ESSEX JUNCTION — Essex Junction’s development review board voted unanimously last Thursday to side with the courts against agricultural cannabis cultivation activity in one of the city’s residential neighborhoods.
At the center of the case is Junction resident Jason Struthers, and his outdoor duck farming and cannabis growth operation on Taft Street. It’s been a years-long journey through various governing bodies, and though the end of the road might be drawing near for Struthers and his beloved operation, his case is likely to serve to clarify broader applications of Vermont agricultural law through a newly-solidified legal precedent in the relevant statues’ interpretation.
This most recent issuance of a notice of violation came in light of the Vermont Supreme Court’s decision that cannabis cultivation is not exempt from municipal regulations, even for license-holders.
The original notice of violation that kickstarted the journey was about Struthers’ ducks, which the courts ultimately also ruled can be prohibited. Several years and many meetings later, the cannabis is also prohibited, as has been determined by the municipality per its zoning laws.
The DRB’s meeting Sept. 18 served mainly to address Struthers’ appeal of a July 14 administrative decision: the city’s issuance of a notice of violation for the cannabis cultivation operation at his place of residence, 8 Taft St., as it is a prohibited use within the Residential-1 zoning district.
Already, in light of this case, the Vermont Supreme Court has ruled local, municipal governing bodies can decide where cannabis cultivation is and is not allowed within their municipality. Since Essex Junction prohibits such practices in the R-1 district, the state supports that rule.
Struthers’ claim in making his appeal was that his should be considered a grandfathered use, meaning a use that had been ongoing since before the rule went into place — however, the DRB held that the land development code prohibiting agriculture uses in the R-1 district has been in place for longer than Struthers had been growing, both of which began in 2022.
Therefore, he’s been in violation of an existing rule, his activities never having been legal in the eyes of the DRB.
“It looks pretty cut and dry to me,” DRB Chair John Alden said.
Still, Struthers testified, starting with the assertion that cannabis isn’t considered agriculture in Vermont — hence the municipality has no ability to zone it. He also claimed he has a license from the cannabis control board, issued in July of 2022, noting local development code changed in September of 2022 — hence, the grandfathering idea. Struthers noted he annually renews his license, and threatened to bring the matter back to court in the event of a denial of his appeal.
But, cannabis is, indeed, regulated as agriculture in Vermont — it’s just not considered farming.
In essence, the Supreme Court decision provided clarification of the existing law, the court ruling effective since 2022, that because agriculture was not allowed according to local zoning laws, local municipalities are allowed to regulate agriculture — and because cannabis is legally an agricultural crop, there is no basis for grandfathering what was never legal in the first place.
And licenses, especially those requiring annual renewals, aren’t exempt from local zoning law.
All growers’ license applicants are required to attest they will comply with applicable municipal ordinances, regardless of what those were when their initial license was granted — and the Supreme Court has since clarified this particular zoning law as an applicable ordinance.
A number of neighbors came to this meeting to speak to their interpretations of the law. Most agreed with the interpretations of the courts and of the DRB. Several neighbors also said their quality of life has been affected, claiming they have developed respiratory issues as a result of the cannabis-scented neighborhood.
But Struthers was more concerned with persuading the DRB to side with his misinterpretation of the laws which have historically and continue to guide his practice and staunch advocacy for it.
“We don't call the feelings police,” Struthers said. “While everybody can give their opinion and share their feelings, they are meaningless.”
More neighbors still expressed dismay by Struthers’ careless attitude as unharmonious to the area — alleging Struthers typically gives them the finger when they drive past his residence.
There was also discussion about the number of plants being grown and debate between Struthers and neighbors as to whether and to what degree he’s expanded his operation since 2022, with some stating such a move would further nullify the claim to grandfathering — plus, claims from some neighbors that Struthers’ property wouldn’t accommodate enough square footage regardless, to adhere to legally-mandated growing setbacks from the property’s edge.
“I'm here to ask that the DRB uphold the notice of violation,” said one of the most outspoken of many distressed neighbors, Stephen Willie Padnos. “And if you have any power to do so, please impose or direct the city to impose the maximum penalties allowed by law.”
“This situation has been going on for far too long,” he added. “It would be a travesty if the callous, belligerent and illegal activities of our neighbor went unpunished. The other members of the neighborhood have been punished already, and we didn't do anything wrong.”
Other neighbors spoke to concerns around the impact of this activity on home property values, noting Vermont's Right to Farm Act exists only for farms predating surrounding neighborhoods — whereas in the case of cannabis, the neighborhoods have been there for far longer.
Following public comment, Struthers tried a different route, noting that in May of 2023, the Vermont Agency of Agriculture, Food and Markets issued him a determination of being a formal farm. But, the DRB maintained its right to uphold municipal requirements that it is a violation of R-1 district requirements to have a farm in R-1 land — as municipal regulation of both agriculture and cannabis zoning has been upheld by the Supreme Court, whose word at the end of the day holds above all other bodies of law, individual disputes or branches of governance.
“Agriculture was always prohibited in the urban district, even before Struthers began his operations — so it was never lawful and cannot qualify as a pre-existing, non-deterrent use,” said the Junction’s community development director, Christopher Yuen, who attended to defend and elaborate upon his most-recently-issued notice of violation.
“This does differ from how I interpreted this at the beginning, before the courts issued any decisions, but based on what the court says, this is what I think,” he added.
Yuen also noted the grandfathering argument is barred by the fact that the legal doctrine for grandfathering needs to be done in the context of court litigation — this issue has already been discussed in court, yet Struthers had never brought grandfathering up as one of his defenses.
So, Struthers hopes to take his hope for grandfathered-status back to Vermont Superior Court.
“Already, the State Supreme Court and the Superior Court have both weighed in on this,” Alden said. “It's not a secret what they think… I still don't understand how we got into the situation in the first place, because there was never a point in time that Mr. Struthers’ activities were legal, so if I were able to do something about it, I would.”
“I don't know exactly what happens when somebody ignores or breaks a rule, but I would find that there's been a problem since day one, and I would figure out how to do something about that,” he added. “But that's not my job. My job is to look with the board at the rest of the things that are in front of us right now tonight, and to decide whether or not we think that the notice of violation that was issued by our zoning administrator is lawful.”
Sure enough, the DRB’s vote to uphold the notice of violation was unanimous.
To learn more about the history of the turbulent tale of ducks and cannabis regulation in the City of Essex Junction, as has since resulted in a renewed understanding of municipal agricultural regulation by municipalities statewide, read our previous reportage here and here.
Another source of case history, with reference to specific relevant legal statutes and land development code, an explanation of the administrative officer’s reasoning for issuing his NOV and a generally fuller timeline of events can be found in the meeting packet.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here