as requested is no different than the uses that were requested by the application right across the street,” Bruso said. “What's different is the potential business going in there.”
Hence, Bruso has no issue with approving the application, so long as it’s approved with the condition that the area’s Thompson Drive connection be completed to accommodate the traffic that’s anticipated to be generated by Amazon deliveries.
“I heard a lot tonight, people telling us that we as a DRB had to basically serve the Town Plan, enforce the Town Plan, and so forth,” Bruso said. “But my understanding is that DRB enforces the regulations. The Town Plan is a vision for the community, and the planning commission develops the regulations that support that vision. We have existing regulations.”
“So we have regulations in place, and that's what we're looking at with this application,” he added. “The staff has done a good job as far as going through and presenting those to us.”
The Town Plan explicitly states the town’s economic development policies aim to maintain Essex’s rural areas and diversify economic development, emphasizing startups, agricultural and home businesses and retail — a vision a number of public commenters saw as incompatible with the presence of an Amazon distribution facility.
Public commenter Jackie Lawlor, who spoke against the development earlier in the meeting, at this point came back to the microphone to say the Town Plan is in the DRB’s mission statement — reading directly from the DRB page of the town’s website.
“Ultimately, the purpose behind the development review process is to help achieve the community’s vision through sensible and well-planned development,” reads the webpage Lawlor referenced. “The community’s vision is expressed broadly in the Town Plan.”
In response to this reading, Bruso reiterated once again the DRB’s role is more directly linked to the regulations themselves, as opposed to the Town Plan upon which regulations are based.
“It says, right there, you're supposed to achieve the community's vision, and that vision is expressed broadly in the Town Plan,” Lawlor said right back. “That's why everyone came here and used the Town Plan to try and convince you.”
Assuming the DRB approves the project, there are other bodies the proposal would have to go through before acquiring a complete stamp of approval — namely Act 250, at the state-level.
But in regard to concerns about local market competition, corporate greed, a lack of synergy with existing taxpayers’ community values, or Amazon’s known history of labor rights violations, nothing rigid stands in Amazon’s way as a legal safeguard. Approval of developments is not a direct-democratic process via a vote at the ballot box.
On top of the nearly two dozen speakers noting anti-Amazon sentiment in attendance, dozens of letters came in online, a vast majority of which were also anti. Zero speakers who attended any of the Amazon-focused DRB meetings thus far have spoken in favor of the development.
Essex resident Jackson Kelleher is one of several attendees to point out Amazon’s history of alleged worker abuse, neglect and general mistreatment — among other points of discontent.
“What the applicants have said about helping small businesses is a lie,” Kelleher said. “Their goal is not to help small businesses. In fact, three quarters of small businesses have stated that Amazon installments are a threat to their livelihoods, and only 11% that have worked with Amazon have actually said that they've had a beneficial relationship with this company.”
“Now, I know Vermonters are struggling,” he added. “Vermonters need jobs, but they need good jobs where they're treated with dignity and respect, not forced to clock out when they need to go to the bathroom.”
This statement was followed by applause.
Although none in attendance spoke on behalf of the build, Essex resident and Teamsters field representative Ryan Wallace spoke neither for or against, but rather to give Amazon a message about his intentions if the company lands in the heart of Saxon Hill.
“The members of the community who fill these jobs that are created will not be exploited, beaten down and paid unlivable wages,” Wallace said at the meeting. “This facility will be organized by the Teamsters union, so get ready… This is a full contact sport.”
Even more applause from the crowd followed Wallace’s statement.
Gina Barrett, an Essex resident who lives on Sand Hill Road next to the forest, said she agrees with almost everything said last night by others, on Amazon being an unhealthy presence in the community — but came also with specific concerns about child safety in the neighborhood with heavy vans, plus the building up of impervious surface by the Winooski River watershed.
She grew up in Essex Junction and came back to live in Essex Town. In her early years in town, her relocation allowed her to experience proximity to animals, walkers, bikers and joggers all by her house. That’s now being replaced more and more by noise and idling trucks, she said.
“I can see the effects of the clear cutting of the 50 foot buffers behind my house,” she said. “We can now see right through… My taxes have not gone down since all the development has started behind our house, but my quality of life on Sand Hill Road has.” `
“You — the DRB and town staff, our municipal representatives — need to be our buffer,” she added. “Protecting that land and us from any economic development that isn't in harmony.”
Another member of the public in attendance last night explicitly mentioned having canceled their Amazon membership in light of recent events — and one DRB member even expressed a subtle discontent of her own with the application, alluding to a similar choice on her part.
