Despite pushback, CCSU firm on transgender policy

Posted

By COLIN FLANDERS

The Chittenden Central Supervisory Union will remain firm in its stance on transgender bathroom and locker room access despite a handful of parents who urged it to reconsider on Monday night, superintendent Judith DeNova said.

CCSU decided in May it will allow students to access bathroom and locker rooms based on gender identity, not biological sex. The change will include both students and school visitors.

Nearly all parents who spoke shared concerns for safety and emotional strife. Some felt the supervisory union’s stance leaves students vulnerable to outsiders. Others said their children are wary of changing in front of the opposite sex, regardless of gender identity.

DeNova referenced Vermont’s guidelines on bullying, hazing and harassment, which mandates all schools provide safe learning environments free of discrimination. She said the statement intended to educate the school community on gender identity.

“That’s a big challenge, to create a culture,” she said, one that will require both parents and school leaders.

Essex parent Paul Campo said this is why he feels CCSU is rushing its decision. DeNova responded, citing state law once again before asserting her motivation goes beyond that.

“I’m also following my moral compass to do what’s right for all students,” she said.

Campo understands state and federal pressure but said the decision came off as “ultra [politically correct] and a tyranny of the minority.”

“Do you do right for a few, or do you do right for as many as possible?” he said.

DeNova assured CCSU schools will ensure children who are uncomfortable for any reason have access to private, single-use bathrooms. Issues will be dealt with on a case-by-case basis, she said.

Kaley Smith, who said CCSU tried to implement the change without notifying parents before the school year, sent numerous emails rallying parents to the meeting.  She said her daughter is “horrified at the thought” of changing in front of a boy.

DeNova said it was difficult to hear all CCSU students don’t feel safe.

“It will require all of us to work together to create that level of safety, and that comes with education,” she said.

CCSU’s statement references a mandate from the Obama administration that threatened to withhold federal funding from non-compliant schools. After 13 states challenged the directive in a lawsuit, a federal judge in Texas issued a nationwide injunction deeming it isn’t enforceable until the lawsuit makes its way through the courts.

Some parents thought this should be enough to hold off on the change. Others offered suggestions on how to implement it.

Laura Campo, a nurse with two daughters in CCSU schools, said transgender students should need documentation of their “medical condition.”

She said the high school required her daughter, who has celiac disease, to provide a doctor’s note before it would provide gluten-free food.

“They should be mandated to have a letter from their provider that says, ‘I am transgender,’” Laura Campo said. “If they don’t have those letters, they should not have these accommodations.”

In an interview with The Reporter earlier this month, DeNova said CCSU has no policy requiring transgender students to “register” with their schools.

“Nor should there ever be,” she said.

Wren House, an EHS 11th-grader who identifies as gender queer, pushed back at some parents’ concerns.   

House said transgender people are more likely to be assaulted or bullied than to commit such acts in bathrooms.

A 2013 study by the UCLA School of Law backs up House’s claim. It surveyed 93 transgender and gender nonconforming people living in Washington, D.C. in 2008 and 2009. Sixty-five of the respondents, or 70 percent, reported either being denied access to or verbally harassed in bathrooms.

Eight of the 93 interviewed reported they’d been physically assaulted in one.

More than 200 municipalities and 18 states protect transgender access to bathrooms with non-discrimination laws, according to the National Task Force to End Sexual and Domestic Violence Against Women, a nationwide coalition of over 200 organizations.

There’s been no rise in sexual violence or other public safety issues due to these laws, the coalition wrote in a statement this April.

“Assaulting another person in a restroom or changing room remains against the law in every single state,” the coalition wrote.

Patty LaRose Kent, the only parent who didn’t criticize CCSU’s stance, referenced safety in a different way.

“I’m more concerned about my daughter on a date … than I am about of her being attacked in a bathroom,” she said. Her daughter is a rising senior at the high school.

LaRose Kent said she fears more for her niece, a transgender woman, than her own daughter.

“I can’t imagine what she goes through having to use a public bathroom,” she said.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here