Dozens rally for healthcare justice at Five Corners

Posted

ESSEX JUNCTION — In a rally for healthcare justice, around 50 people — largely locals but some hailing from as far as the West Coast — gathered Saturday afternoon at Five Corners. 

Despite the cold weather and grey skies, dozens of neighbors, friends, healthcare workers, concerned citizens and advocates decided to show up in protest of the cuts to Medicaid proposed by the Donald Trump administration. 

The gathering was organized in response to the destabilization of access to healthcare on the horizon, and the anticipated loss of hospitals, providers and lives to follow. Over 75,000 Vermonters stand to lose Affordable Care Act subsidies or Medicaid. 

Some showed up in scrubs and lab coats, others in day-clothes, and given the season, most came clad in mittens and jackets. People dotted every corner of the intersection with homemade signs promoting pro-Democracy messaging. 

“I'm just here because we deserve better,” said Fairfax resident Michelle Force. “Working class America deserves better than what we've got… And inequality is out of control… And I’m anti-fascist — as we all should be.” 

Retired nurse practitioner Deborah Kutzko, who is based out of Burlington, told the Reporter she started out at what is now the Community Health Center of Burlington, which used to be called the People’s Free Clinic. 

“I was part of the group of hippies in the 70s who started that, because healthcare is a right,” Kutzko said. “Now, low income people don't pay as much, but in those days it was free, because healthcare is a right and out of privilege. It's still true.” 

“This is abhorrent,” she added. “People who don't get health care end up in the emergency department and are very sick and it costs us the hospitals and the insurers and those of us who pay for our health insurance a lot of money to pay for that care.” 

Essex Town resident, Philip Damus, who works for Vermont Health Connect in dealing with insurance and subsidy processing, said he’s been seeing huge increases in premiums. 

His personal opinion, not speaking on behalf of his employer, is there should be an extension of subsidies for families and individuals who are not likely to be able to pay for their essential care very soon. 

“People are not going to be able to have health insurance,” he said. “The state won't do anything to cancel it. It's just that they're going to default. They're not going to make the payments. Starting in December, they're not going to be able to pay it, because on top of groceries and stuff, health insurance is not going to be affordable.” 

Damus believes the end-result will be a very sick and indebted nation. 

“I do believe we're going to lose people,” he said. “Because they will not be very hesitant, they will not be very willing to go to hospitals because of the bill.” 

Current-day front-line providers had strong feelings on this, too. 

“Healthcare should be something all of us have access to,” said a current University of Vermont Medical Center nurse practitioner, who preferred to remain anonymous for this story. “Our government is taking our tax dollars and putting them there to war, and there are billionaires while so many are living paycheck to paycheck — it is awful. It's appalling.” 

And for many, the government shutdown motivated them to come out. 

“My wife works for the Department of Vermont Health Access,” said Brian Shelden, an Essex Junction city counselor who came this past weekend solely representing his individual views. “She is seeing all the people whose subsidies are going away and are not going to be able to afford health insurance.” 

“So it seems like such a no-brainer, if the Republicans control the House, the Senate and the Presidency, to pass a budget by paying for healthcare, as we've done since the Obama presidency,” he said. “So, yeah, it's such a weird hill to die on.” 

It’s also a very deeply personal issue, and a pressing one, to many. 

Sheila Straub-Armenta, formerly having lived in the area and now a resident of California visiting her friend in Essex, Vt., showed up Saturday with her son Tristan, who is wheelchair-bound with 16 diagnoses, including cerebral palsy, epilepsy, autism and several chromosome issues. 

“If they change the way healthcare is, they're not gonna cover any of his care,” she said. “We’re on Medicaid. He inherited three autoimmune diseases from me: scleroderma, pulmonary fibrosis, and Rayauds, so those will be pre-existing conditions, so none of that will be covered.” 

Before she got pregnant, Straub-Armenta wasn’t sick — all those conditions had been dormant. 

“You get what you get,” she said. “I thought my child was going to be healthy, then he comes out early and all the stuff that comes along with that, the healthcare, and the medication: ‘We’ll pay for the gastronomy tube but not the formula, or we’ll pay for the G-Tube but not the formula.’” 

“They both need to be done and they both need to be changed every six months,” she added. “It’s that kind of nonsense.” 

Straub-Armenta’s father fought in the Vietnam War and had been heavily exposed to Agent Orange while enlisted. Although she isn’t certain, in retrospect, Straub-Armenta strongly believes it resulted in a number of health complications being passed down through her family. 

“Healthcare is just ridiculous,” Straub-Armenta said. “I also get my insulin and stuff, and some people ration their insulin — I think it’s ridiculous that people have to ration essentials, like, ‘Should I take my insulin today? What medication can I take, or what bill am I gonna pay?’” 