“How long are the deliveries?” Zukowski asked as an unrelated clarifying question, between public comment segments and during a DRB deliberation portion of the meeting.
“Because I know I get Amazon packages thrown on my porch at like 8 p.m. — well, not anymore,” she added with a chuckle. “Sorry.”
About a dozen members of the public spoke in the initial segment of the forum, and having initially been cut off midway through the queue — yielding public protest — a similar number spoke after some board deliberations, when they were ultimately given more time by the DRB.
While most speakers came as town residents, Vermonters from municipalities nearby also came out to say their piece.
Burlington resident Julie Macuga said nobody comes to her own neighboring city to shop anymore.
“People blame crime, but really it's online retail stealing customers,” she said.
Macuga has recently noticed entrepreneurs start to trickle back in, trying to open stores despite these pressures, which she believes is partly happening as people are realizing “the evils of Amazon.”
“People are boycotting it, left and right,” Macuga said. “For ties to Israel, killing small businesses, exploiting their workers… If you want constant protests in your town here, by all means, bring in Amazon. It will just become the new Tesla dealership in South Burlington, with weekly hordes of people who are just pissed off — and rightly so.”
“Don't become like us,” she added. “Keep your character, and if nothing else, we should stop Jeff Bezos from getting even richer. He's not going to invest back in this community.”
With the DRB’s prerogative in mind during deliberations, the board carried on as if Scannell’s build for the Amazon facility were any other proposal made by any other developer or company.
The applicant will be expected to work with the town’s tree warden to select satisfactory plant species for a 50-foot buffer area prior to issuance of a zoning permit, per conservation and trails committee. The tree warden directed applicants that the screening buffer between the facility and surrounding area would be most effective if existing vegetation is clear-cut, then replanted.
According to Town Planner Kent Johnson, distribution facilities of this type and size are allowed in the zoning district in question. The traffic impacts calculated for this site are approximately half of the total amount already approved by the town and state for the subdivision area that includes this site and three other recently created lots across the street from it, he said.
The applicant has provided a stormwater management report, and must be able to secure a state stormwater permit and comply with Public Works specifications to ensure that the design is able to prevent negative stormwater runoff impacts on adjacent properties and waterways.
The board also requested more information on any potentially hazardous waste materials from the proposed development of the site from Amazon and its developers over at Scannell. A few additional DRB-requested materials from the applicant, are in last night’s agenda packet.
The distribution facility, if approved, will be located on a privately owned lot within the Saxon Hill Industrial Park in the developable district of the forest, zoned specifically for development, without encroachment into the 60% of the area that’s dedicated to conservation and recreation.
While Scannell Properties is formally the applicant, Amazon is its partner and intended tenant.
Present in affiliation with the applicant last night were Scannell Properties development manager Leo Leighton; Jeff Polubinski of Gravel and Shea, serving as legal representation for Scannell; civil engineer for the project David Gagnon, also in affiliation with Scannell; and Jonathan Greeley, head of economic development for Amazon in New England.
Gagnon said they will be adding 10 electric vehicle parking spaces and 49 additional EV-capable spaces with capacity to meet additional demand for future EV chargers, in response to feedback from the public and town staff about implementation of more green technologies on the site.
Gagnon also noted his team has made adjustments to LEDs in response to the fact that town staff believed certain parts of the site were initially slated to be too bright to be in compliance with town standards, particularly under the building canopy on the east side.
The only other change the applicants made since the last meeting was to thicken the visual, vegetative buffer using native tree species, per the aforementioned partnership with the town’s tree warden, and to do so with respect to intersection sight distances.
The DRB might consider requiring the applicant to provide regular reports from a professional inspector on the installation and maintenance of the site’s stormwater management system, per DRB member Hubie Norton’s recommendation, and also initiating a more comprehensive traffic study — pending independent review of the existing one — per many members’ traffic concerns about the higher volume of traffic anticipated at this facility than at existing ones in the area.
Though Amazon intends to utilize local fueling stations and repair areas to gas up its tractor trailers and vans — which the company pointed out as being a potential benefit to local businesses — Zukowski said all area fueling spots are very dangerous places for large vehicles to pull out.
The Amazon representative promised the site would host zero vehicular idling, zero drones and zero helicopters, per Amazon’s existing plans. Norton also requested signage as a condition be added to the area stating no engine brakes may be used past the facility’s exit-point.
Those who have spoken out as members of the public have overwhelmingly done so to warn against the development, vehemently urging the board to vote no.
More reporting to come after the next installment of the Amazon-focused DRB meeting series.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here