Tens of thousands of people die each year because their first response is to say no to new bills, according to the National Institute of Health, particularly due to a lack of health insurance, which is expensive, privatized and only offered through some employers. 

“I just want to show up and show my support and try to make our voices be heard — healthcare just as a whole, needs to change, and not be a business,” she added. “They’re laying people off and charging so much money, meanwhile, the higher you go up, the CEOs and CFOs are making so much money. I had no idea until Luigi [Mangione] how bad that was.” 

UnitedHealthcare’s former CEO Brian Thompson had been earning well over $10 million a year by the time of his death last year. UnitedHealthcare is the largest health insurer in the U.S. 

City of Essex Junction resident Susan McCormack helped organize the demonstration. She said the most recent No Kings protest in the area saw over 1,000 attendees, which built a lot of good momentum for continued demonstrations at Five Corners. 

“I'm here today because my wife and I are both small business owners, and we have relied on the Affordable Care Act for years for our health insurance,” she said. “It's made it possible for us to start our own businesses, and now we're facing the fact that we might not be able to afford it.” 

Although the stakes are high, McCormack noted a local positive, which is that recent rallies she’s been involved with in response to Trump’s action have seen more supportive honks than negative. 

“My wife might become uninsured,” she said. “Which is terrible, and we know there are a lot of people in the same boat as us, and it's unnecessary, and especially during this time when tax policy is benefiting the wealthiest Americans, it seems the priorities are really backwards.” 

“We're giving benefits to people who don't need help, and we're taking benefits like healthcare food away from people who do need help,” she added. “It's immoral, and we can do better.” 

McCormack said there’s a core group of Junction residents now who work to organize events at Five Corners, mainly because it’s a place where people from all over drive through. 

“So we're not just preaching to the choir,” she said. “It's really great for people who might not be that aware of what's going on to just have a reminder, things are happening that aren't great. We’re not going to a place where we can just admire each other’s signs — we’re here to raise awareness for everybody that we’re not in normal times.” 

Bridget Meyer and Brian Walsh also serve on the small Five Corners event organizing group. 

Both had similar reasons for showing up in the cold at this particular event. 

“The way the system is set up is not fair,” said Walsh, who lives in Jericho. “Some people have health care through their jobs but more and more don't. Everybody should have quality health care. And we don't. Canada can do it, Western European countries and Japan, Australia and New Zealand all have healthcare for everybody. We don't. It's not right.” 

“I just think that healthcare is a human right. It should not be a privilege. It should be affordable to everyone,” said Meyer, who lives in Essex Junction. “I would support single payer universal health care. We're in a deep, deep hole, in which some people survive and some people don’t. It really is a very sad and dangerous situation for this country.” 

Jericho-Underhill resident Giovanna Lepore, has been an activist for many years in Massachusetts, New York and all over Vermont, and is also a longtime supporter of seeing everybody in the country covered by health insurance on a not-for-profit model. 

“This is one of the worst systems imaginable for a country that has this kind of wealth and money,” she said. “There’s no excuse. We’re looking at this scenario with these super wealthy people, and just today, Trump gave another tax break to the billionaires, on top of the trillions already given. It is obscene.” 

She’s been to many protests at Five Corners, and is grateful for the opportunity to rally around the specific healthcare issue, given that millions are about to lose their coverage. Like Meyer, Lepore, too, favors a single-payer system, accountable to the public rather than to a profit. 

It’s essentially another term for “Medicare for all,” funded by a small tax everybody in the country would pay: under 5% for most, and at least 10% for people as wealthy as Trump and Elon Musk, into a universally pooled health insurance cache to aid all Americans when they’re sick. 

“It's the only dignified type of insurance,” she said. “Because it treats everybody equally. Pay-in is based on what you actually earn. Nobody would go without… As things stand currently, the poor are always spat on, the middle class is being squeezed more and more, and they're all being taken advantage of by the very wealthy.” 

The idea behind the single-payer program as a solution is the unlikelihood that everybody in the country could become sick all at the same time — a very low risk, statistically speaking, leaving the resource pool, for all intents and purposes, readily available at all times to those who are. 

“We have to speak out more — we don’t want to see anybody suffer,” she said. “Now they want to take away the ACA. We know how the premiums are going to be skyrocketing. There already are, for a lot of people. I went bankrupt because of medical bills.’ 

“I never claimed it, I’m glad I didn’t, but I was broke, I had nothing,” she added. “I made it to my 62nd birthday and struggled on but couldn’t work anymore, I was in so much physical pain… I was finally able to get insurance, but I don’t feel good about it, because I know there’s millions of people in this country that are not covered, and everybody has this thing hanging over them.”